The Paper Store

Not a Hallmark store, but have Hallmark cards. They don't accept Hallmark membership, but you can sign for theirs.
This a big store with loads of gift options for all ages and all events. Their inventory includes cards, mugs, toys, home accessories, clothing, boutique, and many more.
They keep a huge collection of seasonal items too. The store very clean, well maintained inventory, and plenty of associates around to help. The check out lines were moving fast for us, as they had three counters open. One of my go to places for buying gifts.

They have very comfy rocking chair! My kids love that place.

ALYSSA at the paper store was incredibly helpful. I knew this would be a great store for bulk gift shopping. However I needed some direction with what to get for my kids teachers and Alyssa came to the rescue! Super knowledgeable on sales and made wonderful suggestions.

Beautiful store. Has a lot of different items. Fun to shop in

PROS: Their quality, the neatness, and most importantly their nice staff is what keeps me coming in here. They are a Hallmark branch and carry all of their products. This is one store I would not walk past

CONS: Everything tends to be overpriced even for it's good quality and they never seem to get anything new in the store

OVERALL: If you're the type of person that likes souvenirs and gift ideas come to this store if you don't mind paying the price

Pricey but great selection

This isn't a store for paper products, as the name implies. Good for Squishmallows and other toys for kids, in addition to pre-printed cards.

I expected more high quality greeting cards here and less random trinkets.

I spent a little under $100 on a few items, which I don’t mind doing so as I do like their products. As I was paying I was told by the man cashing me out, that they were out of bags with the exception of small bags and the really large bags. My comment was, with the price of the products in the store….you would think that bags are always available. His response, “Macys and many other stores in NJ do not give bags out anymore” funny because prior to shopping in the paper store I had been to Macys and walked out with a paper bag….so I walked out with my purchases some in a tiny bag and other in my hand…I open my car door and yep!! They all fell to the ground.
I get if I’m not expecting a bag or the option to pay I will choose to take my own..but to be expected to pay their high prices and carry out without. Bag…. Bye paper store

The way they treat customers is the worst. I bought cute newborn socks to give as a Christmas gift. While I was wrapping it up, I realized that I paid $8.99 when the tag says $6.99. I had no choice but gift the sock, and thought that if I took a picture of the receipt, it will be okay. But, boy was I wrong, for $2 bucks, they made me feel like I was getting back $200 bucks. One of the manager was just totally giving me the eye and telling me that they can’t do anything at all since I didn’t have anything. I mean, if she just said in a nice tone, it would have been okay.. I knew that it was my fault for not checking it when buying the item. But the way she was talking without even an apology, I felt like I was being scolded. I guess it was my fault trusting the store to have the right pricing. I should have double checked. It was one of my favorite store to look around in, but I guess I will never be back in there. Honestly, everything in the store is over priced too. So, make sure to look for the same item elsewhere first.