Antimo's Pizzeria

Was not a planned stop for the Pizza Hunters App, Hunting the Best Slice of Pizza, but thankfully the Pizza Gods sent us to this amazing Pizzeria. Two women behind the counter in a Male dominated industry deliver great customer service with a great slice of Pizza. Using the basic formula for success with fresh ingredients, homemade pizza with Love. Every bite delivers great taste with homemade sauce, grande cheese and a crust that has been in the family for generations. This can be one of the best pizzas in Randolph in 2019, we shall see when the final ratings come out. Just look at the photos, this Pizza speaks to you. The women have so much passion for Pizza that they have raised the bar in the Industry. I really cannot wait to get back to this place. Thank You for such a great visit. You are the Best.

They have always had the best pizza in my opinion around this area. Also will do simple things like me loving my cheesesteaks on garlic bread. Some other local places will not do that. Antimo’s is by far my favorite and, the dinners are excellent

Searching around the area for pizza 2 places came up I decided to stop here . I was met by the owner on her own making pizza , garlic knots and a few more things . What a hard working woman. The pizza was amazing , the garlic knots amazing . My coworkers loved their meals . She chatted with us for a little bit , gave a little history , and how she takes pride in what she does and what comes out that kitchen and oven . Definitely recommend this place . Keep doing a great job and thanks for the great customer service . See you soon !!!

My favorite of the pizza places close to my house. In addition to their pizza being very good, their chicken Parm is delicious and I've also had their cheesesteak which was quite good.

Love Antimos. Sausage pizza is killer. The ladies running the place are great and the place has a nice,family vibe.

Amazing food have had the pizza, pizza rolls, Cheesesteak wrap and they all are amazing. The Garlic knots though are the greatest! Everyone that works here treats you like you are part of their Jersey family.

Very nice, great quick bite before going to State theatre !!

Owned by real Italians with amazing talent! Some of the best pizza I have had in a long time. I brought a New Yorker here who said their food was better than most of the pizza in NYC! I take that as high praise. The staff is really friendly, the restaurant is small and cozy, and the bathrooms were clean and tidy.

Great place! We went to grab a slice and ended up getting a whole pie. They ran out of Sicilian but the grandmas pizza was just as good, and the crust was nice and crispy! Also the sweet and spicy wings were fresh and so delicious and crispy. Definitely a great experience and would go back again after playing golf!

Amazing pizza, and the BEST marinara sauce I have ever had! It is the recipe of the owners Grandmother and it is outstanding! A real New York style pizza, not a shortened Jersey version. Consistent and delicious every time!

As someone who grew up in NYC and great pizza was easy to find , I can say that it's been really challenging to find a pizzeria in Morris Country that's close to NYC quality - until I tried Antimos. They are from Brooklyn so they know a thing or two about good pizza. The sauce to cheese ratio is perfect, and the crust is amazing. The staff is also hard working and friendly. I'd recommend this place to anyone looking to upgrade their pizza experience in the area. You won't be disappointed!

These folks are a staple of the community. The owners are superb human beings and they pay attention to customers' needs. The food is great and the location is perfect for commuting families.

Just stopped in to get a gift certificate as a move in meal gift for a closing… had to grab a slice of the sausage that had just come out of the over… worth every bite!!! So glad I stopped here for the gift certificate… thin crispy crust, gooey cheese and the sausage was perfect!

Great food and a great family run restaurant.

Grandma’s pie is fabulous with fresh mozzarella.

Their calzones are amazing and I generally don’t really like calzones.

And their regular pies are great as well.

Support Local. Eat at Antimos.

Sanjay.

Amazing service and prices. Their pizza is fresh, delicious, and cooked in a timely manner. Definitely one of the best Italian places near by in my opinion.

The owners were super nice and attentive! We brought over 20 people on a Saturday night and we all had really good treatment. The food was hot, quick and delicious. The prices weren't too bad either, definitely want to come back!

Seriously the BEST pizza place in Randolph. Their cheese pizza is to die for. Thin crispy crust, perfect cheese to sauce ratio, and the mozz cheese is REAL and doesn't gunk up like most places.

In my opinion, the crust makes or breaks the pizza...and Antimo's doesn't disappoint! Crispy on the outside...airy and doughy on the inside. I recommend the eggplant parm slice!

I’ve been to so many pizza places in Jersey and this is the BEST. Owners were the realist people you’ll ever meet. 10/10

Great pizza and friendly service. Excellent variety too. Nice atmosphere to just relax and enjoy the food.