Elm Hill Pizza

Food is very good. Salads are always fresh and dressings are perfect. Sometimes the grilled chicken is too hard. Grinders are great and huge. Chicken tenders and fries are well done but sometimes kind of spice (maybe they use pepper). Prices are fair. Overall excellent

We had a meatball pizza, mozzarella sticks, garlic wings, tuna melt, everything was excellent. Fair prices, great food, friendly owner family operated. Order at the counter, self service. Small place but there's 4-5 booths, comfortable atmosphere, clean, busy with take out. Thankful a friend recommended it.

We just order pizza from there Monday because the other place we went to the pizza was being burned on the toppings. This place is nice and friendly. The pizza was great Elm special. Next we're going to try the grinders

This is my local pizza place I have been coming to for over 10 years now and I have never been to a better place. Not only is the pizza AMAZING and I dream of it when i’m away at college but they truly care about their community and are the kindest people. They remember me year after year even after moving away to college and I cannot recommend them more to anyone in the area!

Hometown local and showed this place to some coworkers. Always quality food and customer service. The inside is small but for takeout its perfect. Their calzones are huge!!

One of the best place to get pizza and especially their wings! Will not regret coming here!

Superior Pizza 🤌🏽🤌🏽🤌🏽🤌🏽 nice crunchy crust and well seasoned 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽 slices are a bit small but that’s fine when it taste so good 👅

Best pizza around. Family owned, and everyone is so friendly. Growing up, we had pizza here every Fri night from Elm Hill. Even though we no longer live in town, Elm Hill Pizza is still our go-to.

oh my god this pizza is from heaven the best pizza in ct amazing fast service, what a wonderful experience. I will be only ordering from here.

The food was amazing and Nick was very nice and helpful. The place was very clean and everyone was very friendly. I will back to try some of the other foods.

Pizza is always great an I love there grinders .❤I never had any problems with there food .

I love that it is a family run restaurant with dining in or take out options, although the dining in area is small the food definitely makes up for it. Everyone that works there is very professional, very personable, and I have not had one problem with anything I have ever ordered from there. They definitely go the extra mile to give you exactly what you want. The quality and quantity of the food is awesome and the pricing is very very reasonable. I live on social security and they don't give you enough money to throw out the window for lousy food, but I love this place and I get to have their food a couple times a month. Thank you elm Hill Pizza

Great sauce and pizza. Love the crust!

Family owned and operated by a great bunch! Food is always on point and fresh. Large special pizza well done is my go to beside their capicolla grinder with all the fixins!!

Their pizza not like they used to be! Dry alittle bit! But overall everything else is ok

Love the Calzones and Chicken Parmesan grinders here!

THE BEST PIZZA! This place will keep a fat man well fed!. This restaurant is awesome it's family owned and operated. The staff here knows everyone by there first names. Super clean, Super friendly, and truly the best authentic Italian pizza, there is no need to travel to find the best grinders or specialty pizza in this area, if you order a meat based pizza you get meat. The staff and owners here go up and beyond to please their customers. We eat here weekly Friday nights are pizza nights in my home. If you enjoy a good slice or a whole pie and other pasta dishes than look no further. Easy in and Easy out again the Best....... keep it going guys Elm Hill should be on your speed dial. They're #2 on my phone.

We've lived around the corner for 36 years and this is the first time I've reviewed Elm hill Pizza, goes without saying it's awesome !! We got the most delicious roast beef grinder today and it never fails,, so good! We have Niece's and Nephew's who come home to Connecticut and always need to have your pizza before they leave! Tradition!! Awesome French fries too!!! And eggplant grinders!!

Ventured off the Turnpike to come across this gem sitting cross the street from a great little Italian deli, "Public Market". I knew from the awesome smell and the line of people this would be a good experience. Since it was my first visit I ordered my "go-to" peppers and pepperoni. Nice crust, crispy yet tender and chewy on the inside. Saucy, good tomato flavor, not "pastey", not too "herby". Generous amount of pepperoni (not oily!) and very nicely thin cut green peppers cooked to perfection, firm with a little crunch left. Excellent balance of crust to toppings to sauce ratio. I can't say anything bad about it. Shop is small with just a couple booths but we got it to go. Staff was friendly, attentive and very efficient on a busy Saturday night. Nice job! 👌🏻 Will definitely back.

Best pizza in town! We go once a week, esp on Fridays and when we need food and don't want to cook. Will keep on coming back over and over again!