Chicago's Pizza Columbus

We were in a room reserved for our group. Our first time here, but the pizza was hot and good. We had traditional crust 'All Meat' 'Windy City' (sausage, green peppers, onions), & 'Cheese ' pizza's. All good, but my fav was the 'All Meat' pizza. The flavor of bacon just adds the perfect touch.

Great selection on buffet! I always eat too much. Sweet tea is amazing! Salad bar is huge but kinda difficult to use. Love the $12 lunch buffet!!

ETA for pickup order was 6:40, pizza was ready by 6:25. Service inside was good, I was asked by 3 different employees if I had been helped.
The pizza was great. "The Island" pizza sounds strange with the cinnamon on top but don't be a wuss like my brother, it was awesome.

Very good pizza and pasta! Our server was friendly and doing her best on a very busy night. The restaurant is very clean and well maintained. Also a great partner to local places with their fundraising opportunities. Very accommodating for a book club as well.

Server was very nice, service was prompt. All the food came quickly and exactly as ordered. The kids really liked the pepperoni breaksticks - they were actually breadsticks stuffed with cheese and pepperoni, not just pizza crust without sauce like many other places.

This is our regular pizza place. Staff is always friendly, efficient and does an excellent job taking our orders and getting our food to us quickly, excellent service on refilling our drinks also, plenty of seating even when busy

Excellent salad bar and pizza. However, being able to enjoy my favorite beer, Hog Molly (IPA) makes this place truly special.

This place has the best pizza I have ever had delicious 🤤 can’t say that enough you guys are rocking awesome and kudos to the cook and the ladies working the register on New Year’s Eve night. 🎊🤤🎊🎊🎊🎊

Great pizza, $23 for huge pizza and garlic bread yummmmm

We came in around 7:00 p.m. and we were treated with a smile and seated outside to enjoy the warm April air. The deep dish pizza was fabulous and the salad bar was phenomenal. We had a terrific evening and a great price. Thank you Chicago"s Pizza.

Good service, great pizza at a really good price.

Great place for lunch. Always busy.

Small buffet with decent salad bar and friendly service. Food was fresh and kept refilled. Selection was slim unless requested but still excellent option for a quick affordable lunch

This place is awesome! The buffet is delicious, but only lasts 11-1:30. Everything is just so good! Bread sticks, cheese sauce, cheese bread, pizza, salad... it's all so dang good! Prices went up after covid, but also now includes your drink in the buffet price. I make it a point to come here every time I'm in town, which sadly isn't often. But this place is great!

This is the best Chicago's in the area. Idk why, but all the others around here don't taste like the Chicago's i grew up eating. But this one tastes like it's supposed to taste. Great service. N haven't ever had to wait over 30 min for my order.

Best BBQ chicken pizza anywhere. Very good.

Kennedy and Kiersten our the best servers around. They always take great care of my wife and I. Topped off with great food! all around great experience every time.

Outstanding food and cheap prices. My family all shared pizza, spaghetti and a sandwich. They were all delicious. Can’t wait to go back. Highly recommend!!

Went for the lunch buffet with some coworkers. Everything was hot n fresh on the bar. Salad bar was clean and well maintained. Pizza was delicious! Had any kind of pizza that you could want!! Was really impressed that they have the jalapeño nacho cheese on the bar as well!!!! Awesome!

I gave 3 stars for atmosphere only cuz they were playing Fox news on the tv and there was a larger party of people across from us talking politics rather loudly. But that is NOT Chicagos fault. Just made it hard to have a conversation with our table.

I think this is the best pizza in town. It has quality toppings and you can get a one trip salad bar at a bargain. The service is always excellent. The atmosphere in cleanliness is always a+ plus