The Bagel Store

The owner showed me kindness. I tried to use apple pay but they did not have that service and I only had 6 dollars in cash. He waived the extra fee and said "Don't worry about it." They are very friendly and great bagels. Love the scallion cream cheese.

I discovered this place during covid working from home, it's now my go-to bagel place. The ladies provide great service and a smile on their faces. The bagels are always fresh and the prices are fantastic!

Always love coming here, bagels are made perfectly, and the wait time is much less than some other bagel places in the county. Staff is friendly, food is delicious, and I cant wait to go back

Hands down the best bagel shop in Monmouth County. Their bagels are worth every penny! Kettle bagels are a million times better than rack bagels!

I love their shirts! Super funny and nerdy! Oh yeah... The bagels are great and the employees are very nice and quick to get your orders done.

Good breakfast sandwiches. Nice verity of other treats and coffee. Quick service. Friendly staff. And happy to see they take care of our their first responders. 🚓

I may not be a frequent customer, but I am a loyal one. Your everything bagel is superb! Your staff is always polite when I place an order over the phone and come in for pickup.

My first time here today. I ordered a western omelette bagel sandwich. It was absolutely delicious. It was a big sandwich with plenty of ham and very flavorful. The staff is nice, and the temperature of the restaurant is cool and comfortable inside. I really like this place and I'll be spreading the word, for sure! Great job guys. All the best👍

Delicious Pork Roll & Cheese on a Bagel. Cooked exactly the way I wanted it. Staff is always helpful & pleasant. Pork Roll, Sausage, Bacon, Egg & Cheese is also delicious, & not drowning in grease like other places! (as per my partner).

Hands down the best bagels in Monmouth County. They are perfection! The classic PEC is a staple in my families weekend ritual and it hits the spot every time. The staff is SO friendly and organized even when it’s super busy. We appreciate this small business in the heart of Colts Neck and look forward to many more years of prosperity for them!!!

Took my phone order on a busy morning, and had it ready within 15 min, along w a solid iced coffee. DIY coffee condiment bar with coffee mate and different milks.

The 5 stars is for the bagel though - wow, it was enormous, and so well-seeded on both sides for an everything bagel, which is rare! $8.50 for lox spread and an iced coffee

Some of the most awesome bagels and staff! The owner is a really cool guy and cares about the experiences his customers have and seems to make things fun. The Everything Bagels are delicious as are their breakfast sandwiches. Yum!

Love this place!!

What can I say? Great bagels (I'm sure all their food is amazing, but I'm a bagel lover :p) Nice, friendly staff. Doing everything they can safely in these trying times. Highly recommend!!

The BEST bagel place ever. PERIOD. Even when I lived in NYC, I would still miss this bagel store. Wish I could go here every day. The jalapeno bagels with jalapeno cream cheese is so tasty and flavorful.

Nice people working here, I rolled in hungry 10 minutes before closing one day and they were starting to pack up shop for the day. Not wanting to inconvenience them on their way home I said I can go someplace else but the insisted they can make me a sandwich. It was a great sandwich on top of it all

They have the best bagels in Monmouth County! The women that work there are always so pleasant and happy to assist. Well deserved 5 Star Review.

Bagel from heaven. I've had alot of bagels in my life and the bagels here are by far the best I ever had. The perfect amount of softness and the the flavor was real tasty on the everything. I will definitely be a regular.

Best bagels around… Patti is the absolute best! Their work ethic is unmatched… always there day in and day out 💯

This place is part of my weekly routine that I will never miss. The bagels are great, the staff is great and the Instagram page is great.

The Bagel Store is hands down the best bagel and sandwich shop in the area. Their egg bagels are the best I’ve ever had. 10/10 recommend.