Sheridan's Frozen Custard

No matter hot or cold, i love a good ice cream and Sheridans is the perfect spot! they are open late night for those late night cravings & they are quick, friendly, & affordable!

Sheridan's has the best frozen custard around! I bounce between an Oreo concrete and a Razzle Dazzle, which is my favorite anywhere! Service is always fast and friendly. I also like that it's open all year round! That's when my wife and I eat in the car, which is not a problem. We'll keep coming back for a long time. Thank you!

I hadn't been to Sheridan's in at least 4 to 6 years. It was a chilly day but we enjoyed our ice cream! Best banana split anywhere around for sure! Phew! I love it here. I had almost forgotten how good that banana split was. I had hot caramel added to it. Yum!

Cery tasty!!!
I felt so bad for the guys inside, there were only two of them and the place was hopping! They seem angry tho. Good service and great custard!

Best custard hands down! The vanilla and chocolate are both delicious every time! Many toppings to choose from.

Consistently good every time. I would post a picture but I already ate it all. I always get the pie in the sky every time, I promise this is the best concoction of ice cream I've personally ever had. Warmed brownies, hot fudge, three scoops of vanilla custard, pecan bits and cherries. Amazing.

GREAT CUSTARD! Custard is a richer version of ice cream and WOW is theirs FANTASTIC. The crew is always friendly and STELLAR!

MY NEW FAVORITE PLACE! ❤❤❤

UPDATE - Taking out-of-town family there for the BEST ice cream in town! Still amazing! CRISPY Waffle Cones, homemade on site.

Yum. My current favorite is the Caramel Pretzel Crunch Concrete. Whatever I order is always good and staff is friendly and helpful.

UPDATE - August 2022, finally decided to try something new, the Mocha Wowieccino. While it's not my new favorite, it was pretty darn tasty and nice for times you want a "lighter" treat.

This place is fantastic! Their custard were delicious. Making custard is like works of art! Hope that place doesn't close down because it's amazing!

Best frozen custard around! I never get anything, but scoops of chocolate and vanilla in a waffle come because their ice cream is so good that I just want it by itself.

My son will always get the Wedding Cake concrete!! It is the best

Serving only vanilla or chocolate custard (no hand dipped ice cream flavors) with tons of toppings and combinations, Sheridans is always a delicious treat. Be sure to try the Pie in the Sky and share with a friend! It’s huge.

When I was in the USAF and stationed in Illinois I came across Sheridan's frozen custard. I absolutely fell in love with it. It is hands down the best frozen custard on the planet. Sadly we moved away and there is no Sheridan's near us. I am so happy to be back in the area for a few days and able to have my favorite frozen custard again. I had the Razzle Dazzle but with chocolate instead of vanilla. My husband loves their vanilla with pecans and caramel. My daughter got vanilla with caramel and pretzels.
I can't wait for our next visit!!!

I revealed the new baby to my family with the help of the staff! They really made it perfect, even the people sitting out enjoying their frozen custard as well.

Super cheap and amazing custard. Drawn back is that it is outside, so if it's a cool night it might make it uncomfortable. Still worth it through!

The most delicious ice cream and custard mom and pop walk up and drive thru we’ve ever been to in all our travels. Quick accurate service. Friendly staff. Good prices. Delicious desserts. I recommend to anyone going in the St. Louis area to stop and treat yourself.

Absolutely awesome. The best place for peanut butter shake. And butter pecan shakes. Thanks bill barber 👍,

Fast service. The salted caramel brownie concrete is a caramel lovers dream. The buckaroo is delicious also.

i have always loved Sheridans, many dates spent here ;) never one time i regretted getting Sheridans, super rich & creamy every time!

Very good frozen custard! Service was prompt. I had a hot fudge sundae with pecans. Pecans were super crunchy and fresh and the custard was excellent with the hot fudge. Prices are a little high compared to some of the other places like Culver's, but better quality.