Benny J's Pizza

I had no idea this gem was here!! We really wanted mozzarella sticks and they had them!! They have great tomato sauce, very bright flavor, very fresh!!

We were not sure how the sandwiches would be but I am so glad we got them!! Best bread!! I got the eggplant pesto focaccia and my family got the orange chicken. The Eggplant was nice and tender! I didn't expect orange slices on a chicken cutlet but we really enjoyed it!! Roasted red peppers seemed fresh & were perfect on both sandwiches and THE BREAD!! the focaccia bread is fantastic!! Fluffy and slightly crispy with some rosemary on it!! Sandwiches were warm but not over toasted or burnt like some focaccia sandwiches I have had at other establishments.

I am so happy we stopped in here and will be back for the pizza!! Give them a try!

Comparing this place to other branford pizza joints: these sandwiches were the least greasy focaccia sandwiches we have had! I really can't compare the bread to any other sandwich place it's sooooo good!! The fillings didn't all fall out and portions were perfect for us! Yum! Clean restaurant, very fast! Very friendly! Thanks so much!

Amazing amazing the best food I had in 15 years the best food ever. Very much recommend the avocado pizza if u want an explosive taste in your mouth

We are a pizza centered family. We found Benny Js by mistake. What a fantastic find!! Their sauce is beautifully consistent and never fails to please. My husband will "ban" restaurants if he gets a bad pizza. We've been ordering delivery for the last year and through the pandemic. They are awesome. Thank you@

I ordered a steak bom sub and it taste amazing. It was not tossed in the bread and messy like other places. The food had a nice presentation. Food tasted super fresh. And best part of all the tomatoes looked like they were cut fresh it did not look soggy like other places! Overall I will be ordering from them again.

The best food in our area, for quality and taste! Always a consistent 10, never a disappointment! AND they deliver! Happy, pleasant staff, always make you feel appreciated when doing business there

Started with the pasta fagioli soup which was so good I put in another order of it to go. The fried ravioli were crisp and had a perfect amount of filling. We had a cheese pizza which had an excellent sauce. It's all about the sauce! Will definitely go back. The staff are very friendly.

HIGHLY recommend. Great large portions, quality food. Great service at the front! Very fairly priced. Always delicious.

First time ordering.Just ordered a med clam casino pizza I gotta say we were pretty impressed food had good consistency just the right amount of topping flavor. The price was good for wut we got. Well see be ordering again. Bravo Benny Js vast improvement when it was Eddies

Best salads ever!
Edit (May 28th 2020)
Wouldn't let me add a new review.
Seriously such an amazing place. I wish I knew the kids name because he is just awesome. The food is just so good. Seriously my go to place in Branford 🙂

We have ordered from benny j's three times now and all three times the food was outstanding the delivery person was pleasant and friendly. The salads we ordered were delicious will definitely order again. 😊

Amazing pizza & great fresh creative salads! Friendly service & they deliver locally. Grandma’s pizza is the best!!

Fantastic Pizza and other delicious items, it's a local gem! A great family establishment and they deliver..

It doesn't look like much when you walk in but, they know how to cook! The chicken picciatta & marsala were like butter.

Good pizza. Not too much sauce, just right amount and not hard crust. Plus the delivery came so fast!

The pizza is fantastic, the delivery drivers are always courteous and my orders come before time expected.

Sausage and mushroom pizza was great. They are friendly the place is clean. I recommend.

Their penne vodka pizza is my go to! It’s absolutely amazing. Thank you Benny J’s!

benny j’s pizza is amazing and excellent, good customer service, must try again!

Exceptional food. Reasonably roved. Generous portions. Small, cozy place. Owner very friendly. Really enjoyable.

I ordered the Mango salad it was delicious, highly recommend. I will be ordering again..😁