AJ's Pizza Co

Go for the thin crust and the bread twists. Service and atmosphere and food were excellent, but per my taste the red sauce is a little too sweet.

Really great experience! Excited to come again and again!

The service is the reason for 5 stars. Casey was incredible. She was attentive and focused. Sarcastic and funny as well.

The salads were good, great dressings. The wings were okay, the sauce wasn’t hot (temperature wise). The pizza. I highly recommend you get the thing crust and that you ask for extra crispy! The people could of been cooked more.

The desserts were amazing! The cheesecake was my favorite!

Great employees make great restaurants. The food is only part of it. We’ll done AJ’s!

Pizza was good. Arguably a little undercooked. I’d recommend that you ask for yours extra crispy.

Salad was basic, the croutons were mid. For sure came out of some kind of packaging. They were tiny which was kinda cute tho.

The chocolate cake was actually really good tho. Like to die for good.

Our waiter was what made this review 5 starts. Fantastic service. Casey took the time to get to know us. That was awesome.

An absolute banger of a joint. Fantastic wings, great staff, and what keeps me coming back is their rotating beer selections. I consider myself a beer geek, and they stump me and gas me up discovering new brews!

A wonderful “home town” pizza place in an upgraded location. Very friendly waitstaff. They have the usual pizza place offerings with a fantastic craft beer selection and delicious gluten free crust option.

We visited friends in the area and they brought us to AJ's. We loved it! The pizza had just the right amount of sauce, cheese, and toppings! We also had bread sticks that were very delicious. Our server was very friendly and did a great job!

Such a fun and inviting atmosphere. Pizza was amazing! Staff are all friendly and while busy, still attentive and having fun! The owner was engaged and helping staff. She was also talking with guests like they are family even when never seeing them before!
Definitely a must visit!

OMG. This place is amazing !!! There was nothing we got that was not exceptional. Fabulous flavors in their beef. I got the Garlic steak, Hubby got the Italian combo, and the BBQ mac n cheese. Plus we grabbed a Pizza to go. our bread twist app was so soft and yummy !!! Our service was great, as every single waitress, not just your own, asks if all is good, every time they walk past you. Definitely will be back here !!!

Always good pizza! Definitely one of our favorite spots, and love trying new things on the menu. Most recent visit I indulged on the recommendation of the Portabella Mushroom sandwich and it was absolutely delicious! Side of au jus hit the spot. Husband couldnt decide between the meatball sub or the chicken sandwich, got half orders on both, and was very happy he did! We come here at least once a month and even reserved their private room for our baby shower! The staff is always great and their seasonal drink specials are perfect!

All was fantastic from a food and atmosphere perspective. When the bartender poured straight vodka over ice for a martini and then told my wife that's the way you are supposed to make them, it gave me room for pause. Ever heard of vermouth? Then, she ended up charging us for it even though we sent it back...Service in America, what a fleeting idea.

After walking the trails at Coffee Creek, my friend and I went to AJ's. I've gotten carryout from there before, but never have dined in, and friend never had AJ's at all. We had a wonderful experience. Food, fantastic. Service, fantastic. Wonderful surroundings with TV's to watch sports on. There's a bar there too, if you wanted to sit there. Highly recommend!

My family and I have been going to AJ’s for YEARS, ever since I was a little kid. I have introduced numerous other people to the business, and everyone has positive things to say about it. I was passing through town with some coworkers of mine and told them to check it out, one of the guys said that out of all the pizza he’s eaten all across the country, it is the best pizza he’s ever had. He took pictures and everything. I have introduced people who are New York pizza snobs to this place, and they like it. This is THE local pizza place to go to. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed.

Had my small baby shower here recently and it was great! The private room was really nice and spacious, plenty of room for the kids to hang out without running into adults too much! The pizza was really good and sooo inexpensive. We will definitely be having more parties here in the future.

Lived in the area for years and this was our first visit. Appetizer and pizzas were very good. Crust was light and flavorful, toppings were well balanced. The Italian sausage was a bit overwhelming for my tastes but didn't completely ruin the experience. The chocolate cake with the caramel was fantastic, as was the Italian lemon cake my wife had. Solid place.

Best pizza in NWI hands down! My family can't get enough of the bread twists either. Great menu selections, awesome service, and super friendly staff. High 5 AJ's! You knock it out of the park every time!

The food was delicious, the Grafefruit Sangria to die for and service was excellent! Alicia our server was kind, attentive and great! Will be back. This place is worth the trip!

Wouldnt even know it was there. Not your classic pizza fast food chain. With a full service bar. This place is a gem of good hospitality and finger food. The boom boom sauce and fried ravioli were beyond perfectly cook and came out piping hot.

Always a good experience here! Got the pizza of the month for January, the pierogi pizza as well as a sausage and mushrooms! Both delicious. Always love trying the pizza of the month!!

We had a family birthday celebration in the back room. Food was great ... don't forget the fried pickles and fried green beans with some pizza's! Great service, food and drinks.

We've been customers of AJs for years. No complaints at all. Always our go to for pizza :) but everything else is very good also!