Sugarboy Bakery Cafe

My family and I always get our custom cakes from SugarBoy Bakery. They make quality cakes and never disappoint on their execution! They always exceed our expectations and on top of their beautifully designed cakes, they taste delicious. Would recommend their cakes for any special occasion.

Love this place!! They have done wonderful and memorable cakes for us!

Thanks to Steph and her colleagues, I was able to present the best cake to one of my best friends. Whatever idea you have for a cake, please come here. They will make it come to life.

Sugarboy is my go to for a cup of coffee since moving to the neighborhood. There is always a fresh pot of hot coffee to look forward to on my walk home. As the other reviews reflect Sugarboy is THE SPOT for creative cakes and classic baked goods in the area, no question. multi generation family owned-they put heart and soul into everything they make. Sugarboy is a gem. No lie when i say the only thing sweeter then the cakes is the customer service-so welcoming-i could stand and chat with y'all forever, thanks and bless

Love how super helpful the cashier was, and very friendly. Definitely will be getting my cakes and cupcakes made there. The price for my cake was 175$ but it was worth it because the look and taste was amazing.

Expert and quality cake designer. They are very helpful in setup your cake design. I highly recommend. Also try their other cake and pastry

LOVED IT. My family’s a big fan of this place and we just discovered it! The cakes are so aesthetically ✨pleasing✨ and It was so yummy. The only downside is that it has a lot of cream/icing. Personally, it didn’t matter to me because of how tasty the cake was.

Immediate friendly service. As this was my first visit, everything was set up like a normal bakery glistening in what some say is egg wash. So, I went with the personal size carrot cake, the strawberry shortcake and the almond pound cake (the greed in me 🙈😂).
Pleasantly surprised everything was so moist/fresh so much so no sharing so that it last. A must visit if you're in the area...perfecto!

I always get my cakes from this location. They are fresh and delicious. The guava and tres leches mix is my favorite. They are able to customize beautiful cakes for you within 20 mins. Very creative and tasteful.

Stopped in today on a whim to get a couple of cupcakes for my kids and the woman behind the counter was so sweet! The girls loved the cupcakes as well; will be stopping in again!

Is my mother birthday she is special
The costumer service is 100%
The cake is delicious.
In the must important my mother loved
Thanks thousands

Best cakes and pastries I purchased my wedding cake here many years ago and ever since it the place tho go. For every occasion their cakes has been the best. It never disappoints.

I have never been so happy with my son birthday cake. Thank you ladies for making sure my cake was done as I asked. The texture of my cake was delicious and the illustrious was made to the T. Thank you.

Ordered my cake last minute because my other person had fell through. I found them via google and I'm happy I did, the cake was good, I had a different flavor in every tier and it came out exactly how I wanted it. They are pretty expensive but it was worth it.

One of my favorite places in NYC ... Staff is amazing.... Products are perfection.. love you all

Just tried the strawberry mousse and it it amazing texture and flavor for a sweet fix

This is my favorite bakery in NY. The tres leche and flan are always my go to when I am craving sweets. My cousin recently got the rugelach and it was really good too. I particularly like the chocolate one. They always are friendly too!

bought a birthday cake here and the guests loved it and thought it was delicious

So I want to say that the tiramisu has been inconsistent and varies. One day the lady fingers will be nice and soaked in the espresso and the next day it's dry like no love was put into it. Some days the cocoa powder is too heavy like covid cinnamon challenge and other days it's the perfect ratio. However, it is still good, none the less. I think multiple ppl make this and some are better than others. I'm going to try something different because the inconsistency has me like "girl, my ex works here?". But yeah. I still give love to my community. 5 out of 5, keep small businesses alive.

Get cakes from here every month for the family's birthdays (big family). It's always a sure thing, we get great customer service and oh their cakes are the best.