Five Star Pizza

First time I order from here, the pizza was good, the place felt good when I walked in, was greeted immediately and my pizza was done by the time I got there 😋. I got the Large Pepperoni, Jalapeño, Pineapple 🍍 for $21.46.
I liked how they have different sizes - I def want to try their biggest pie next time.
Pizza smelled good as I brought it to my car.
I’d go back for sure.

5 star pizza is one of our go-to pizza spots for pick up. Our preference is for their thin crust pizza, but the regular crust is good, too. We prefer our pizzas well done/crispy, which you can see here. Delivery is available, and it's through the restaurant, not Uber eats or anything like that.

If you order online, there are usually coupons available to save some money.

5 star has yet to disappoint. There's only one other pizza spot in Tallahassee that is in the same boat. Thank you 5 star for consistently good food and service.

The food was DELICIOUS and the customer service is awesome! Will definitely be ordering from here again!

First time ordering here and absolutely will be returning. We live 30 minutes south of 5 Star Pizza and have lived and worked in Tallahassee for many years. The Everything Pizza was fantastic, tasty and delicious. Crust was perfect and done exactly when told. Try this place you probably will return! Also good prices IMHO Sorry about the picture... nice almost whole 18" Everything 🍕

The pizza here's great!! Got a small pepperoni and cheese for my daughter and chicken poppers for me. Everything tasted fresh except the sauce but all in all it was good for the price we paid!! I would defiantly say give them a shot and see for yourself! It was 20 mins til closing and we still got great food even so close to the end which says alot for this company.. who now has my late night business from now on!

Only place in town that I order delivery instead of pickup. The "Everything" pizza is delicious and has a lot of toppings. The pizza from here is fantastic! Delivery is quick and affordable at $2.99. The 16" inch large everything pizza is $20.99 before taxes. The garlic sauce is amazing! I highly recommend that you order a few of them to dip your pizza in. The garlic rolls are delicious. Break them open and dip it in the sauce that comes with it to soak it up. We will be back and have been a few times.

Jim did a great job making my Chicken Pizza hot fresh crunchy bottom juicy chicken and cheesy on top. He was patient and helped Me with options and understanding of the place and the ingredients. I was hesitant about ordering from here but now I think I found a great place for my Chicken pizza. Thnx Jim

We stayed in Tallahassee for three nights. On the last night, we just wanted to stay in snd order a pizza. We had seen pizza boxes from Five Star Pizza the last two mornings at the hotel we stayed at. Figured it had to be good. So glad we ordered. It did not disappoint and the prices are really reasonable. Delivery was fast considering how far we were from the establishment.

My first time ordering was today from there.......let me just say this they are the 💣..... okurrrrrrrr.....💅the food was delivered hot,hmmm I ordered the garlic Parmesan wings/Terriyaki Wing's...make sure you tell them well-done,
"personal preference" cuz I don't like my wings mushy and soft...I also ordered the garlic knots,pizza rolls...both was on POINT omg!!!!!!!!!!!!!! This place amazing I'm mad it took me this long to realize they've been around... try them.. you won't regret it.

This pizza took me back to my childhood so I had a nostalgic moment when taking the first bite! It reminded me of how Chuck E. Cheese pizza use to taste back in the 90s when everyone was talking about it and ordering it out like crazy too! So good which I could give you all 10 stars ⭐ I got the specialty pepperoni “something” but it’s the one with extra pepperoni and cheese with a order of cinnamon rolls which was oh so good and made with fresh dough OMG!!! My new pizza spot DEFINITELY….update: try reheating it the next day in the oven on 350 for 10-15 minutes bc it tastes just how I picked it up!!! 🙌🏽😋🍕

Pizza is great. Cheesy and delicious. One of the best pizza places in Tallahassee

This is BY FAR one of the best "chain-style" pizza joints I've ever been to. Quality to price point ratio is phenomenal. Super friendly staff too!!

Texan comin’ thru on a late night, this pizza was great- good crust, fresh toppings, quick and courteous service. Probably some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. We ordered the 16” Everything Pizza, and it was FANTASTIC. Absolutely recommend Five Star pizza

The quality is on point, holds up so well even when delivered. I could eat it cold - they're that good.

Do yourself a flavor and eat some today.

My co-worker and I find ourselves ordering Five Star pretty much every single week, it's decadent and affordable. Much better than standard chains.

As a college student in the mid-90's in Gainesville, Florida, I lived on 5-Star Pizza. (Back then, Large cheese, $4.99, free delivery...lol, the good ole days.)

I recently moved to Tallahassee and was pleasantly surprised to see a 5-Star here. I ordered pizza and pepperoni rolls, and both were perfect, delivered faster than promised, and just overall a great delivery experience. I'd give them 6 stars if it would let me.

This place really is a 5 star pizza 😳 wishing we had one back in Waco,TX right now 😩💜 -Kiwi

My husband and I had some friends over and decided to order pizza rather than cooking. This was our first time ordering from these people. Often times, when we pick up pizza, it's greasy or undercooked; which causes one of us to become sick the following morning. We drove to the store and ordered a 24" barbecue chicken pizza for everyone to share. The store could have been cleaned a little better. The pizza was delicious! Maybe a little extra mozzarella and chicken, otherwise it was perfect. The dough wasn't undercooked. Wasn't greasy. My husband and I weren't sick the next morning, which was a plus. We'll definitely be ordering pizza through these people again.

Super fast delivery, great prices, and always awesome. They even have a vegan option! This location offers Miyokos vegan cheese, which is way better than the usual Daiya option you see at most other places. I cannot recommend Five Star enough!

I've been ordering from this place for about 3 years now and this is not only consistently good but also fast. It's not the "best" pizza by far, but there's so many more redeeming qualities about 5 Star. The customer service is always on point, I've never had an issue with my order and the one time I did it was handled super professionally and was still a pleasant experience. Going to miss this place when I leave Tally. The Pizza, wings and garlic rolls combo is my go to order. Love this place, hits the spot everytime.

Easy to work with on the phone, pizza time quoted 10-15 min at prime time on a Friday, I think they had it done before that, efficient and lean customer experience. Good work guys.
The pizza itself is 6.5/10, but I am EXTREMELY hard on pizza. Recommended.