Pizzaro's Pizzeria

My wife works down the road and bought a cheese pie for me for lunch. Simply put, it was probably the best CT pizza I ever had. Reminds me of back in the day in Queens and Brooklyn. We've tried all of the highly reviewed new haven spots, we go around trying different pizza places in CT, this place has them beat.

In the area and wanted pizza! My family normally orders from here so I decided to pick up a pizza! It was really good! Their pizza sauce is delicious and the pizza is not soggy but not too crispy. It was just right! Definitely have to try other options next time. The service was good too!

Tried the chicken parm with angel hair pasta, tonight. Wow was it delicious! Came with a nice fresh salad too! Love this place!

I’ve eaten inside many times but today decided to get the takeout. The chicken parm was large enough to have dinner tonight and leftovers for tomorrow. And this is also the small calzone. Keep the good portions coming and I’ll keep coming back

Definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve tasted in Connecticut! Great atmosphere as well!

Best pizza outside of New Haven! Love the wood fired pizza! The sauce is the perfect tomato sauce for a pizza! A little pricey but once you take that first bite it’s all worth it.

I love this place, I take my kids here all the time. Pizza has a great taste. The cheese is the best. Garlic knots out of this world. Calamari was fresh and not over cooked. Staff is very nice and accommodating. Would definitely recommend to a friend or family member. Well o have already lol. So I’d say best place in Seymour hands down. Just wish they were open today!!

Our first pizza here! We got a large "special". Was ready on time and perfectly cooked. It was excellent. Not "thin-crust, New Haven style" but not thick crust either. Nice, well-cooked brown crust and perfect on top. I couldn't have asked for better. Great ingredients, flavor and taste.

I brought some friends of my fiancée and it was close to closing time but I knew these avid pizza lovers would be floored by how good the pizza is so we went even though it was close to closing time and they let us in!!! And I was right, they gushed over how amazing the pizza was and now can't stop talking about it... they'll be wanting to go back with or without us! 😆 so so good!

Best brick oven thin crust pizza in the valley. Have been going since they opened and have never been disappointed. From the friendly owners and staff to the awesome food it's well worth the trip.

The food is the best in town. I don’t order anywhere else but this place I absolutely love there food!!! Also customer service is absolutely awesome. I give it a 10 out of 10.😄

Good is always great, reasonably priced, ready on time, and great atmosphere.

Family owned and operated. Warm, friendly, and fast service. Wood fired oven produces a great pizza crust that is medium-thin, but not cracker-like and overly charred like some thin crust pizza. Their uniquely delicious sauce and generous high quality cheese and toppings make it a must try for pizza lovers. A bonus is that it's great leftover and/or cold as well, unlike most good pizza. Their Italian dinners are some of the best I've had and you won't find better in the area.

We order takeout regularly but eating in pizza is crispy and hot so even better. My favorite is their thin crust white with broccoli, yum.

Excellent pizza at an affordable price.

These guys are the best! They remember your name, preferences etc. a true family business!! Top quality food! Super clean! Will customize any dish for "picky Irish" custom! Love it, a Friday nite ritual, the pizza is even better heated up the next day! Hey.. don't judge.. I am Irish.. there was no pizza in the first 25yrs of my life back home!☘🍕🍝🍷🍺☘

Pizza very good, atmosphere is very nice,and the people , waitress are great also

Best pizza I have ever had! Wish they were open 7 days per week bc I would go every day. I legit am not even a huge pizza fan. Everyone I’ve brought here loves it, too.

The best take out anywhere around! The ingredients are high quality and extremely fresh. Every bite explodes with wonderful flavor. Thanks for the great meals!

I first would like to say to the Management and Staff of Pizzaro's a belated but WELL DESERVED THANK YOU. This was because 3 yrs ago on July 7th in the afternoon. I and a family friend were picking up a few pizza pies. When we entered the venue and saw on the National news about the Dallas Police Sniper Killings. We were surprised seeing this news. But the matter of the mood of the other customers inside made us feel uncomfortable. Myself and friend are both African American and the media had stated the shooter was as well.It was then the Resteraunt staff noticed and had made us feel comfortable by speaking to us kindly and even discounted 2 2 liter sodas. I know with all the craziness going on in this world there are still Beautiful people in it. The food is fantastic and will always return as a customer. You made us feel like very happy and loved. And for that God will bless!

Hands down, best pizza in the Area. Staff is ALWAYS happy and outgoing. Hardly ever a long wait and the Pie always comes out PERFECT. Have been going here for years and will continue to.