Tenafly Pizza Restaurant

Tenafly Pizza is a popular pizzeria known for its delicious, authentic New York-style pizzas. The restaurant uses high-quality ingredients and traditional recipes to create its pies, which are cooked in a wood-fired oven to give them a crisp, lightly charred crust.

In addition to its classic pizzas, Tenafly Pizza also offers a variety of specialty pies, as well as salads, subs, calzones, and other Italian favorites. Many customers appreciate the restaurant's friendly and accommodating staff, as well as its casual, laid-back atmosphere.

We tried dinner grilled chicken, dinner grilled shrimp, lobster tail, and large cheese pizza. We enjoy the food and the atmosphere.

Dine In. Large portions a s attentive and knowledgeable staff. Enjoyed veal piccata and a wonderful side salad! Great dressing. Loved the warm bread to start!!

Almost as good as the original Rudys!
Very good pizza with crunchy crust, good mozzerella and sauce.. so so so close to the best Rudys! We ate inside during the stupid lockdowns of 2020. No masks! We were able to sit down and eat like normal human beings with no masks! Very good! The dinning room is nice. They have lots of tables. Comfy leather seats. Free yummy bread made fresh and hot.

Pros:
Great pizza, almost as good as Rudys
Free yummy bread, fresh and hot
Free parking
Indoor dinning
No masks!
Friendly employees!
Good menu selection

Cons:
None

Suggestions:
Buffalo wings were a bit too hot. Maybe add plain fried wings and a sweet dipping sauce like Grant St or Rudys.
Please add Joes Tea (raspberry, lemon, peach)
And please add diet rootbeer and diet dr pepper

Food,service and atmosphere are great! Been coming here quite often. Some of the reviews are truly entertaining on this site. If you eat pizza from a gas station you should be disqualified from reviewing any type of food, period! Red flag….

I don’t usually write reviews but I noticed a few one star reviews within a few hours of each other. I e been coming here for the last two years and I can tell you that those reviews are FAKE! Too many similarities and all BOGUS! The food, atmosphere and service are top notch. These clowns are just stupid trolls. Sorry they have nothing better to do.

Great food, Amazing Service. Hands down the best restaurant in town. I was shocked to see that some people left a negative review. I would question the legitimacy of those individuals and reviews.

The food here is amazing! It’s like eating at grandmas on Sunday. Everything is fresh & nice size portions. You can’t go wrong here.

Amazing place. The food was great, we had Chicken Parm Hero and Eggplant Rollatine. The atmosphere is nice and the people that work there bring it all together. I travel quite a bit and love to find hidden gems and TPR is definitely one of those places.

Their pizza has improved tremendously since the change in ownership. I haven't tried their other dishes but they make a good pizza pie which are better than the other options in Tenafly and Cresskill.

It's fast and they have friendly workers.

I have been eating at TPR since my grandfather took me as a young child and now that I have moved back to the Tenafly area it’s the only place I want to go to get pizza, pasta, chicken parm and salads!!! So glad it’s still around and even better than I remember!!!

We had an 85 year old birthday party here my my dad! Food was excellent as well as the service. They were accommodating and very attentive to our needs. Food came out fast and even with a large crowd everyone had their dishes within a couple of minutes!

Very tasty pizza came to town for work for 1 day and after 16 years with out coming to jersey I really wanted had to have good NJ pizza and this place did not disappoint I really enjoyed it next time I'm in town most definitely will be coming back

The service is amazing and the food is absolutely outstanding I had the lobster ravioli and the crabmeat stuffed shrimp they have a full bar available berr and wine .... this place is a must!!

The service was excellent. The manager and staff are extremely attentive. The food was very good. We hadn't been there for a while and were pleased to find out that their famous Marinara Sauce was the same. Bravo for the teamwork of the staff that made our dinner a memorable one.

Always great pizza here. Will try the calamari soon., and still very good quality pizza (May 2019). Here is a large with mushrooms and onions. This pizza disappears very fast.

Been going here since the 1980s, great place with such a great atmosphere.

Yes it's a pizzeria, but, what great food, fish, Italian specialties, from the hot bread, tossed salad to there tasty food prepared only with olive oil. Their steamed mussels in white wine are fabulous.

I've been coming here since I was a little kid and I never grow tired of the place. Excellent service, delicious food, and warm, family-friendly atmosphere. If you're visiting, make sure to stop by!

The best Sicilian pizza. The staff are very nice and friendly. It's clean and I've never had to wait for my food.

Small and cosy. Outstanding service. We felt home here. The food was excellent. I might drive down here just to experience this again. Ask for Mr. Cesar. ! 10/10 Service guys. Thank you for taking care of my family.