Scileppi's at The Old Stone Church

Excellent and amazing! 😊.Food was fresh and the lasagna was huge. Lots of desert selections. Going to try every dish the food is perfection. I don’t like cooking so I do eat out everyday. This place is my favorite and the best!!!

A fairly interesting small Italian restaurant that was converted from an old Catholic Church in old town Castle Rock. The menu is fairly standard with pastas and pizza as main dishes. Our pizza was good and arrived at our table piping hot. The eggplant fries were also good without being too filling. Our server Jacob was attentive and helpful at all times. There was an indoor parking lot that is open to the public next door. During warmer weather you could have Alfresco dining outdoor too.

I normally don’t say this but “WOW!” I am a New Yorker whom transplanted to Colorado and for 3 years have been searching for a true slice of pizza. I FOUND IT!!! Thank you gentlemen, as I ordered chicken parmigiana as a back up and although great wish I ordered more pizza.

I will be back! If you are anywhere near ( Pueblo, Fort Collins…drive to a Castle Rock as it is worth the drive)

I cannot thank you enough for redeeming Colorado pizza.

Great LITTLE Italian place!!! We had Chicken Marsala, Clams with Linguini, and cheesy garlic bread. Everything was exceptional

Amazing service, great food. Gson wants to go back for 11 th bday

Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Food: 4.5
Wine & Drinks: 4.5
Bathrooms: 3
Price Expectations: $60 per person
Tip: 25%

My wife and I went there for our Valentine's Day dinner. We loved the atmosphere and the service. The food was amazing, mostly. And we really enjoyed our time there. You definitely need to set a reservation. Do not come in thinking you will get a table within an hour. We knew it was going to be pricey, so we planned in advance. Overall, we really enjoyed our experience.

The food was delicious, the service was perfect and the atmosphere was amazing. No wonder they're packed on a Tuesday night! I had the chicken piccata 🤤 and it was so delicious. My husband had the gnocchi and the sauce was so yummy 😋 and the appetizer burrata was so creamy. Worth the price!! Loved the church atmosphere. Definitely recommend! 🤩👍🏻

My husband and I stopped here on our way home from Denver. To start we had Gavin as our server and he alone was amazing. For drinks I had a glass Moscato and my husband an old fashioned. We got the bread and oil. The bread with the seeds on it wasn't our favorite. The other bread was good. We ordered crab cakes which was yummy. The breading was perfect and crunchy. Inside didn't taste fishy at all, the drizzle was good as well. Next we both ordered the lobster ravioli and let me tell you how good that was. I ended up taking mine home cause I wanted it for lunch the next day. My husband and i were stuffed. We ended up ordering dessert to go.

A really unique experience. This restaurant is in an old church with all the stained glass windows & old wood.

Beautiful, small & it was bustling! Not a quiet place.
The meatball appetizer was hearty & tasty for $8

The marinara sauce was delicious and so was the tomato basil soup.

Wonderful dinner in an old Catholic Church.
Everyone enjoyed their meals. We had five people - we ordered Lobster Ravioli, Stuffed Shrimp, Chicken Marsala, Chicken Piccata and the charcuterie board. Two of us added salads to our dinner for $5 each.
Fantastic, friendly service. I highly recommend it!

This was our first time here. We loved it. Our server was the best. The calamari was delicious. The garlic bread was great. I had Stuffed shrimp as did my husband. My daughter had the spaghetti bolognese and my son in law had the linguini carbonara. Everything was delicious. The atmosphere was great. I can't wait to go back.

Loved the pizza. Tall Matt took care of us. Should be even better after renovations.

The eggplant fontina was outstanding. Just like the waitress said. The pasta was average, but I don't usually eat pasta. I just had to taste it.
Small quaint pizza place. We had an enjoyable long lunch.

We came here on a Saturday night, it was busy, but well worth the wait!
We were told it would be about an hour and a half wait; ended up only being an hour.
The environment is super cool, I love how you can still see some of the original bricks inside the church. They kept the menu in theme with the restaurant being in a church (garden of Eden, Old and New Testament, etc).

Our waiter was Lee and he was very knowledgeable and super welcoming!

My recommendation- start with dessert first. The cannolis here are AMAZING! Hands down one of the best cannolis I’ve ever eaten. Perfect texture and sweetness.

The portions here are huge- one other reason to start with dessert first or you won’t have any space for it! We ordered the Gnocchi and it was delicious! We ended up splitting it and still had left overs.

I wish we lived closer since there’s so much I want to come back to try!

This is one of our favorite restaurants in Castle Rock…excellent Italian cuisine…the Braised Short Rib Ravioli is exquisite…phenomenal service….and love the atmosphere! Great vibe.

Scileppi's at The Old Stone Church is a great spot for fine dining or simple comfort foods. It can get a little crowded at times so be sure to check and see when the busy times are using the map view.

Prices are on par with other eateries in the area and the food is very tasty. Portions are a beyond fair for what you pay and I've never had an issue my food or experienced a bad meal.

This is definitely a spot to try at least once, chances are you'll be coming back again!

Have been trying to come here for years, but it's always very hard to get into. We came from a horrible day at DIA, and Jacob our server, totally turned the evening around with his outstanding service. The bread to start was delicious, we ordered a bottle of Scileppis family wine- outstanding and one of the best reds I've had in a long time in fun glasses :)

And then we moved on to our main. I head the sun dried tomato rigatoni as I am vegetarian, the other members in my party had gnocchi. Both were delicious. And of course we saved room for dessert. The tiramisu and crème brûlée was split with the table. But you HAVE to get the tiramisu.

I can't wait to come back for this great experience and really want to thank Jacob! It's such a wonder how they've turned this church into such a unique dining place. Such a creative concept and experience. We were here about a week and a half ago so it's a bit delayed, but that's how much the experience has stayed on my mind.

Now go get in line- they don't take reservations!

This was a wonderful place to celebrate Father's Day! The food was impeccable and the service incredible! The venue is beautiful with stained glass windows and dark wood but done in a modern, comfortable way. Indoor and outdoor seating is available as well as seating at the bar, which is modern and comfortable. We sat at a charming, cozy, two-person table right under a stained glass window. Our server, Gavin, started us with a taste of their homemade red wine which is sweet and dessert-like. We ordered warm, cheesey garlic bread, crusty with sesame seeds. Dippable in a fresh, bright tomato sauce. I enjoyed the gnocchi with Alfredo sauce, which had an unusual flavor, maybe nutmeg, bursting through. They were very soft and stuck to the roof of the mouth, but delicious comfort food. My husband enjoyed his chicken parmesan tremendously. Both meals made excellent leftovers later as serving sizes were quite generous. Honestly, the highlight of the meal was the creamy, fantastic cheesecake! Obviously homemade with love! Swooning! Best ever! Gavin was so fun and gracious and we had an awesome time!

I asked what they recommended to drink and they said the Italian margarita and it did Not disappoint!!!! So good! Great people working here too! Every one from host, to waitress, to bartender! Every one pitches in and helps check in, get water, etc. Bella is such a sweet heart and it was just a great experience. Thank you!

I love this place. I have been going here when I'm in town for many years. Stopped off of I-25 going towards Denver for 2 slices of pizza. Definitely worth it!

Because it's such an iconic and unique place, it makes a great lunch or dinner date spot.