Mill Pond House

Celebrated our anniversary with an excellent dinner there. The food was excellent, the view wonderful. We shared fish and the tuna dumpling special, both delicious and carefully crafted. The hostess was kind and helpful in enabling us to wait for a table on the deck but once seated, the table service unfortunately was indifferent. Nonetheless, the overall experience was worthwhile.

It had been a while since we came back the Mill Pond House. We had previously been here for my niece's communion, now it was my nephew's turn. Large setup, 2 tables, almost 15-20 people. The menu was prix fixe, which was fine. It was great to spend time with family and friends. I hope we can return and try the other items on the menu. The staff was super courteous and played along with our antics(nothing annoying). The AC was not working great that day and we all felt a bit heated... Hopefully this is resolved before it gets too hot.

Came in for my mother’s birthday. It was a big party and they sat us really fast. Food was great and portions really big. Big menu as well. The staffs were super great and attentive. Hopefully coming back soon

Enjoyed a wonderful anniversary dinner at Mill Pond House. We had the fried calamari, fra diavolo (there's also thai style) as a starter. They were lightly battered and nicely prepared. Very fresh and tasty. For our main course my wife ordered the branzino which came with sautéed spinach and I had the 12oz fillet mignon with mashed sweet potatoes. Both our dishes were perfectly cooked, flavorful and delicious. For dessert we had the banana bread pudding which comes with creme anglaise and vanilla ice cream, the perfect ending to a great meal. We were there on a Tuesday night, not too many people, very relaxed. Staff were attentive, but not overbearing, room temperature was just right and the ambience was very nice. Valet parking only (have cash handy for tip). Overall, a great dining experience.

Lovely setting on the water. Friendly service and great food. I had a strip steak that was perfectly grilled to medium. Sauteed spinach was also perfectly cooked. Only downside on this visit was their cappuccino machine was broken and the were out of while milk?!

Splendid Sunday afternoon at this majestic place. Great ambience, food, and service. From the valets to the maitre’d to the waiter (Rafael) to the bus staff.

It’s on the pricier end but so worth it. We drove about 1.5 hours from northern NJ.

Love this restaurant so much. The food is amazing, service 10/10, and the patio is beautiful, you will have a nice view of a lake. I definitely recommend this place for their lunch special 12-3pm.

Wife and I, first time here, and we enjoyed the place and food. The food was fantastic, delicious and fresh. We would definitely return, and I highly recommend eating there.

Always great! We have been here a many times previously and always enjoy. Last week we went again for dinner and had a wonderful time! The food is always delicious, however, I specifically wanted to write a review because our server and host were just amazing. We were seated inside right away.The drink menu is terrific, so unique and delicious. I mentioned to our server Brandon, that I have celiac. My husband and friends were shocked, without me even asking, he showed me which dishes I can order and be safe with. We ordered shrimp tempura for appetizer, Tuna Tar Tar, and the passion roll, presentation and taste work terrific. More importantly, Brandon made sure that the Tuna was gluten-free for me I didn’t even ask, because I knew not to eat the chips, but he came over with cucumber slices for me and the tuna and to make sure that I knew what not to eat, and what was cross contaminated. When I usually go here, I always order the Bronzino however, it was not on the menu, so I tried the Salmon, which was delicious & again just a beautiful presentation and the food was impeccable! The rest at my table, ordered seafood and pasta entrees, which they also loved. I highly recommend!

Service was a little too attentive? This is the worst thing I can say. The food, view atmosphere, and vibe are excellent. Be Ware: If you drive a manual transmission, there is valet parking.

Wonderful anniversary dinner. The octopus was seasoned well and tender while the buratta was well paired with grilled peaches. Next course was duck and seared tuna, both really delicious.

Really enjoyed the "outdoor" seating even during a hurricane!

Feedback: Steamed veggies had no flavor but good texture.

Ok I’m being very strict so I’d say food is ok, but to be fair, for being a restaurant in a small town is pretty good . View is unbeatable , portions are huge and prices are low (compared to Manhattan restaurants) . We did the prix fix menu for 35 dollars that includes an appetizer (which are huge), an entree and a dessert . I was stuffed and couldn’t even eat the dessert .
I will definitely come back. It was very romantic 🥰🥰🥰. Loved it .

What a cool place. Valet is on point. The hostess was friendly and knowledgeable, and she didn't rush us into sitting down anywhere even though we had a reservation. We waited at the hip little bar area and had a drink. The bartender was super nice, and the bar, although out of view of mill pond, has a great ambiance. The hostess was 100% correct in encouraging us to wait a few minutes. The table we got upstairs was AWESOME. What a great view. The wait staff was really friendly and the food was delicious. Thank you for making a special occasion for 2 unforgettable.

We got a table for six on the covered patio.
The Montauk sord fish was fresh and delicious.
Service was prompt and helpful.
Bathrooms were clean
Atmosphere was comfortable.
The menu was loaded with great options.
Everyone loved their meal!

Great food, service and a wonderful view of a beautiful pond! They have an extensive menu and terrific drink menu as well. One of my favorite spots. Especially on a nice sunny day!

Beautiful view, wonderful wait staff! Food was delicious and nicely presented. Drinks were amazing,as well! Our server was attentive and engaging. Had lunch on the deck, outside. Covered and very clean!

Hidden gem a must visit . Superb service staff . Great athmosphere and views . Food ar simply the best whatever you choose from the menus its delicious

Wonderful place to grab a quick bite or a dinner out. Great wine selections.

9 out of ten for me all was well but the lobster tail but perhaps next time it will be a ten from me. But the atmosphere service and meats were amazing. The price was fine and worth it for newcomers like myself.

Wonderful experience at this incredible restaurant! I brought my mother here for her 92nd birthday. Her birthday lunch began with a Scotch Manhattan. Beautifully blended and greatfully sipped! My mother had mussels in white wine sauce for her appetizer and for her main dish as well. Bread was delicious as well as the steak that was ordered. Our servers couldn't have been kinder!