Anthony John's Pizzeria

Their wings are amazing!!!! So crispy and lots of flavor. Their pizza is also so good too. My sister and I were looking for a new pizza place and I'm glad we decided on here.

My friend brought these amazingly delicious stuffed breads to my house last night. They arrived hot, HUGE & with sauce. One was steak & cheese. The other was chicken parm. I’ll be getting my breads here from now on. Absolutely FABULOUS.

We are Open Sunday 24th For Stuff Breads

I've been getting food from here all the time for the last month. One of the most beautiful places I've discovered. Staff are friendly, perfect place. Try their pizza, their sauce is perfect.

Ordered a small mozz and a large with bacon and onion for my first time. Must say both pizza's were delicious. The best I had in a while and they delivered. My experience was great from start to finish and will definitely be ordering again. I love their pizza and as long as they make it the same and don't change a thing I will always be a loyal, weekly customer.

Anthony John's makes delicious food in proportions much larger than you would expect for the cost. Their chicken parmigiana sub is the best I've ever had and big enough to make two meals. Their stuffed breads are delicious, and they don't skimp on the cheese like most places in the new haven area. Their fried mozzarella is a much bigger serving than you will find just about anywhere else and, while it's not the best in the area, it isn't far off. Their pizza is good. Not quite on the same level as pepe's, modern, or Sally's, it would be among the best in any other part of the country.

Great pizza, boy taking orders is great!

I order weekly from Anthony John's and recommend them highly. They offer a huge selection of toppings as well as other salads, sandwiches and italian dinners. They make the best stuffed breads in Connecticut and the fresh baked rolls are incredible. I also hosted a Christmas party in their party room and everything went so well. Everyone raved over the food. They also deliver!

Awesome Pasta dishes and stuffed breads . Penne vodka and Fettuccine is beyond great. And the steak and cheese sub is HUGE they really stuff their subs and you definitely get what you pay for ! Can never finish any food from here in one sitting! There's something for the whole family !

We stopped by while we were on our way to nj, we had cheese pizza and garlic bread and penne ala vodka dinner which was perfect and tasty, looking forward to go back again.

I have ordered from Anthony John's a few times the service is fabulous food is Yummy !! Ordered Angel hair pasta with meatballs the other night I have enough for possibly 3 meals comes with a salad and bread the meatballs melt in your mouth

They are the Best BEST Place in the New Haven County Area In my opinion they are caring not only is the Food Beyond Tasteful I’ve had my daughter’s party there is was great from the catering to the Curtusey of asuring decorations were set up Not Only to mention when we order pizza for Delivery from them they are GREAT the Drivers are amazing Tonight’s Driver WAS BEYOND my expectations I’ve never experienced a take out experience no better I am in Traffic 15-20MINUTES maybe he waited to make sure our Food stood hot and fresh and didn’t want to leave the food on the steps even when it was offered still went out the way Thank All of you there !

Best food. I had a birthday party, and had food from here, it was awesome and enough food. They not only brought food on time but it was hot and fresh too. I am very glad and hope to do business in future again.

We stopped here on a whim since the Frank's (we're not sure on the name) place we heard about was PACKED. This place is AMAZING. The food is great, the workers are super nice. It's quiet, quaint. We loved it. Recommend!!!

Great freshly made bread and dough for subs & pizzas. Staff friendly and glad to see you, feels like home. Warm and fantastic aromas.

I got 12 Wings with Large Cheese pizza. I was met with a friendly service. Cheese Pizza and Wings so delicious.

It was a place i randomly stopped by and i just got pizza. The taste was great, stop by here if you go.

A must try!!! Best pizza I came upon in a minute! 🤤 🍕also incredible cannolis 😍 10/10 would recommend 🌟

I been eaten at Anthony Johns since it opened I watched the place grow the food is always phenomenal never ever had a problem prices always really good to.
Frankie sauce is 2nd to none

Best pizza I've had in awhile certainly in my top 5 for Connecticut. Great customer service which makes the experience even better.