Yorkside Pizza & Restaurant

We’ve always been curious to try Yorkside Pizza, and thinking it was a Tuesday night we thought it would be a good time to visit - little did we know there was a concert at Toad’s Place, so the place was hopping! We only waited for a little bit before getting a seat, and the staff really did a commendable job of handling the volume that they had. Definitely a well-oiled machine here! We just did a cheese pizza and chocolate milkshake, and it really hit the spot! Definitely one of the best Greek style pizzas I’ve had, and it was a nice change for the typical apizza style in the area. The restaurant had a classic pizza parlor feel in here that we liked! We’ll be back!

Amazing food, lovely staff, great atmosphere! I loved this place. The only problem was that their pizza took a long time to get ready! Oh I also seriously recommend trying the Musaka, it was beyond delicious! Loved the Greek server who got excited that I ordered Musaka! 😁

We were out of town and stopped by for some pizza. We had a great time, the pizza was great and greek salad was perfect. Nice family place.

We went back a second time and had an experience of a life time. We started out with this wings which are truly amazing and proceeded to order most of their Greek food. If you like home made Greek food, then this is the place to go.

Beautiful old building, awesome pizza!!!
I had the Mediterranean, which is tuna, anchovies, crab. I added spinach and fresh garlic.
My husband had the Yorkside special pizza, which he ate all of so I assume he loved it...
Our other kids all got pizzas of their choosing, and all ate a lot!!
We also got a bottle of wine.
We were just passing through and walking through the Yale campus, so we are happy that we stumbled by this place.

The food is all good, with different layers of taste. We had 3 different pizza, 2 pasta, bbq wings. The manager George is nice to us, as a group of 20. If you don’t know what to order, you can always ask staff for recommendation. Such a warm place you have to stop by for a bite, when you visit Yale community, New Haven.

The pizza was amazing. It was kinda a long wait but definitely was worth it. I’ll go back for sure.

The pizzeria is situated in a highly accessible area, where you can explore York Street and Yale campus on foot. The prices are affordable, and the pizzas are delectable. We savored the 4 cheese and hawaiian varieties, and relished the flavors of garlic parmesan chicken and bbq chicken. The meat lasagna also impressed us. The ambience is cozy and inviting, and the staff is courteous and helpful.

The pizza was fantastic! Everything a New Haven pizza should be. The crust….was perfection. There was a nice quantity of good quality toppings and the perfect crisp and flop to the pie without being too greasy. Would definitely recommend.

I’ve been eating here since 1986. Still great. The best Greek salad. Great onion rings. Solid pizza- it’s oiled dough so it’s really tasty - different from Pepe’s. Great owners.

Very good pizza! Pleasantly surprised! People are always coming to New Haven for Sallys, Pepes or Modern & they're fine... esp if you like thin, charred over-priced pizza but if you prefer pizza that tastes great (esp the sauce & cheese) & you don't need to eat 6 thin pieces to be satisfied then this is the place to go.

The yorkside special pizza is damn goooood and my nephew loves its chicken cutlet tomato sauce spaghetti! Everyone works there is super nice and kind. Recommend this place!!

I love this place. The pizza is good but they also have a really great burger and DEFINITELY the best and tastiest wings in downtown new haven.

I went here a lot when I was a kid with my dad- I hadn’t been since, and one night while contemplating dinner and craving pizza I told my boyfriend we should come here since I remember it being amazing. Well in short I wasn’t disappointed and it looks exactly the same way it did 20ish years ago when I last went with my dad. The same Yale alumni photos and such hanging up. I was thrilled to see it hadn’t changed or modernized- it’s stayed it’s true self and I love that. The pizza is amazing still. The calamari is just as good as I remember. Even my boyfriend who’s a seafood hater loves it. Frosted beer mugs which he loves. A baklava to die for. And friendly and timely staff. This place has become a new staple for us. It’s become his first choice for pizza. Whether it be takeout night or date night out. A must have in the New Haven area.

Yorkside is one of my "musts" when I am in New Haven, for the past 20+ years. The food and service NEVER disappoint; the chicken fingers ALWAYS get wow-comments, and there must be a sauce magician in the kitchen. Portion sizes are fantastic and sharable. It is family-friendly and affordable. I am already looking forward to my next visit!

Nice food, atmosphere and people. When I am walking home they let me use bathroom and not buy anything. If u ever walked in city you know why this is a big deal. Steve Colbert was here. My best friend got her wedding catered by this place.

Nice pizza place right adjacent to campus. Food and service were great. Would absolutely come here again.

Yorkside is always great! Stopped by for lunch with the kiddos got a small chicken tender plate that could have fed 2 adults (tasty chicken) I had the Sm greek salad that I could barely finish(really good salad) mom had a tuna melt with fries which was also really fresh and tasty. Needless to say we needed boxes upon leaving. The kind of leftovers that are worth reheating ! Thanks again Yorkside!

I've been coming here since I was a kid, all through college, while dating, right after I got married, while pregnant and now with my very own kids. its always been consistently amazing.
The owners are very friendly as are the staff. My favorite waitress "Eleni" is the best! My daughter calls her "ya-ya" (grandma in Greek). It truly is a New Haven Gem!!
The Peasant Salad with house dressing.
Pepperoni pie and Avgolemono soup are our go-to's.
Parking is a little tricky but it's worth the walk.

My favorite restaurant in New Haven and some of the best pizza and Greek that I’ve ever had. Chill vibes, friendly staff, and incredible food for the price. Go here!

The best gyro in America! They are known for pizza and shakes, but the gyro was a gem! You will feel like you are in a top notch Greek restaurant. When you visit New Haven you have to try this wonderful dish!