Bagel Cafe

Delicious lunch. Fresh Turkey, Swiss, coleslaw and honey mustard sandwich, on a bagel instead of the panini for me, with side salad and a full pickle. Good stuff. Priced as most places nowadays. But it was worth the price
I saved some for later too. Thanks all! Tell 'em Barsnobs sent ya.

Bagel Cafe is my go to for catering. Randy and his team create the most beautiful platters and dishes! The displays are colorful and gorgeous and everything tastes delicious! Thank you guys for always being so reliable, timely and amazing! Highly recipe d for a family breakfast or catered event! Never disappointed!

Long Island Bagel Cafe is our go-to spot. The food is always delicious, the staff are friendly and always greet you with a smile and no matter if you’re making your coffee or sitting in the dining area, it is always stocked and clean! Donna, Drew and Bernie are just some of our favorite employees who make the best egg sandwiches! However, if you’re not in the mood for breakfast; there are a ton of different and delicious options to chose from daily!

So one sunday afternoon my wife and I stopped in and had the best bagel sandwiches ever! Mine, cranberry chicken salad on a toasted pumpernickel bagel, absolute delicious perfection, and hers a monstrous ham and cheese on an egg everything bagel, complete with mac salads and pickels and large Iced teas that we couldn't finish, its really alot of food. Place is super clean and comfortable, employees are very helpful and friendly. Cant wait for our next visit! Its very close to the walk trails next to Smithtown Library, so we'll be making this our regular stop from now on after walks. 5 stars easily, there is nothing bad about this place!

Been here several times. The food is great! Breakfast sandwiches and homemade iced tea. Most of the staff is very friendly and accommodating!

I go here often, today they accidentally messed up my sandwich so I went back. It was no big deal they are very busy and it happens. The person who made my sandwich when I went back deserves a raise, it’s scrumpdeli-omptious ( I had to make up my own word bc that’s how good). They are the best place around

Customer service top tier! Bagel so soft! Soup amazing! Great price! After this review I’m heading over there!

AWESOME! Bagels/Deli. There is a line for a reason. This place has great bagels. We are visiting from California. This is where we go for bagels and bagel sandwiches the NY way. I get the lox sandwich, cucumber side salad, pickel and coffee.

Friendly staffing from the time I walked in the door. I went there for muffins and they were fresh and delicious. One of my biggest requirements is excellent customer service and they passed with flying colors especially since I am a minority and the current climate in which we are in. If I could have giving ten stars I would have. Thank you, you guys are 👌awesome

They've stepped it up lately. Bagels do the trick, their scallion cream cheese is pretty good. Their sandwiches are delicious, breakfast or lunch. They also have cartons of eggs, bacon, salads, good sandwiches and other deli fare.

Outstanding experience. Staff is thorough and attentive to your needs. Food is always fresh and excellent. You may wait in line for a little while, but in the end, you get what you pay for. Which is superb.

This is my deli that I use at least three to four times a month. They never disappoint me and are always consistent! I especially love that they packout the side salad when you get a sandwich! Nowadays it's really hard to find a consistent deli and this is definitely one of them! I love 25 mins from this location and it's so worth the wait! I adore both their Breakfast and Lunch sandwiches! Also their Coffee is always top notch! clCant say enough great things about this place!

The bagels are delicious and the price is definitely worth it. For a place that gets crowded fast, the staff remains friendly and gets things moving as smoothly as possible. If you haven't been here yet, I recommend giving it a shot.

My wife and I recently had my daughters sweet 16 catered from LI Bagel Cafe in Nesconset. From the start of planning, the communication with the manager Randy was amazing! Every detail was paid close attention to, from the amount of food to order, 100 plus people, to the quality of food, we were very pleased and impressed. I would get random texts at 9 PM, "did you remember this"? It was a pleasure dealing with someone ho cared so much. We usually make some of the food ourselves and order certain things, but we felt completely comfortable leaving all of it to them and we were not sorry. The food was delivered on time, and was absolutely fresh, hot and delicious. As soon as I tasted the first bite, I texted the manager immediately and told him how happy everyone was.
We also had a 6 foot bacon, sausage, egg and cheese delivered the next morning for out of town guests that was amazing!
I can't say enough about the entire experience, I would definitely recommend having the LI Bagel Cafe cater your next party, no matter how big or small. I sure will.
Thank you- Rick

I had a great experience at Bagel Cafe. I was helped by a very kind blonde woman. The place was clean and very welcoming. Great interior design. Food was absolutely delicious. Great menu selection. These workers clearly work very hard and this is a great business.

The bagels here are delicious and their coffee is good too. Large variety of cream cheese and salads. Service is efficient. I go here every weekend. My only suggestion is that they have 1 or 2 employees work the grill while the others work the counter to keep the line moving. Sometimes line wraps around the store and wait is long.

My son was getting married in Long Island. I wanted to make my guest comfortable. I live in Staten Island. I know nothing about LI. I was staying in a hotel and wanted to provide food for the groomsmen in the morning. Then for in between church and reception. Then breakfast the next morning. I was recommended to Randy of Bagel Cafe. He assured me that he had everything under control and things would go smoothly. Well the food was outstanding more than enough for my guest. My guest raved about the food. The men he sent to set up were fantastic to. The breakfast was a great variety of food. And lots of it. So I would highly recommend Bagel Cafe. Best bagels ever.

Picked up catering for a brunch party and everything was so delicious. Portions were very generous and I had yummy leftovers for days. Very thankful I found this establishment. Keep up the good work!

Best BECSP I've had since leaving NY! Nice deli, great service & excellent food!

I go there on a regular basis. Sometimes “to go” and other times to sit and hang with my daughters. The place is always clean and Anna and the staff are always friendly. I also used them for catering when my mother passed and they went out of there way to ensure I had a stress free experience.