Sweet Legacy Gourmet

If I am ever in this area again I’m stopping for the oatmeal pie and caramel marshmallow. Oh my! We walk into the smell of perfection and the greeting from a kind young lady. She gave us information on the products and helped us select the best sugar and chocolate for us. The best, though, was the molasses cookies. Good golly! We Got 6. They boxed everything up and made it special. My son said the cookies were awesome. They explained their shipping policies for the holidays and helped us register to win a basket for Christmas in July. I’m not sure if it was the manager or owner but she came out and talked to us. I can’t remember her name but she must have eaten a lot of product because she was sweet as sugar too. She was small and mighty with a sweet punch to really make us feel Welcomed. Thanks for all the guidance. We loved everything!

If your in the area, you must stop in . I saw the marshmallows in the window and wow! I actually sell handmade carmellows at my place of business and these put mine to shame . The caramel that is wrapped around the marshmallow is to die for and if you try this you will never want to eat a store bought marshmallow again. I brought several back for coworkers and they all agreed with me . I should say, what make it back to work! I also grabbed a blueberry out bar for my breakfast and that was delicious also . I wish I had bought some other items from there so I could give a better review, but I’m pretty sure by the taste of those two items nothing in there would disappoint ! Even there bag was pretty !

If you are unaware, this is one of the most amazing sweet shops on the Eastern seaboard.
You walk in, and are greeted by the overwhelming smell of buttery, sugary goodness.
It's the smell of everything being made by hand in front of you, it's the smell of magic and quality, it is a smell that is sorely needed when you need that extra bit of loving.

Stopped in on a whim after dinner. I've been in the candy industry more than 30 years and I HIGHLY recommend! Her homemade caramel and marshmallow is fantastic! Chocolates were wonderful as well. Two thumbs up@

When I was in Lititz I stopped into this adorable store. The owner, Chela was very friendly and helpful. Her sea salted caramel candies were the best I ever had. I will certainly be returning.

The owner was great! They didn’t have something we wanted, so she made it for us! The cookie sandwiches are amazing!

THE BEST! 😍🤩😍 Has been my go to ever since I first discovered it two years ago. Expect to find the most delicious treats! Nestled in the cutest town's downtown district. Perfect stop while enjoying the equally adorably quaint shops nearby. It’s always full of good vibes and delicious smells inciting you to treat yourself.

New owner and great service. I asked about a shoefly tasting cookie, the owner did not have that in the case so she got it ingredients and made a few. I took 2 and loved the taste, they are a must have when I stop. Her cashew turtles are also great.

I stopped at this wonderful shop on Friday and bought their caramel apples with peanuts. I will say these were the best I have ever had. These were so amazing I visited again on Sunday before returning home to State College to buy several more. I called first and to ensure they had more before driving there from our BB. The Ice festival was still going on and they kept some back for me. The owners are very friendly and you can tell the greatly appreciate their customers. I then bought some butter caramels and these were amazing as well. Thanks SLG Shop for the great service and 2nd to none apples and caramels! - Mike

Lititz' Best Kept Secret. Hands down. Move over Wilbur! Though Wilbur Chocolate is a classic of this area, and just as loved, the level of quality of Sweet Legacy candies, fudge, and cookies is so stellar you will think you are on another planet. Must go if you are visiting Lancaster County. and also fair warning to those who drive to the shore during the summers, you may never want fudge from South Jersey again either once you have tried the fudge at Sweet Legacy. I gave this fudge as a gift to my in-laws one year for the holidays and they still gush about it. My sister-in-law visited when they were closed and she was so sad because she wanted some fudge. I have also gotten this fudge for my dad, my aunts, and even coworkers. It is a go to gift. Support this local business! They are worth the time and money and thickening waist line. I promise.

This is exactly the type of local dessert place that I look for when I’m traveling. I wish I had more time and more room in my stomach to try more things! This is what a local business should be. Excellent product, friendly staff, wonderful & visible store set up. I’ve only had the chance to try the molasses cookie so far, but that secured a worthy 5 star review in the first bite. Go out of your way to stop here.

If you are visiting Lititz, treat yourself to a stop at Sweet Legacy. Amazing caramels, jellied chocolates, mint, you name, they have it. Oh and wonderful cookies as well. Owner is very pleasant and answers any questions you may have.

Brought a small Summer Camp group to Sweet Legacy was was IMPRESSED. The owner ( and candymaker) took time to answer all our kids questions and even gave them a small sample of a sweet. Very generous. Very kind. And the Sweets were delicious! Best Peanut Butter Fudge I've ever had. A must if you're in Lititz

Hands down the best fudge I've ever had! I finished most it by that night because of how fresh and creamy it was. Days later, still has that smooth, chocolatey flavor! Would recommend getting several slices because of how good it is

When you walk through the front door you are hit with the wonderful smells of all the amazing treats and sweets. The shop is so aesthetically appealing too! You can’t leave without trying the handcrafted old fashion family recipe fudge in so many amazing flavors (try the dark chocolate, peanut butter, and salted caramel chocolate) the salted caramels are to die for, and the caramel popcorn beats Fishers by a long shot.! My children couldn’t leave without taking a few cookies and chocolate covered marshmallows for later. You must try everything!!!

My son and I stopped by this morning and he was able to watch a little of the process of making fudge. He picked out a candy apple and the two people working were really sweet and kind to him. Luckily for me, my son ate only a few bites and I was able to enjoy the rest. It was so delicious! My family loved the gummy bears too!

A great little gourmet candy shop in Lititz, PA. The entire staff were extremely welcoming and helpful.

Had a great experience ordering for Mother's Day. I called on a Wednesday with a rush order to pick up the same day. They told me not to worry- they'd have it ready and would deliver it free of charge that same afternoon.

Everything came well packaged and presented. And most importantly- everything tasted great! The chocolates were high quality handmade and the baked goods were fresh and delicious. This place is well-run and worth checking out!

My husband & I stopped in during our Lititz day this week & just absolutely loved it! The best peanut butter brownie I could have ever dreamt of! You've got to stop in if you're in the area. I can't wait to visit again!

Dark chocolate caramels are out of this world, my favorite ever by far. The caramel is soft and chewy on the side and the chocolate is coating is thin with sea salt. Oatmeal cream cookies are also a favorite in our house hold. We also have to pick up a bottle of the bourbon barrel maple syrup every time we go there because we use it so often for Dutch babies and pancakes.