The Picky Picky Resale Shop

We are from out of town, but went in here for the fun of it, and believe me, its fun in there. I found so many things I wanted to go home with and hubby had to carry out for me. This place has everything. If you get in the area, stop in. and dont be shy, ask about items.

Awesome store. Cashier very friendly
Anything and everything for good prices.!! Very thankful to have worked out a good deal on a Thomas Kinkade.

I've known the owner Henry for a long time and his store is THE COOLEST thrift store of its kind on The Planet Earth!!!
If you are looking for anything that pertains to video gaming or accessories, Picky Picky has it or else he can get it, believe me. His collectibles he has for sale are extensive and every time I visit the store he has something different from the past when I was a kid. Henry is one of the smartest guys I have ever known and his knowledge of his items is impeccable.
Lastly, Pickys' prices are unbelievable, at times I've had to ask Henry if the price is printed correctly. Please stop in and experience one of the best times you've ever had shopping in the ultimate place of business anywhere.
A. Reichel (Dangerous Toys)

where to start this store has everything and anything every time i have been in there i have bought something. there so much stuff there i would say it will take two or three trip to see everything great prices to i would recommend this store to anyone and everyone. they have everything from modern day game systems to old school antics lots of old beer signs and tons of vintage collectables from cabbage patch to old marvel comic they even had a few graded pokemon cards in there

I Got Some Cool Vintage KISS Band Merch Here. Workers are nice. Even got to talk to one of the guys behind the counter about The Band KISS while he was checking me out today. 10 Out of 10 Would Recommend To anyone who Likes Collecting Vintage Stuff.

Incredibly cool shop with great items at great prices. Staff is incredibly helpful, kind, and honest. Definitely going to be returning when I'm in the area!

This is such a cool shop for vintage toys, knives, music, and other things! The staff and owner are very pleasant and helpful! I definitely plan to go back!

All the employees here are very personable and professional. They are extremely knowledgeable and very willing to assist you. I highly recommend going in and browsing, you'll be pleasantly surprised.

I had a wonderful experience, first visit, inside the store of "The Picky Picky", not only with my interaction with the owner, but the plethora of products - in fantastic condition - the store has, and I'm looking forward to my next visit!

March 5, 2023: I cannot thank Larry, the employee, for his kindness, and just wonderful service. Kudos to him and the store. You HAVE to check it out!

Great merdandise. A cornucopia of everything and anything. Will barter, too!

And still awesome as ever! A must go.

This shop is one of the best! Prices are GREAT for such unique pieces. Purchased some great glassware and games for my son. It's also in an awesome historic building. You've got to go. Once you do, you'll be hooked.

The Picky Picky Shop is a Unique store. The employee that works there is really friendly and good guy. The owner is really cool also. I had a really friendly experience there. They have alot of unique cool stuff there. I bought an Xbox One S and a Turtle Beach headset and he even throw in a free game for a pretty good price. I would recommend for anyone checking the store out. Odds are you find something that you will like. He can even order something for you if he doesn't have it in and he will get the cheapest price for it and I belive he does even charge a fee for that.You never know what hidden treasures you might find there. Just check it out and see for yourself.

Never know what I'm going to find! Great store. Prices are negotiable..love it. Owner is very welcoming..

The owner has a lot of stuff in his one store front. There's a little bit of everything, including snacks for those of us who have been shopping at several shops. They have a table arcade game that my son and my husband fell in love with. Now he's on the search for one! Nice place, we'd stop by again if we were in the area.

Great staff and lots and lots of stuff to look through, very unique and interesting things to find, make sure to look in all the nooks and crannies there is stuff everywhere and you may miss a interesting find, I Stayed for over a hour just searching and enjoyed every minute of it. Thanks for letting me rummage through all your stuff.

Nice old style shop in downtown Waukesha. Reasonable and good owner solid to chat with about stuff. I guess fortunately I've never gone down there and seen they're closed when they should be open, so hopefully thats an rare/uncommon occurance?

Sometimes people (especially the "thrifters" whining in the reviews who only want to flip stuff instead of enjoying them) pick through certian types of items (especially sports related, games, vintage/nostalgia/memorabilia etc) but its worth stopping in to browse and see what they have.

I've gotten a few things I was debating caving and buying online for myself that thrifters want to overcharge for by stopping in when I'm downtown and found. Which was great.

So if you're in the area and want to kill some time its definitely worth checking out like I have. Making a day trip just so you can flip stuff online? Get out of bed before noon bro.

I wasn't sure what to expect going into this shop but was pleasantly surprised by both the staff and the items. A great collection of reasonably priced items and some of the most down to earth employees I've had the pleasure of doing business with. Will definitely be back!!

Henry and Greg are super nice guys! They were super accommodating and even offered to keep the store open late for us to browse.

We came all the way from Edgerton to shop here! Fantastic store.

Bad: Can't really think of anything
Good: One of the best places downtown, huge variety of stuff set out. If you're looking for something specific you're most likely to find it here. They have clothes, games, a million random knick knacks, etc. They even have junk food & ice cream. Everything is organized really well and the place looks very nice & clean. Staff is VERY kind and open to questions.
Tips: Best time to come is Friday Night Live imo because the whole town has better atmosphere. :)

Fun place to find unique gifts! They have games, shoes, movies, magazeens and alot of random things! Owner is very nice and he will let you play his videogames.