Stuff-A-Bagel

First time trying this establishment and just overall great service, great food, and great atmosphere. Everything is fresh and the facility is so clean. I was greeted so kindly in the morning. The staff are very nice! Food prep was quick and done with care. Prices are great!

I can't for the life of me understand why they have 3.5 stars! I've served these bagels to high end clients and have been told "this is the best bagel I've ever had".

I'm so glad this is now my hometown bagel shop 😁

Always the best sandwiches and nicest people working there!!

I only come to this bagel store now. Their vegetable cream cheese is the best in town and their bagels are soft and delicious. Prices are cheap compared to some other shops in town

The best, haven't been home in a Long Island in 8 years and this place has the best bagels around they even threw in a few extra for us to take back to Florida. Will be back on our next trip

First time here. Grabbed a steak egg cheese bacon on everything bagel and it was...... Great. Would come back here again if I need something quick. Got here around 9, wasn't busy at all.

I want to start of by saying I don’t normally write reviews unless I really am happy with service I get , with that been said I am very happy with the service this place gives you they are very nice , clean and bagels are always fresh so that’s a big plus I always come here to get my breakfast highly recommend ( they have new management so things are really great)

been going for many years and always my go to spot for picking up fresh bagels. Ive long since moved away from NY but always make it a point to go here, last time even left room in my suitcase to fly home a dozen to FL

Stuff-a-bagel has some of the best bagels around. With great variety with their French Toast Bagel being to die for. Their staff is extremely helpful with speedy severice. It's a great local place that I can't recommend enough to any bagel fan.

I love bagels from Stuff-A-Bagel in East Islip. I only get to visit every couple of years but make it a priority to stop there at least once when we go to Long Island for a visit.

It doesn't matter if we fly or drive we always pick up a dozen when we head back home to Missouri.

They've got at least a dozen varieties of bagels and all the fixens. Plus they've got lots of other great food.

Great and with new ownership!!! Staff is very friendly and fast. Food options have significantly increased. Revamped interior. Always our go-to.

Excellent courteous service, sharp clerk marked each it! Without even being asked. My first time there and sure to return as it's much closer to my house 🏠 🙂

My new hot spot...use to go to this new deli up the street across from the church on main street, but they keep switching owners. This place has a lot to offer as far as menus goes and all the staff ,super friendly and service is quick.. not to mention the food is always tasty and however you order it is exactly how you get It!, hot food is hot ! Cold food is cold....

Great food and service.

Great fresh bagels. Just make sure you request a detailed receipt of your purchase.

This place is always so fast and their egg everything bagels are so delicious. It's my only breakfast spot when i'm down in East Islip visiting friends. The scallion cream cheese is always my go-to!

Bagels are amazing. Everything fresh. Service is quick and staff friendly. Place gets very busy, but that's cause they are good

This is the go-to place for the best Brooklyn style bagels around. Forget bagelboss with thier horrible rude staff. Always a pleasant experience even when busy.

Been coming to this bagel shop for many years and will continue to do so. They have the best bagels and egg sandwiches.