Bagels Your Way Cafe

nice people! on top of there orders average food .

It’s a Saturday morning so I knew it would be super busy. Called and had to call back a few times since it kept saying “user is busy”. Expected someone to answer and rush me through my order but instead I got the kindest gentleman who was so nice answer the phone. He asked how he could help me and told me he was on the other line and asked if I could hold. Absolutely. After about a minute he got back on the phone and continued being nice and very professional. When I picked up my order there was a line out the door. It felt like it should’ve been complete mayhem but everything ran so smoothly. I asked the gentlemen manning the cash register if this is where I picked up phone orders. He kindly asked me to hold on one second while he finished up ringing someone else. He asked me my name, told me my total and I gave him my card. He thanked me and told me to have a great day. I have a new favorite bagel place and this store will be my “go to” from now. Thank you!

I love this place use to be in here like every day when I worked at Staples before it became tj Maxx. Carl and his son joey run a solid business, best egg sandwiches and plenty of cream cheese on a bagel whenever you order from this establishment. Amazing food 👍

One of the best if not the best bagel/ Deli I’ve had the pleasure to have gotten my food from, the crew is fast and the line is always out the door so. Thank you guys for a great job. Respectfully,
Robert G Melvin Sr.

Me and my dad went today it was so good the service was fast and my dad enjoyed his roll and I enjoys my bagel

absolutely amazing food, perfectly cooked and delicious, will definitely recommend. fries deserve a michelin star.

First time here. I’ve read so many reviews while sitting here having my breakfast. Conflicting. Interesting how different people can have totally opposite experiences. I did pick up that some aren’t happy unless they have something to complain about….and that some negative ones seem legit.

Must be my lucky day because my initial thought as I entered and got in line was that it was a lively, positive vibe. I didn’t witness anything unpleasant. Everyone was friendly and my food was very good. On the pricey side, yes. But the traffic coming in and out tells me it’s worth it. Lots of people behind the counter. Sometimes that can be challenging with communication but my wait was minimal and my order was perfect. I’ll be back for sure and see if I get lucky again :)

Amazing breakfast!! Love the selection!!! Great staff , baseball team came in for breakfast and the team there was very helpful and awsome!!! When at the Island gotta hit the Bagwla your way!!!

Went today with my daughter and ordered 2 egg sandwiches, I’ve got to say that my order was spot on even though the place was really busy. The staff was friendly and courteous. I can see why the place was busy because, the food and service was excellent. I definitely will be coming back quite often…

I can't understand the negative reviews other that the fact that "you can't please everyone". We're here nearly every weekend for bagels or egg sandwiches, NEVER had a problem! And we have tried many bagel stores over time, this is the best!

Very friendly and accommodating staff. Attentive and great food. If you want a real Long Island deli experience this is your place !

I went here to get my iced coffee one day and it was delicious! I always order from here through Uber eats now because they’re the only ones in this town with really delicious coffee! And the add ons were awesome! They take directions really well!!! The staff is also super nice!

Stopped in before closing, so grill was off & I got a toasted bagel and a 1/4 pound of vegetable tuna. It was delcious and my bagel was toasted & buttered perfectly.
I will definitely be back

I cam home for my Mom's 85th birthday celebration. I went to Bagels Your Way Cafe Medford and enjoyed the delicious breakfast. I need to bring them to Atlanta Ga. Service was fast and the food was delicious . I miss this so much about NY.

Every time I have went in for breakfast the staff is very friendly and the food is delicious. My favorite bagel shop on my way to work. Love the online order ahead option 😊

Great bagels and sandwiches. I plan on trying the batman ( egg sandwich with a chicken cutlet) and superman (egg sandwich with a burger patty) on my next visits. This place is always busy which is an obvisious reflection of the quality of the product they put out Aka the food.

Pretty good bagels and other tasty things, lots of options.

Read some of the reviews. Take them with a grain of salt.

People complaining about price. Could always go down the road to a McDonald's. It's cheaper but the quality isn't the same.

I had a bagel with cream cheese. A bagel sandwich. About $16 I'll pay that all day.

Always great and fairly quick service, especially with how busy they get. They offer vegan options! Bagles are the softest. It's my favorite bagle place in Suffolk County.

Great bagels. Fast service and friendly staff. Been coming here since 2007. Same great tasting bagels. Wide variety of bagels, too. For the area, they are the best bagels. Enjoy!