Out of This World Collectibles

Awesome store will definitely be making it a weekly stop. Found some cool memories and picked up a nice find.

Nice collectibles shop. Owner and staff were personable and conversational. While disappointed they didn't have any Magic: The Gathering items, they did have a huge assortment of most collectible toys from all different eras, and Pokémon.

- staff friendly and knowledgeable.

- place clean and organized even know it a little store.

- prices not bad for most items.

- store has a nice selection of different items for sale, you can also sell them certain items if they are interested in what you have.

Parking is not hard to find but a little limited if the area is busy.

- overall a nice little store to visit if you are into Funko's, action figures etc.

- I'd recommend this location.

Absolutely amazing store with tons of great collectibles.

Bought an item from them and noticed a part was broken at home, I took it back and they gave me the replacement and $10 as an apology. I will be going back often

James and Sonja are amazing. Friendly, family oriented business. I have been holding on to my childhood Star Wars toys for over 40 years. I know I took it to the correct place. James gave me a very fair deal for all I had, and even threw in a few Legos for my 5 year old son. I highly recommend going here if you are looking to buy or sell vintage toys.

Super friendly, pretty knowledgeable over a wide array of toys cards action figures etc. if you're looking for something particular he'll have no problem helping you find it.

Take a trip down memory lane at this fun little store! Get your nostalgia fix and then some.
Very reasonable prices and super friendly staff.
If you're a collector or just happen to be in the area it's definitely worth a visit.

My wife and I absolutely love this collectables store,The owner makes us feel welcome and his little dog boba fett is too cute not to pet. We have gotten our most prized items from here.

Absolutely love this store. It's located in downtown Pataskala and is such a neat find. My son loves the choose your own Legos by the pound bins and the Lego figure bin. Seeing the Spiderman outside made our day. Will be back to do a trade in or 3.

If you like the 80's toys, this place will take you back! Great shop and the owner is very, very helpful, knowledgeable and most importantly, friendly. My son and I will make more trips to this shop!

We love this toy shop! We make a point to stop in when we visit the area from ID. The people are amazing and very friendly. They are very knowledgeable. We love the furry little helper (They have a dog.) We have made it a yearly tradition to pop in. You never know what treasures you'll find there.

Picked up these two Star Wars collectible signs. Got to talk to the owner and play with their dog! They were welcoming and a pleasure to do business with.

Awesome selection of cool retro toys. Employees are super nice. Great deals.

Best Toy store in the Central Ohio and the surrounding area! hands down! I've been doing business with the owner for 25+ years and this store is the culmination of his many years of experience!
You will not find a more knowledgeable expert in the field.
The staff is friendly and helpful, the selection is always changing and always awesome! Be sure to check this store out!

Fantastic collectibles shop! Owner is very personable and knows his stuff! So much to look at in there! So worth the trip! You can even take pictures with Spidey out front!

This is one of those awesome stores if you are feeling a little nostalgic. The store owner is kind and super friendly/knowledgeable. They will pay a fair rate for vintage toys you may have laying around. Worth it to check this place out if you are looking for that specific piece from your childhood.

This place instantly took me back to my childhood. Nothing else matters when you walk into this store. The owners are so nice. What an incredible place to be to press pause on life, reflect on some of the best times of our lives and dream again. The Spiderman standing outside gives me life every time I pass it.

We’ve passed that spider man many times before I finally agreed to stop and explore the shop with my kiddos. I’m glad we did. My kids were encouraged to take good care of their toys and keep their Lego pieces together. They were taught a bit about the trade-in concept.

With help from the owner, was also able to secretly make a purchase behind their backs (for Christmas) because they were so into the many things to look at.

I’m sure we will be back!

Was pleasantly surprised by the selection in this shop. Glad I stopped buy. I recommend for anyone

Wow where do I start?! These are some of the best business owners out there! They love their customers and make sure every piece that comes through their shop is ready to go and for people to enjoy. They have such rare items and are so helpful while in the store. My family and I consider them good friends now! ❤ and thank you for always having batteries in the toys!