Stephanie's Italian Restaurant

Let me start with this we were at Fat Fish and saw Stephanie's sign. Not one time but two times we see the sign. We go to Google look at the pics, reviews and menu. Stephanie's is a place go and so freaking glad we did.

One it's not a restaurant it's your kitchen and your dining room. Why I say that cause it's cozy yet elegant. You feel at home once you step in that's an awesome feeling and they nailed it.

Stephanie's is a BYOB and our amazing server Ms. Michelle was tremendous. Warm bread comes to the table with butter and flavored olive oil. Ms. Stephanie's tells us the appetizer specials I guess. Wife ordered the fresh mozzarella with roasted peppers and tomatoes. Stuffed rice balls with beef and cheese in a vodka sauce also ordered.

Ms. Michelle told us the specials which to our surprise we ordered from the special. Maryland blue crab stuffed ravioli in a vodka sauce is what my Wife ordered. I on the other hand ordered flounder stuffed with crab on sautéed spinach in a lemon sauce. Hot AMN that flounder dish had my complete focus. Seasoned perfect the flounder was the lemon sauce with a touch of fresh garlic. Man Chef you put your foot in that meal. Stuffed and happy my Wife and I were. Ms. Michelle awesome server Chef phenomenal Stephanie's is a World Class Italian Restaurant

We dined outside which is decorated beautifully. Staff is wonderful. The food is fabulous.. we shared the arugula salad special, I had the lobster raviolis, my friend had scallop and crab stuffing special, I finished with the berries w/ cream.. make reservations! BYOB..

Fantastic dining experience! Our waiter was amazing and knowledgeable about the dishes. You could tell how much pride he took in the restaurant which is easy to understand why after having a full meal here. We ordered the fried zucchini as a starter. It came out piping hot and was excellent. So was the sauce that comes with it. For our entrees we got the spaghetti carbonara, although we substituted for rigatoni, and the Chicken Calabrese. Both came fresh out of the kitchen, were hot and delicious. The only thing I didn’t like is that they have carpeting, but I’ll get over that because the place is soooo good! I can’t wait to eat at Stephanie’s again in the near future. What a gem!

Stephanie‘s has excellent food at reasonable prices. Manager Michelle Iansito provides excellent service—efficient, friendly, and very willing to ensure customer satisfaction. I am a lifelong diner in differing types of restaurants in US and abroad, and I would go the extra mile to eat here!

Great little place for Italian food, byob. I’ve been going here for years and it doesn’t disappoint!

Update: went back again this past weekend and ITS STILL SO GOOD!

I decided to go here for my birthday to try their Fiocchi and they did not disappoint! The service was wonderful and the Fiocchi was even more delicious than I expected. It had a perfectly sweet/savory pear & cheese stuffing with white wine sauce. I found the light lemony sauce particularly complimenting to the (deliciously) dense cheesy fiocchi. I only wish I had more to enjoy for leftovers.

Just an overall wonderful experience. We made a last minute reservation for 6 and were accommodated immediately. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable. The food was great, quintessential Italian. Great desserts! Can’t wait to go back!

Fabulous early birthday celebration for my uncle. Incredible food, service & atmosphere! Our server Michelle was top notch with amazing recommendations, Veal Chop, Sea Scallops, Fiocchi, Warm Toffee Bundt Cake and Apple Streusel just to highlight a few. Definitely a go to for lunch and dinner.

The food is very, very good. the staff is very friendly. I absolutely loved it

Went for dinner with a group of six, was totally impressed with the food and service. We had a mix of appetizers, the rice balls in vodka sauce were amazing, best I have ever eaten. I had the triple parm for dinner, chicken/veal/shrimp it was delicious, I couldn't finish which is a rarity for me. Everyone at our table enjoyed all their food. Great dining experience!

Recommended by friends. They were right. Food and service was outstanding. Large portions. Ceasar salad served chilled. Chicken parmigiana was hot and delicious. Cheese cake with strawberries was scrumptious. Our waitress was friendly. Loved Stephanie's!🎉👍

Good food and service at a reasonable price. About 50pp.

Stephanie's is wonderful cozy restaurant with friendly staff and great food. The restaurant itself is clean and inviting. We sat inside although the outdoor dining space was very appealing as well. The food was delicious. Our server was attentive to all our needs. Great daily specials. Freshly made food. I cant say enough good things about this restaurant. First impressions are everything. I highly recommend this restaurant, you will not be disappointed. By the way, the pricing is very fair for the size of the plates and the superior quality of the food. Yum!

Not only was the food delicious yesterday, the service provided by Michelle to our table of 9 was outstanding, exceeding all expectations. She was polite, professional and dedicated to enhancing our dining experience. She made the day very special for our Birthday Guest!
For most of us, it was our first time at this restaurant but it certainly won’t be our last.

Ordered for the first time tonight (takeout). Had a slight miscommunication (I take part the blame for). The women was nice about it. Will definitely be back. Great food and wife thought it was great as well!

You should definitely give this a try. Their food is amazing. We've been going here for years.

I’ve been on a mission looking for the best chicken parm dinner in NJ. This place just took the #1 spot. Great owners and staff. Love the ambiance outside. Price is great!! Thank you for letting us sit without a reservation also. Stephanie’s mom runs a tight ship. This is my new favorite spot. .

After discovering this place on seamless as well as an recommendation from an coworker, my boyfriend and I decided to try it and came here to celebrate our anniversary. Wow! The food is absolutely fantastic. The food tastes amazing, and absolutely authentically Italian. It is now my favorite place to go for an nice Italian restaurant, so if you are looking for an authentic nice Italian restaurant then look no further! We will be coming back on special occasions. What an an wonderful experience!

Enjoyed the most delicious meal of my life at Stephanie’s last night. Appetizer of 3 colors of cauliflower baked with breadcrumbs and grated cheese, followed by entree of Fresh pasta in a magnificent vodka sauce (what was in there??) and dessert of pistachio gelato served with strawberries and whipped cream. I’m not much of a foodie so I was surprised at how “over the moon” this meal sent me. Kudos to the staff for accommodating our request to sit outside near the fountain and much appreciation for the gracious service. Wow.

I had a private party there of 50 people. The establishment is charming, quaint, and has class! The Italian food that was served was exquisite!!! The service was perfect, two extremely wonderful servers. The manager Michelle was so helpful and pleasant, and so were the owners. You will absolutely love everything about this restaurant!! And it's a BYOB!!!