Timothy's Pizza Kitchen

Love Timothy's!!! The penne ala vodka is fantastic, along with the pizza too! Meatball pie was soooo good!!! Thank you again!!!

The owner, Michael, is so nice and helpful in navigating my daughter’s egg allergy needs. Best local pizza and knots around!

This is a small pizzeria very humble and with very little fanfare. However the pizza itself is excellent with excellent quality ingredients.
New to the area and living very close by my wife and I were extremely hopeful that Timothy‘s would be good. We were pleased and I guess you could say relieved that the pizza is indeed excellent.
The owner and operator Michael is so hard-working so genuinely kind, a humble guy that you can’t help but root for an establishment like this.
There are many other pizzerias in the area and we’ve tried them all some of them a little bit more modern than Timothy‘s is. Yet time and time again my family tries out the pizzerias and says Timothy is still better.
Facts: They deliver locally. There is easy parking in the parking lot off the street right outside of the pizzeria. We especially love the garlic knots I always order a batch even if I have them the next day with a different meal.

He doesn’t mind me requesting ham and pineapple on my cheese slices 🙏🏻🍍

Hidden gem probably the best pizza on the north shore. I only wound up here because one of my riders had a drop off nearby (uber driver here). The slice I had was so good basil and mozzarella it was delicious. Will have to come back next time I'm in town.

Great old-fashioned pizza place-friendly & very small-town feel, & the pizza was fantastic!!

Yesterday my friends and I ordered a Grandma’s pizza with pepperoni and it was outstanding. We ate it while on a nearby beach at sunset and all agreed it was one of the best pizzas we recalled having!

Visiting from out of town and stopped by on our way to Vanderbilt museum and planetarium. Delicious perfect cheese pie! Absolutely perfect crisp yet dense crust and delicious sauce. Family meal deal was a steal with salad garlic knots 2 liter soda and pie for $23. Definitely recommend !!!

Great pizza as always, this is my son's favorite pizza place near us.

Great pizza! Love his sauce and sausage/peppers! Use him for catering all the time! It doesn't get any better. Thanks so much for always taking care of us!

Always a must. I used to stop here everyday and now I try to do so despite things being busier. Great pizza and very calming serene pizza place vibes.

Delicious pizza that you can get by the slice as well. Their buffalo chicken is the best!

Timothy's Pizzeria quickly became a family favorite as soon as we moved into the neighborhood. We typically go there at least once a week and Michael and his crew are phenomenal!

Excellent pizza here! Was looking forward to trying out a good New York style pizza while in town from Arizona and I found it!!

This place is a hole in the wall of Centerport! I had a delicious tomato n basil slice never had it before any where,it was delicious also had a cauliflower parmesan slice to die for if u love cauliflower, I definitely going back to get me a hall pie(sorry no pictures of the slices) but one won't be disappointed.

Great pizza, plump wings… all around good food!! must try.

Been going here for 5+ years. Always a great slice! Best of which in my opinion are Sicilian, grandma, and especially chicken parm slice.

Best pizza in the area. I travel 40 minutes to pick up some slices once a week. Friendly owner, fresh, handmade food.

Great food, cooked to order, with friendly customer service!

This place is amazing! The pizza was delicious.