Neuhart Cards & Sports Collectibles

New to the hobby and first time in the shop. Owner is a great guy and they took really good care of me! Recommend to all and I’ll definitely be back.

Keith was very kind to look at my cards today. Offer was fair and the shop selection is always top notch and friendly staff. Always recommend this shop to friends and family visiting. Glad to have this shop so close!

Awesome shop! Extremely friendly and were willing to work with me on the Kyrie Kaboom I purchased. Highly recommend!

I’ve been coming to this store since I got back into the hobby in 2012. IMO this is among the very best shops around. The owner, Keith, is very personable and is a genuinely good guy. Having moved to Cleveland, I only get the opportunity to stop in about once a month, but I am always pleasantly surprised by how well refreshed their inventory is. They always have new stuff coming in, keep their bins stocked, and pricing is spot on. Finally, I can’t say enough about the diversity of the shop; They have everything from low end raw cards, to high end graded cards. I would recommend this shop to anyone and everyone who enjoys the hobby!

Very clean shop. Owner is super friendly and informative. The selection of singles is huge as well as the boxes. I break a hobby box per week and never have an issue finding something. Definitely give this shop a try.

I'm going today for the 4th time and I live an hour away. Normally I order online even though I have 2 shops within 20 minutes. They never have a selection with one box left of everything which is high suspicious. Neuhart Cards however always stays stocked.

First store I've seen to sell at a reasonable, uninflated price

Great shop. Good selection of singles and new boxes. I also love buying junk wax era boxes and they had plenty. Storage supplies are cheaper than amazon or Target. The owner was extremely friendly. My 8 year old son bought a 2014 OBJ rookie jersey card, his favorite player. The owner gave him a magnetic hard case for free when I attempted to buy it for him. We’ll definitely be back. It was worth the 45 minute trip. Great card shop that reminds me of dairy land In Wooster where I went as a kid.

Not from the area just stopped in and they have a great selection. My son sat and went through the single Pokemon cards while I looked around through basketball cards. Will definitely stop back next time I'm in the area.

The owner was very kind while I looked through the selection of cards for about two hours. I think the other reviews are mad because they didn’t get an unreasonable amount of money for a at best mildly rare card. Thanks For the wonderful experience! Might come by next week!

I've been coming to this shop over seven years. Neuhart offers the best selection of single cards, with decent prices on boxes as well. The staff is extremely knowledgeable and are up to date regarding prices on all their cards. They are constantly buying and will try their best to work with you and your needs. Thank you for everything!

Awesome Place! The guys here are fun to talk to and knowledgeable. Pricing is very competitive vs online or anywhere I have seen! Great selection! Highly Recommend! I always pull Fire in store!

Great shop!!!! Came in for a few one touch cases and left with more! Had a large supply of hobby boxes and a ton of cool singles. Very friendly an a nice clean shop!

Best selection, and prices of any shop in ohio. Drove 2 hours to get there and was well worth trip. It's nice to see there are still good people in the hobby. Every shop I have been to in ohio most owners are lazy, unorganized, and if they have singles are sickly high. Best shop experience I have had in 15 years. Highly recommend A+++++. Best shop by far In ohio

Fantastic store and super friendly employees. Had great quantity and prices of the cards. Stopped by and ended up and hanging out for a while. Highly suggested!

A place that brings back fond memories of one of the best parts of my childhood. Keith and Brian are great guys and very knowledgeable in the happenings of hobby/products/sports world. The prices for wax/singles are excellent especially when comparing to online prices from blowout, COMC or eBay. My favorite aspect of the store is the various boxes of singles...I never leave empty handed. Bottom line, visit and support Neuharts. 🐐

Amazing card store! Has a lot of inventory and can grab so many cards for a great value! Keith is also the nicest owner ever! I got a ton of prizm base cards and autos too!

Stopped in yesterday, first time in card shop in 25 years!! Owner and staff all very nice. Relaxed, can take your time, no pressure.

Will be back

Thank you

Best singles selection in central Ohio! Very friendly and knowledgeable staff. Great place to go if you want to sell for fair prices and purchase for great deals.

Great and knowledge owner and staff. Brian is really helpful. Never felt pressured and very relaxed environment. I won't knock down a star because Google can't get ur location right

Very nice staff. Patient with my kids. Excellent selection with variety.