The Judge & Jury

The Judge & Jury never disappoints!

Today I enjoyed a pretty hearty Reuben Sandwich at lunchtime. The smoked meat was piled high and delicious. It was huge and I was unable to eat the whole thing.

Love at first visit and I've already gone back four times! This place is hands down the best restaurant/pub/bar in all of Halton region! The staff, the impeccable food, cozy atmosphere and large portions!!! Wowwww! Dale, Leah, Holly, Madison..just some of the staff I've chatted with! Great people, great place! This is a hidden gem in my opinion and it sucks they don't have more locations!

Went to this place on a whim for the first time yesterday with my bf. It was pretty busy (would recommend a reso for a party larger than two) but it is so cozy and well decorated inside x the staff was super friendly from hostess to server. The menu is great and the food was really good. We got the roast beef yorkies and the chicken wings and it was large portions and really tasty. The Guinness on tap is extra cold as well. Will 100% be making this part of our regular rotation! Thank you :)

Fantastic first experience at Judge & Jury. Very friendly and attentive staff. Among us, we had the Beef dip, Bacon Cheeseburger and the special, Thai Coconut Shrimp Tacos. All three were very delicious (no leftovers...) and the portions are very good. We tried both sweet potato fries and regular fries. Both were tasty, but I always prefer sweet potato fries. There are lots of beer choices on tap and two ciders as well. Angry Orchard cider went very well with my shrimp tacos. Very good value and a great pub vibe.
Highly recommended! Looking forward to the next visit.

Great hidden gem of a neighbourhood bar. The chicken wings (lightly dusted) was the perfect amount of crispy and the wings were super juicy. The Montreal smoked meat sandwich was delicious and flavourful.

A smallish, cozy 100% pub. Lynsey was our server, and she was the best. There are so many amazing menu items, and Lynsey took us on a menu tour. Excellent dinner!! Best fish tacos. Terrific beer selection. Our first time, but we will be back! Thank you, Lynsey!

Came Friday evening for a birthday get together. There were 8 of us so we waited for a table and it was well worth the wait. Excellent food excellent service and can’t say enough about our server. She was beyond amazing. Coming from the Falls it’s so worth the drive. Can’t wait to come back real soon.

Dale at the bar is amazing. The Yorkie are the best I've had since my Grandma passed away! The fish is moist and the chips are cooked just right. Portions are very plentiful!

We decided to order food from here for a recent birthday celebration.
It was our first time trying this restaurant.
We are very happy with the food we received!

We ordered a few different entrees and two different salads; the Judges Cobb salad and the Greek salad.

I am happy to say that all of our food was very well prepared and delicious! The portions were very large, and the food was excellent overall.

I would definitely recommend The Judge and Jury to anyone reading this review.

Here is the Cobb salad:

Enjoyed some delicious gluten-free, beer-battered fish & chips! The fish was tasty, pulled apart easily, and paired nicely with the gluten-free batter that just melted in your mouth. The fries were cooked to perfection and the coleslaw tasted fresh. The turtle cheesecake for desert was scrumptious & satisfied my sweet tooth. Would definitely return to try out other menu items - especially on Mondays as everything is gluten-free, celiac-friendly on Mondays. The waitresses were very friendly & the service was super quick. I would definitely recommend this restaurant.

My wife and I just had lunch here, our server was awesome , recommended I try the Shepherds pie , it was the best I have ever had and my wife had the Greek salad with chicken and shrimp, she could not stop raving about how fresh it was, she also commented on how clean the restrooms were. Really and enjoyable experience at the Judge and Jury today

The fish and chips are my go to, tried the burger and poutine this time, and it did not disappoint (I like my burger less well done, but such is life in Canada)

Fantastic spot for lunch or dinner. It has a great English style pub atmosphere. We went for lunch today for the first time and it was great. Wife had the Nashville chicken sandwich and I tasted, it was juicy and not too spicy. I had the bacon cheeseburger and to my surprise it was one of the best pub burgers I’ve had in a very long time. I will absolutely be returning the try the rest of the menu.

We had Patti as our server. She was excellent. Very attentive and friendly. She made our meal very enjoyable because she paced everything appropriately. The food was excellent and we loved the wine list. We highly recommend the Judge and Jury because of excellent food, great ambiance and excellent service. It is our go to place to relax and have a great dining experience.

We just visited for the first time for gluten free Mondays. The service was friendly & welcoming, the food was exactly what you would expect from a typical pub- delicious fries, fish, burgers and shepherds pie! What makes this place stand out is that it is celiac friendly. Our 2 year old daughter was recently diagnosed with celiac disease and with all the lifestyle changes we have made as a family, giving up eating out at restaurants has been a tough one. Her and her siblings were so happy to be out eating again, thank you to the restaurant and all who work there that have made GF Mondays possible! You all rock!

I have heard so many great reviews about the Cobb salad, so decided to give it a whirl, also added grilled chicken, which is not shown in the picture, but was also moist and flavourful. And treated myself to cauliflower bites on the side. Needless to say, I have a few leftovers for tonight as well. Will definitely be ordering the Cobb again, all of the reviews are spot on. Great job😀

The food was fantastic, especially the burger. Would recommend the double if you're really hungry. Quick, friendly service and very reasonably priced. Plenty of parking. Will definitely come back in the future.

Myself, and two friends celebrated our birthdays, and it was our first time at the Judge and Jury. Patty was our waitress and she couldn’t be more helpful. Telling us in detail about the menu and the quality of the food and she did not disappoint us. The food was delicious. The atmosphere was very much in the style of a small British pub. Even though it was full House, you were able to carry on a conversation. I will definitely be referring and returning. Thank you for an enjoyable evening.

Hubby and I had a wonderful experience today! We haven’t been in a while. I’m so happy to be back!! My favourite place for food. Everything I’ve ever had has been delicious!
Today we started with the Buffalo cauliflower bites. Yummy! My hubby had the Judge’s chicken sandwich. Holy moly that sandwich was huge and very tasty! For myself, I had the Buffalo chicken wrap with sweet potato fries. It was divine!

Our server, Inzo was absolutely wonderful! We found out, we were his first table ever! Nothing but great feedback. Inzo is really attentive but not too attentive, if you know what I mean, and really personable.
I don’t think I’ll be waiting six months to head back here.
Thank you to the Chef’s as well! Honestly, best pub fare ever!!

We will be back soon!

Awesome pub atmosphere, classic black & tan pints, attentive service from seasoned servers, very good food selection.