Goomba Johnny's Pizzeria

Hands down an amazing pizzeria! Food is always on point, even with our family's big order with multiple requests! Their vodka sauce is our favorite!

The staff is always so kind and helpful when I come here. And the food is delicious. My husband and I love coming here.

Been coming here for almost 20 years! Always good food and friendly service! We have them deliver often as well and on the rare occasions when something is forgotten, they always make it right. Highly recommend!

Excellent pizza I have been coming here for a while I live close now and ever since I won't go anywhere else the employee named Pedro that I found very very rude that's why I almost always get delivery

Great food with a hard working crew. Have been coming here for years and hate when I have to eat at someone’s house and it’s not goomba’s. Pizza, specialty slices, hero’s, etc all great!

Our favorite delivery place make sure you get the goomba Johnny chicken cutlet garlic fresh mozzarella hero the best yum yum yum

Goomba Johnny's is pretty good with great delivery service. 5-22-24 Ordered a pie from Johnny goomba, best pie I've had in a while! 6-9-24 Just ordered another pie not quite as good as the last one I guess it depends who's cooking it

Don't let the place fool you, tucked away in a tiny strip of stores with limited seating, but, the food is excellent and the crew working there are great people

So good. Never a disappointment. Even at the end of the night they throw down a satisfying pie.

We get all our hot food catering from goomba we love it fair price and great food!!!

My family has ordered off the catered food menu for most of our big family events and they never disappoint! Food is amazing! They always go above and beyond. Every dish from eggplant, to chicken, to sausage has always been delicious! They send a ton of garlic knots that’s are so big and really tasty! We have also ordered there pizza and that is really good as well!

I have loved these boys since they took over the area, but I have to say.... they definitely pumped up the quality and richness of taste....they are cutting zero corners!! People... try the sauce!! Are you kidding me? Effin' OUTSTANDING! The meatballs are ALWAYS a favorite. Can't go wrong with pizza--by the way, pizza is for Mondays and Tuesdays too!! Look, I could literally write a book about the quality and quantity of portions, entagled with taste and elegance, and always as speedy of a delivery as possible (look guys, they're popular!! Sometimes it may take a little longer....but it will always be hot!). But......it's your turn to leave a review...

#38

Gommba Johnny's catered my daughter sweet16, the food was amazing, everyone loved it. Thank you,

Ordered from here this weekend and the food was delicious. The Chicken Francese pie & the Fiesta pie were both great, the fried raviolis were huge, not like little mini ones most places usually give, and the wings were great too. Can't wait to be back in LI to order again (wish they could deliver to Queens!)

As always when I come home to visit this is my first place I have to get food from. I had the chicken with pesto tonight and other family members got the penne vodka and pizza and pasta with sauce
Fried ravioli is the best anywhere.
Absolutely delicious with amazing service.
My family has used them for catering as well and absolutely excellent service and food every time.

Best Italian in town and surrounding towns. It's not just a pizza place, although the pizza is fantastic, but the other food they make is delicious. Everything I've tried here has been perfect. It's a little food place with big restaurant quality and the portions are large. They have great specials and deals. It's worth a try, you'll forget any other place around. They deliver as well

When my family is visiting from Florida this is there go to place for takeout. So I make a phone call and we always get the Lobster Bisque Soup, Garlic Knots, and a variety of Pizzas. OMG, absolutely delicious! We love the owner Dominick and staff. Everyone is welcome and friendly. They have the best coupons. We highly recommend!

All I can say is Awesome love Goomba pizzeria!!! My favorites are Goomba Slice Delicioso!!, and the Chicken Bruschetta, Grandma's Pie Mmm love it Very Friendly Staff Never disappointed brought My Mom in to try the Bruschetta Now she brings her friends. Now your our Goomba only in our house Thank you for sharing your Delicious food!! Thank you Mrs Donna Sellitto and Craig Sellitto see you soon.

Very kind and caring employees, familial atmosphere. And the food is delicious, i recommend the chicken alfredo pizza. Definitely coming back here!

Best pizza I’ve tried in the area. We’ve been here four years and we finally got our pizza place. We had a bit of a snafu with SLICE. The people at slice promised that they would take care of the refund but ultimately made Johnny’s work for it. I don’t think that’s very fair. I really hate app ordering. I think that adding a middle man just makes more room for issues. But I also understand why our local places sign on. It’s a new age. Anyway, Goomba Johnny’s assured us that their in house delivery is on point and I believe them. It’s a good hearted family owned place with really tasty food. Definitely worth a bite!