Gifts & More at The Paper Store

Staff, as always, friendly and helpful. Large selection of cards and many other items. Perfect for gift giving and decorating.

Revamped Store looks awesome! But what really made my experience great was the girl at the register. Her eyes made me speechless for a second! They were almost yellow! She was so beautiful and kind! I didn’t catch her name, but I hope I run into her again :)

I have been going to Hallmark for many years staring in NY, NJ and since 2001 here and I have always loved the products they carry. I do like the way this Hallmark (Paper Store) has a variety of items to chose from. I have always found the staff members I deal with to be friendly and helpful.

I really enjoy shopping at Amy's Hallmark store. The store is clean, organized, comfortable and nicely arranged. There are a variety of gift choices. Associates are so friendly and personable. I don't feel rushed and feel like I can take my time making card and gift selections. The products are reasonably priced and unique, especially during sales. I also, appreciate that they allow coupon stacking.

One year later, not the Hallmark I knew. It says Hallmark, but lacks Hallmarks customer service. Lots of gift items, but employees are not friendly, at all. I'll just buy my Hallmark cards someplace else.

Absolutely love the process for picking up ornaments ordered from wish list! Arrive for the appointed time and my order was ready to go - easy peasy.
6/2/23 - Hallmark rebranded as Gifts & More / Paper Store. Has moved around the corner from the old site. Beautiful, large, new store with lots of different items. Still carries Hallmark cards, ornaments, etc and honors Hallmark coupons.

I was very impressed with this place, and usually I don't think highly of Hallmark stores. They have great geeky gifts (star wars, Harry Potter, marvel, Disney etc.) With high quality merchandise. Plus a ton of others. I think you can find great gifts in there for almost anyone. A little less stuff for men though, although still some really good choices.

Great place to find the perfect card and gift.

I am handicapped and therefore use a walker or scooter when I am out of my home. This I share because this wonderful AMY"S HALLMARK STORE is VERY friendly, helpful and easy to navigate with my different walking aids!
The inventory is always plentiful and beautifully presented.
The staff at AMY"S HALLMARK STORE is very friendly, helpful, knowledgeable and never rushes or interferes with a "just looking" visit. Wherever we have lived, a Hallmark Store Location was just as important as the nearest Public Library! This one is the best and I live nearby!! I am fortunate.
Every time I am able to enjoy a shopping time to search for special cards for special people - This is my FIRST choice to hunt for that SPECIAL card or gift. Stop in and enjoy AMY"S HALLMARK STORE in Waterford Lakes Mall1

So much variety and fun things to choose from for any occasion!! Definitely a great selection of Christmas ornaments!! The staff is super friendly and always helpful!!!

Overall experience was cool they also offered coupons and I got a free card too. Visited the shop for a couple Valentines Day cards. Felt welcomed as a customer and thats always big with me. Thanks Hallmark.

Found a very nice pair of Pandora earrings for my Wife's birthday. The were very nice and let me take my time to find the pair I liked. I did also get a discount certificate for 20% off in June.

This is such a fun store! They have a wide variety of beautiful gifts and cards for any occasion. The staff is very courteous and helpful. Thank you.

Love the people working here, they're so nice and helpful especially during this time. Shout out to them!! 10/10 recommend the wood wick candles!

Friendly and helpful staff. Great place to shop. My go to Hallmark for Christmas ornaments every year.

Such a sweet shop. Friendly staff. Have been going here for a while now, and will continue to go for my card buying needs.

Went in to buy anniversary and Valentine's day cards. Found what I was looking for. My hands were full and staff was nice enough to help me out.

My friend and I went shopping..was a very pleasant experience..the lady working took time with us and answered all our questions and made suggestions..we greatly appreciated her help.

Great shop with lots of unique items in addition to an awesome card and ornament selection . Staff extremely helpful and friendly.

Big lots of things to chose from.

Great card selection