Bagels by the Bay / Bagel Doctor

Bagels are made fresh right there, it's a very friendly and welcoming place, you have to try it

Ah... breakfast on Long Island can be something of delight given we have mastered the art of the bagel and the breakfast sandwich. Bagels by the Bay certainly doesn't disappoint. I moved off the island five years ago and besides missing family and friends, the regret of not having the food I've grown up with and loved nearby you can bet anytime I go home to visit I'm eating my face off. If you're in this area this is a great, casual place to grab either breakfast or lunch on the go or dine in as seating is offered. We came for breakfast and everything was delicious. Perfect bacon, egg and cheese on a roll as well as terrific everything bagel toasted with two overeasy eggs and bacon. Definitely stop in and try them out I doubt you'll be disappointed.

Great bagels, food, coffee, and breakfast sandwiches! I’ve never been disappointed with the food or service. Everyone is friendly and bagels are always fresh and delicious. My favorite is the whole-wheat sunflower seed flagel.

Stopped here for a quick breakfast. The staff behind the counter was very friendly polite and my breakfast wrap came out in a reasonable amount of time. The coffee was also nice and hot and very tasty.

My favorite bagel place by far. Still travel from a few towns away and worth it every time. A+

They are always busy because the bagels and breakfast sandwiches are good. The service is fast and they have never screwed up my order. The owner is always on site and cares about quality and keeping his customers happy. Even when its packed they keep the line moving and the food coming out quickly.

In town from San Diego and stopped by this joint after some disc golf. Beautiful ladies behind the counter, great customer service and the best bagel breakfast sandwich I have had, hands down! Will be back again. Check them out.

Bagels by the Bay turned me onto acai bowls. They make the best ones.

Love breakfast sandwiches are best in long island. Great place digg I'n and kill hunger breakfast

They have a wide variety of bagels..I love this spot.

We drove all the way from Vermont for a Long Island visit and went here EVERY MORNING for breakfast. Best bagels, rolls and egg sandwiches in Suffolk County. (And I'm from here so I know what a bagel should be like lol!)

Good bagels, super friendly staff who treat everyone well and great specials like a free coffee or hot chocolate with your bagel sandwich.

Joann is the only reason this place is amazing!!! Makes the best of the best!! So sweet and welcoming and keeps the place clean!!

Great bagels, and great service. Even when there is a long line, they have enough people to keep it moving quickly. Great place!

Fresh warm bagels, helpful pleasant, hard working staff, good sandwiches. Plenty seating and long line moves fast. A local favorite. Parking sometimes tight.

Soft, delicious bagels. Good tasting veggie cream cheese. Fast service.

The staff at this place make the whole experience! The bagels and food are top notch! Any time I am in Oakdale, I stop in.. definite recommend!

Best BEC on Long Island (my humble opinion but I'm fat so it should count for something)

Charming little breakfast shop on an easy-access main road.

+1 for a delicious hazelnut flavored hot coffee.

Thank you for donating the bagels for our church bagel brunch each week. We encourage everyone to patronize this friendly business.