Pet Supplies Plus Fair Lawn

This is a hidden gem. Ive brought all my dog food from here. The staff and managers are very helpful and they always give you the matched price. Thank you 😊 🙏🏾 💓

Clean store, staff is very friendly and always ask if I need assistance. Always offer to help bring my items to my car if it's too heavy. Good prices and good options

The staff are helpful and friendly, my cats like the Mittens brand cat food and it's healthier than some brands

This is my first time visiting this location, I was greeted warmly by the three employees when I entered the store.I looked online and they had the fish tank supplement that j needed I was so happy to find it local! They were quick to help with my questions! I ended up getting some fish too and they were mostly on sale. Their tanks looked great with happy fish and nothing dead. I found some wonderful fish and snails to add to my community tank. The woman who helped me got them quickly without chasing them with the net which stresses them out. I am very happy with my purchase!

A local pet store that is convenient and has people that can actually help you find what you're looking for.

The staff at this place are always so friendly, they treat myself and my dog Cooper very well. Anytime I go in to buy a large bag of dog food, someone always asks me to help carry it out to my car. Support local places like this.

Great place- I bought 4 glowsmart fish and a new tank with all supplies needed to care for our new members of our family- it’s been 3months since I was there— I am extremely satisfied with the customer assistance and help from the staff-
Great place perfect timing and great customer service- thank you to the team and staff- Have a blessed Day -

I recently had my 11yr old dog Molly groomed by Cyan. She did an awesome job. When I dropped Molly off she was definitely scared but Cyan introduced herself & asked if she could pick her up. She was so gentle and did an amazing job with the grooming. Molly will definitely be going back. I got there a little early & there was another groomer already working on a dog. She was doing a great job too. All the groomers there do so much to make the dogs feel comfortable.

We go for the vip vet on Sundays. Reasonable prices, no schedule in advance, nice people

Manager was awesome and so attractive to our needs. Helped us out and took his time explaining what I needed to know.
Thank you again for your help.
BTW we were coming from the state of Delaware, we don't have this store near us
Everyone here was awesome.

Sianna was so helpful!! Called to see if there was any information for adoption and it couldn’t have been sweeter!! Amazing place and lovely people!! 10/10! Thank you!!

I'm new to area. Convenient location. Carries all the products i need. I use weruva cat food snd unless I order it online, its not available at most stores. Well...its here and much more. Staff is polite, professional and helpful. Ready to answer any questions. They also price match. Store is clean and inviting. I recommend this store.

Great prices and a wide selection of products

Pet Supplies is my "go to" destination because I can always count on the staff. Fair Lawn and Oakland have outstanding personnel who are happy to be there and want to help you. Stocking of inventory, even during pandemic or the current supply chain issues, is very good. They are rarely completely out of stock of any single item. 5 stars!

Great store! a lot of pet products! Great customer service!! everybody was nice and kind!!!
We accidentally found the store 1 day after our 1st time online order (1st time shoppers) and met Tessa the store manager.
She was very informative and helpful! can't wait to come back (with Skye) and shop for more stuff(:

I ordered for pick up and as soon as I entered it was right there waiting and ready. Love buying my girls their food from here because it's always in stock.
Friendly people too!

I bought 2 Guinea Pigs here and I could not be happier. The service was wonderful and they know their stuff!! I am confident in and trust their input. Jenelle was especially helpful to us and made the experience really great. Thank you, Jenelle !

Great prices, great selection and amazing staff! After a long day of work i used to dread having to go back out for cat food, but honestly the evening managers (Matt and Christine) happily go out of their way to help compare products, match competitors prices, place special orders.
Love the sense of community in this store and am always greeted with a smile from Noah or Shirley.

Extremely satisfied with help from the staff. Nicey was amazing! So helpful. Didn’t rush me. And was so patient with ALL of my questions! She is definitely my gold fish go to gal! Thanks so much!

We love our local PSP in Fair Lawn. The team there is always friendly and welcoming. They are around to assist us with everything from carrying a heavy bag of kibble out to the car or finding something on the shelves. We can bring our dog who has a great time when he comes with us and we apologize if he is sometimes too quick in grabbing those low lying treats:-)