McCrum's Bakery

We ordered our daughter’s birthday cake here last week and it came out amazing! Exactly how we wanted and tasted absolutely delicious we could not have been happier they were extremely busy when we went in to order and still took the time to take our custom order when other places told us they could not do what we were asking and the price was better than what I have paid at the supermarket! we will definitely be back for all our special occasions thank you so much McCrum’s bakery!

I just want say how thankful I am for Randy and the cakes/treats he has done for my family. Randy is simply the best in what he does. He literally makes my vision come to life on the custom cakes he has made for me. Not only do they have amazing cakes but their pastries are also fresh and tasty. Try the pies too! Everyone you come encounter with at this place are super friendly and professional. I highly recommend them!

Can't say enough how much I loved my custom order cake. Not only did it look amazing and exactly how I wanted it to look, but it tasted amazing ! I knew I didn't want an ordinary vanilla or chocolate cake and instead went for a walnut w/orange mouse and everyone loved it. Really a great cake and ill definitely order again for my twins christening soon.

McCrum’s Bakery is my go-to bakery. We moved almost an hour away, but still ordered my daughter’s birthday cake from McCrum’s. It was beautiful and delicious. The girls at the party were so excited to see the pink strawberry cake when they got a slice. Thank you for making the day special!

This bakery usually requires 3 weeks in advance to place an order. They took my order even though they were fully booked on a Friday and Sunday morning my cake was ready for pick up. I’m so grateful. Randy provided exceptional customer service and the cake was delicious. Ohhhh and my son loved it! Best cake I’ve had in all Jersey & I’m not BS!!! This will be my go to for every occasion and you can’t beat their prices!

Happy Holidays and THANK YOU!! No time to bake this year. I stopped buy and bought a pound cake and cookies..WOW!! taste and quality is no different then home baked.. No need to bake ever again! I can't stop eating them.. rugelach and pecan balls are addictive!

We ordered cake, cake pops and cupcakes for our daughter baby shower. Everything looked so beautiful and elegant. But tasted even better! Cake was star of the party. Fresh, light, tasty. Thank you so much 👏

Recently had a cake made for my sister's baby shower. Came out beautiful. Freshly made that morning. Moist and delicious. Was able to get a diff flavor for each tier. Very reasonably priced!

The best decision ever i took was this one for my son's 1st birthday. I wanted to celebrate his birthday with and under the sea theme and i was struggling to find a bakery who can give me exactly wat i wanted. I asked so many bakeries but everyone gave their suggestions and to compromise with the cake with buttercream instead of fondant design. But i was not ready to compromise on it and thats when i found randy, he is an amazing guy and a very understanding and active listener too just like how every customer wishes for. HE MADE THIS CAKE POSSIBLE. Im so happy that i chose this bakery and its completely worth it. The cake tastes soooo good and all my guests were awestruck by seeing the cake and by tasting it. Thanks to randy. 🤟😃

This was my first time coming to this bakery and they did such an amazing job with our cake we will definitely be coming back here. The cake was beyond beautiful and was very delicious.

Can’t say enough good things about this place! They made a gender reveal cake for me in less then a days notice! And they were the only bakery willing to dye the actual cake blue or pink.. not just the buttercream inside. First picture is the inspiration picture and the second is the one they made for us. Perfection!

On a whim I called McCrum's for my sister's bridal shower and I'm so glad I did! The man on the phone was so incredibly helpful as I had no idea what I was looking for. He worked with me creatively and was open to all ideas I had. I ended up getting a two-tier red velvet cake and specified that we did not want fondant and he said no problem at all. The order was put together in under a week (again, no idea what I was doing) and was beautiful and so unbelievably delicious.This was the most delicious red velvet cake I think I've ever had in my life, my sister is still talking about this tasty cake two weeks later. Excellent job, definitely will be using McCrum's in the future!

We ordered our daughter’s 1st birthday cake from McCrum’s and it was adorable and delicious! The best!! If you want a beautiful birthday cake, this is the place to go!!

This was my first time ordering and I am so happy with purchase. The cake looked amazing 🤩 and was oh so delicious!!!!!

McCrum’s always does an amazing job on any cake order you give him. He is always personable and reasonable. I needed a cake for my daughter’s admission into the National Honor Society. He knocked it out of the park! We were so impressed. My daughter was ecstatic and loved it so much. The cake as always was delicious too!

I've lived in EP my whole life and am so glad McCrums is here in town. I've never had anything from here before but my mother in law from Wood-Ridge says they have the best black and white cookies. For mother's day, we got her a custom black and white cookie cake. I ordered it on Wednesday morning, completely forgetting about mother's day that weekend and was so thankful to hear they could accommodate my order. I've heard nothing but great things about this bakery and am so happy to say they're true. They have a great selection of goodies, and while picking up the cake, I also got a box of mixed cookies and a chocolate chip muffin-so fresh, delicious, and fluffy! I'll definitely be coming here for baked goods more often. The gentleman I interacted with over the phone and while there picking up my order was so nice, attentive, and very considerate. Highly recommend!

Really the best cake I ever had

We got a Baby Shark birthday cake for my son’s second birthday. It was DELICIOUS! Not only did it taste amazing, it was also a work of art! My son loved the cake and so did his little friends. We will be using McCrum’s bakery from now on definitely for any bakery items we need. Thank you for the special Birthday cake !

I have nothing but all wonderful words to say about this place . I don’t know how their cake taste but I do know that customers here are very valued, which is the biggest part of any business. I had ordered a baptism custom cake 3 days before my daughter baptism . Set it all up exactly how I wanted, canceled other 2 bakeries even for less money because this place promised to do all I ordered exactly the way I wanted . The night before the baptism I came to pick up my cake just to be told : “ what cake ?” I can’t even describe the devastation and the emotions that I was having at the moment since it was 7:30 pm on a Friday night while realizing I have no cake. I ran to the local store to pick up a cute looking but not custom cake and no one to even wright a name on it. I was looking through the local bakeries almost all night to find this one that opens super early and there I went to try to salvage my cake , somehow. Ofcourse I didn’t expect a new cake 3h before the baptism but the baker, and I’m assuming the owner , offered to spruce it up by making the righting on The cake on the spot free of charge, though he was in the middle of a lot of cake orders to be made for today..And thigh i didn’t get my cake the way I wanted snd only got the pretty righting on another stores cake , I’m grateful from the button of my heart that he saved the day and my broken heart from the other bakery . Someone else might’ve turned me away being that it was last minute, them being busy or not their cake. This is a true definition of a customer service and a local small business that strives and cares. I will definitely come back .

Amazing!! I can't say enough about this place...first of all, the pastries are to die for. The bear claws and Apple turnovers are a must..i also ordered a monster cake for my sons birthday. The cake came out amazing! The price was great compared to other places and the taste was absolutely indescribable. I went for a second piece. Not too sweet, just right! Also the owner and the staff are super friendly. I definitely recommend this bakery. You wont be disappointed!