John Anthony's of Valley Stream

Gluten free pizza...dough is just OK. The cauliflower gluten free choice is better, but what really makes them, is the wonderful sauce and cheese.

Our company regularly orders pizza from here, and it's exceptionally delicious. The taste of a regular slice is so so sooo good!

Tried BBQ chicken pizza, pepperoni pizza and grandma pie. All were delicious. I would definitely recommend the BBQ chicken first. So good. I have also tried their regular cheese pizza, but I was not as impressed with it. I have also taken out one slice of vodka pizza, and I didn't like it after they reheated it. I would recommend the other types of pizza pies here and would recommend getting a whole fresh pie instead of having them reheat a slice already made before.

One of my favorite Pizza spots in Nassau County. Yeah, its close to my house, but they’ve also always done right by my family. Good service and good food. Pizza, Ziti, Stromboli, all of it top notch.

Just started to go here and so far love their takeout food.

They were able to make a really good "no cheese" pizza for me.

My daughter was invited here for a birthday get together the other day so I decided to order yesterday as she liked it. I ordered pizza, garlic bread, and Calamri and it was all amazing! This is the best spot yet that i have gotten pizza from. We will be ordering all the time from here. As well its not as pricey as all the other pizza shops around.

I’ve been buying pizza from Tony & Paul for years upon years. Their food is always fresh and consistent every time. I enjoy their regular pizza which is never shy of cheese, crispy and a sweet sauce that’s addicting. Also, the best Philly cheesesteaks around hands down!!! Never have been disappointed! Don’t forget the garlic knots!!!

Pizza is fantastic, we order the regular cheese pie from time to time. We also heard from multiple sources about their angelic cheeseburger and in an effort to make our own decision, it’s been finalized that Pizza Express has the best damn cheeseburger around here! Keep up the great work and don’t change a thing guys!

This is a nice local place. The pizza is good, but the hero sandwiches are exceptional.

Very nice staff too.

Enjoy!

We’ve been frequenting John Anthony’s for lunch this year and have been greeted with friendliness & delicious food every time. Recently I took advantage of a deal they have - buy 2 trays, get 1 free - for a family party about 20-25 minutes away. Anthony delivered the food promptly & it was yummy - all our guests raved about the chicken & broccoli, eggplant parmesan, and sausage & peppers. Visit them today & taste for yourself!

The owners and staff are super friendly. They have, by far, the best pizza around.

I wasn't going to write a review on just one item purchased... We had the baked clam... 2 thumbs up... meat pizza... 2 thumbs up... Sicilian pie... very good . white pizza with sausage... 2 thumbs up... all in all, the food has good flavor, the pizza has a nice crust... i did have a calzone... good flavor it had sausage ... also good, the ricotta cheese was creamy they did use a pre-cooked calzone so the dough was crispier than i wanted but no bad.

They had a seating in the back that is much larger than the front area. They Whole Wheat Carribean Wrap was good but it didn't taste Carribean. The food was served to me in aluminum pans instead of plates but that made it simple to take what I had leftover home. They let me be seated without having me pay and much to my chagrine we discovered I was short of funds. They didn't stress but just gave me a significant discount. So I owe them and hope to be back to make up for the shortage one day.

I've been searching for a good pizza place that delivers in my area fir 2 years, and I finally found one! The food is excellent, fast delivery and great pricing. Congrats on the new place, keep up the good wirk!

Best pizza I ever had and really good customer service 10/10

Order from here often. Pizza is always very delicious. We love that the pizza comes in "mini" sizes and we can order different types!

This really is the best pizza around. I eat here too much.

This place have the best pizza I think in valley stream. I probably eat here at least twice a week and enjoy their food every time, keep up the good work.

Good service and good food. Pizza, Ziti, Stromboli, all of it top notch.