Stillwater Olive Oil Company

As an Italian I must say I felt like a kid walking into a candy store! Was pretty busy when I went, but I was helped quickly and the reccomended products I bought were excellent quality! The Tuscan herb blend paired very well with our home made garlic bread. Also, the walnut oil had exceptional flavor! Will definitely be back to try more varieties.

Side note: If you guys could source a high quality macadamia nut oil it would be very much appreciated:)

This cute store has a large variety of great olive oils and balsamic vinegars, and I appreciate that you can sample the products to see what you like and don’t like. There are several interesting and unique flavors that you can’t get anywhere else (that I’ve seen). The two times we’ve been here, the staff has been very friendly, helpful, and efficient. We really like and highly recommend the Tuscan Herb oil, the Garlic oil, and the Traditional 18 Year balsamic vinegar. I urge you to visit and try for yourself!

We’ve been going here for our olive oil needs for the past 5+ years. Both in person and online ordering are fantastic experiences.
The products are high quality, and not ones where you can tell they’re cutting corners. The olive oils have a good taste, and flavors stick with the oil over time.
Balsamic are similar.
The service is stellar and 2-4 team members always available if needed.
Will continue to give them new orders!
Thank you!

Their oils and vinegars are exquisite, and make excellent gifts. The staff are friendly and engaging. I never imagined that shopping for oils and vinegars could be so much fun. The shop smells so good, and it laid out very well. The stainless steel containers all lined up make for a simple and clean decor. Overall it is a good shop and we always enjoy it

A one of a kind place and experience. The women kindly greeted us immediately as we walked in the door. There are incredible vinegar and olive oil flavors that I never thought were even possible. They highly suggest trying as many as possible and that’s exactly what I did. A simple store with diverse flavor options.

There is a huge variety of oils and vinegars that you can sample and purchase here. The staff are awesome and helpful and the store is very clean and well organized.

Nice shop great product and staff. They have a large variety of extra virgin olive oils and balsamic vingers.

I went in November with my cousin and got some olive oils and balsamic vinegars in the small size. I fell in love with the garlic and just ran out yesterday, so I placed an order. It shipped the same day and was on my doorstep this morning! Everything was packaged safely and I didn't need to go without the garlic infused olive oil. Thank you so much for the fast shipping and the great products!!

My mother-in-law is a big fan. I went in to get her a gift and tried all kinds of different oils and vinegar. I had no idea such variety existed..from REALLY spicy to sweet...Mary was great and was excited to have my try various samples. I ended up getting the lemon olive oil and raspberry balsamic vinegar...my MIL loved it!

The wide variety of olive oils and balsamic vinegars is incredible! Mixing and matching different flavors has been fun and has leveled up our meals so much! The employees are very knowledgeable, kind and helpful. Bekah has been my go-to resource there and her recommendations are always spot on!

They were so kind and gentle, they even gave us a gift for free, and each flavour of olive oil was different, i personally loved the spicy ones.

The oils and vinegar were wonderful to try. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable and we're excited to cook with our purchase.

We had such an amazing experience! The staff and owner were so welcoming, friendly, and helpful. They gave us suggestions, walked around with us, and helped us choose the most delicious balsamic vinegar and olive oil combination! We will definitely be back!!

Simply outstanding! This was the first store of its kind that I ever visited, which was some 10 years ago. Fell in love with their Tuscan herb olive oil. Have tried other Tuscan flavored oils from other companies… But none of them compared to Stillwater's! And they have some of the best prices that I have found, as well. Highly recommend!

I have visited a handful of time, and always leave with goodies. I live in Rochester, and this time ordered online. I cannot believe I got my order in 2 days, fabulous. I have already tried the plum flavor on my broccoli and hickory on my chicken breast last night, amazing as usual.

I would recommend anyone to Stillwater Olive Oil Company! Their customer service was outstanding and everyone was so helpful! I went into the store looking for gifts, but not knowing exactly what I was looking for. They helped me pick products out and it was exactly what I needed. I had to contact them about another product and they promptly returned my phone call. Great service and great products!!! Thank you!

The quality is superb. The customer service is superb. I have the larger bottles of the vinegar that I like . Bring in your larger bottles and get them refilled. Friday September 10 , I brought mine in. The young lady washed them, she fill them up for me gave me new stoppers and even put a nice seal over the stopper Just like it was brand new. I felt so special I'm so glad I come to you guys for all my needs. Thank you thank you thank you...

A wonderful array of olive oils, vinegars and more. Very helpful and friendly staff. My recommendation, buy the large bottle when you buy your products, it's worth the extra few dollars knowing you have a great product for cooking!

Stopped at this store while walking Main Street. It is a great store with very helpful staff. Many kinds of oils and vinegar. With the staffs help I bought some oil and vinegar. Let me say if I am ever in the area again this will be one of my first stops. Stop in you won’t be disappointed.

I always love coming here. The staff is great, prices are fair, and the product is amazing. This is legitimately the only place I will buy my specialty oils for cooking and my Balsamic Vinegars.