AJ's NY Pizzeria

A nice visit on a cold Kansas night. My wife and I shared a small order of Buffalo Wings, and then we each had our own large slice of pizza. The slices weren't traditional NY Style pizza, but they were hearty and filling none the less. Oh, we both also had side salads, which, again, were hearty, filling, and tasty. The beer menu was appealing also, but maybe next time. Next time I'm in Manhattan, KS I will gladly stop by AJ's again. I strongly recommend them.

Aj's pizza is a great local place to grab some pizza. They have a great atmosphere to hang out and talk to family or friends. I had the chicken bacon ranch pizza and it was amazing! The garlic knots are also buttery and garlic-y! I would definitely go back for either a slice or a whole pie. They also have a nice selection of alcoholic drinks on tap and bottled.

I was staying in mhk for a week and ended up going to AJ's three times while I was there. The place is fantastic. Great pizza, wings, and salads. I did pickup and dine in. Food was always hot and fresh. Great place and for sure the best pizza in the area!

Came in here on a whim to try this place out.
Intended to be a carry out order, but showed up earlier than anticipated.
Sat down and decided to grab a drink. Turned into eating my dinner and having a couple more.

Enjoyed the conversation with the bartender and those at bar. Pizza was tasty at bar, next day cold out of fridge, and reheated in the oven.

Will try to make it back to this facility and grab another pie and good company!

Five Thumbs Up! My wife had the Large Ziti Pasta w/Alfredo sauce, I had the Large Romaine Salad Nolita and slice of Manhattan Margarita pizza, everything was excellent!
👍👍👍👍👍

Nice local pizza place.
Single slices are LARGE. Our eyes were a little bigger than our stomachs, we ordered several slices of different things we wanted to try and ended up lots of leftovers.
The BBQ Chicken, 18th and 8, Big Apple and Hawaiian were good. Our daughter got the grilled cheese and enjoyed it as well. She barely finished her slice (she's a pre-teen).
It was pretty busy, but we didn't wait very long. Staff was excellent and helpful. The NYC theme everywhere was cool, but the pizza was more brick oven type.
The thing that really surprised us was the affordability.
We'll be back the next time we're in town for sure.

This was a wonderful pizza place! The food was piping hot and the calzones we got were stuffed full of toppings. The flavor was spot on and is now a new favorite place for us to stop when we are in town. The bathrooms were clean and the staff was friendly. Can't wait to come back soon!

The BEST restaurant in Manhattan, KS. Hands down. I’ve been a couple times, but I recently ordered the large spinach chicken alfredo. The pizza crust was crunchy but perfectly cooked, and the sauce was creamy. Their ranch is the best I’ve ever had! Definitely recommend trying this place out. I will always visit when I’m in the area.

Delicious pizza! Anything you order will be great here. One of our favorites to visit while in Manhattan.

Good place and setting. Can choose to eat inside or out. Pizzas, pastas, calzones and sliders are create your own. Few choice of things to eat but plenty of ingredients!
P.S. tried it again, and the food is quality. The cheesecake is one of the richest I've had. Could not finish it in one sitting. Delicious

Absolutely the best pizza. Perfect thin crispy crust. Great toppings and sauce. Cheese bricks are amazing also. We had the Popeye Pie and the big apple. I went to school in Stillwater and everyone raves about Hideaway. AJ’s will make you want to throw hideaway in the trash.

Nice staff took my order and did fantastic. I was in town visiting friends and we were downtown and hungry slice of NY pizza in Kansas with beer...yes & yummy... Did order from front counter- got my food and it was piping hot after a short wait. My order was accurate and I definitely will return when in the situation of hunger and in the area. I really felt valued with my interaction with the staff. They were pleasant and smiling....that goes a long way!

Thank you again for being awesome.

Respectfully,
Bryan
Yukon Oklahoma

AJ's is the best. A great place to grab a quick lunch or go have dinner. The atmosphere is awesome and great for all ages. Whether we are grabbing drinks with friends on the patio or getting pizza with the family, AJ's is always a top-of-the-list option.

During the busy hours I had to sit at the front table which the line goes around. Not the best atmosphere. Would suggest a more structured line which would allow the front table to remain segmented off to the side. Or move it into the corner of the lobby with the other counter style table. Either way, Everywhere else looked nice.

Service was great but it was packed so we didn't get our last item until we already had a Togo boxs. Machine broke so only -1 on that!

Pizza was Delicious. The pepperoni was solid and stood above the rest, but that's just my preference :).

Had takeout. Tasty pizza. Fulfilling. You can add additional toppings to which initial pie you select, they have an array of choices. Would recommend if you want to try something different then the chain pizza joints.

I’m so happy with this place. It’s not often we find a Gluten-free pizza that doesn’t taste like cardboard. This place hit it out of the park. There regular pizza is also VERY good. We’ll be coming back again and again.

It's quite lovely here, especially the outdoor eating area. The food was served rather quickly, though our appetizer arrived with the pizza so there really wasn't any point in getting it. Would highly recommend though!

Super cute 🥺 very friendly staff super cute seating and nice music I am hard of hearing so I had a bit of a hard time hearing my bf, but other then that everything was super good!

Good Pizza. I go for the specialty pies XL. Ravioli and pepperoni bricks are also nice. Big salads. Nightly specials. Dog friendly patio on Wednesdays. A good spot for sure. Nice selection of cans and bottled beers.

Probably the best pizzeria around here. The food is delicious and you get lots of it for a cheap price. I absolutely enjoyed the atmosphere and the management. You don't wait too long for your food. Good for groups. I definitely recommend it.