The Wrestling Collector

MY MAN TOMMIE ALWAYS DELIEVERS!!! Greatest wrestling store in the East. Extremely professional and knowledgeable owner hell I got into wrestling because of him. Gives the best prices and deals for anything you could ask for pro wrestling and has given so much to his community and the people around him. He runs ISPW, 80's wrestling con, and the superstore itself The Wrestling Collector!! Amazing store and once in a lifetime items. I've never been disappointed anytime I've went to Tommies. Truly the best!!!!

I’ve ordered some signed memorabilia from this store a few times over the years and I’ve always been happy with the products they send. My last order hit a bit of a snag but I reached out to Tommy and he promptly corrected the issue. If you are looking for unique wrestling memorabilia then the Wrestling Collector is your place. Their Facebook pages are also chocked full of nostalgia from the “Golden Era” of wrestling.

Tommy is an amazing person and owner of this great store. (Yes we share the first name) this store has a ton of rock and wrestling items, I always end up buying something awesome! thanks for always having something cool dude!

What an amazing treasure! I made it back to the Wrestling Collector today. It has been about a year since I have been in the area and the store has changed a lot. Love the Wrestlefest Arcade game. When I make it big someday I am going to ask to buy it. I have been collecting Collusiem Videos and WWF magazines since the early 90s. So to walk in and immediately see PPV VHS tapes that I am missing made me realize this place is going in the right direction. Walking through the doors of the store instantly brings you back to your childhood. Today they had Royal Rumble 95 playing on the TV. Vince McMahons voice booming throughout the store.

This place has something for every age fan but particularly hits on the Golden Era-New Generation age group. They have LJN figures on the card in the back. The giant LJN Ring sure pulls my nostalgia strings and I might return to buy that someday.

Today the owner was not there so I had the chance to chat with the owner's mom. I bought Survivor Series 90 and Survivor Series 96 on VHS. She told me she is not the wrestling fan of the family but the owner is about my age so we shared amazing stories of remembering Survivor Series Thanksgivings and how wrestling memories play a big part of great memories with our Dad's/husband. We learned that the owners dad and my own passed days apart earlier this year.

I look forward to stopping in again next time I am close. New Jersey is so lucky to have WWF fans so amazing that they open stores like this. Thank you!!!!!!

(01/14/2023): First Time at The Wrestling Collector Store was Amazing. I Met Former IMPACT and WWE Superstar Mr. Anderson (FKA Mr. Kennedy and Ken Kennedy), AEW Dark Superstar Former RCW Angels Champion, PPW Champion and 1 Half of Mission Pro Tag Team Champion(s) Madi Wrenkowski and “The Neon Blondes” Dani Mo & Facade

I haven't been able to visit the shop in person yet but I made my first purchase recently and the quality of my order was excellent! I'll try to make it in to shop in person sometime for sure!

Amazing store. The owner is a great guy and he makes the experience so much better. Talks to you and has knowledge of every single product in the place. And genuinely helps you get what you need. I got some collectibles I haven’t seen before and he threw in a free autographed picture of jake the snake roberts for Christmas.

Tommy is an amazing owner and promoter. fantastic atmosphere and large selection at the store. He really looks out for the fans and not the dollars. Between his store and ISPW (check it out, great time) No one loves the industry more, and respects the roots of it than Tommy. If you're a wrestling fan, this is well worth the trip, especially for a special event.

A must visit for any fan past or present! The owner has created a great environment with merchandise, games, entertainment and in-store events. Truly worth checking out!!

This is a destination for any wrestling fan! Crazy amount of collectibles from all different eras. If you ever get the chance please check out this store you'll be doing yourself a favor! Can't wait to go back soon!

After a few years, I finally was able to make it out here!

If you like or liked pro wrestling - 80's to the Attitude Era to present day - this is a store you should stop at. There's a wide selection of figures, autographs, DVDs, books, VHS, magazines, and lots of other collectable memorabilia. There aren't too many options out there in the area that houses these type of items, so to have this place around is awesome.

Store is small, but plenty to look at. If you're not careful, you can easily miss something as it happened to me when I passed an area and noticed things I didn't notice the first time.

They do have autograph signings at select times which are updated on their website/social media, as well as shopping options. Some really cool stuff inside and on the website.

The owner is very welcoming and friendly.

There is a comfortable parking lot.

Really worth a trip and recommended for any wrestling fan - former or current - as there is plenty to see and something for anyone inside.

Found this store after driving to another store that was closed. Very cool store. They have a ton of signings and cool collectibles. The owner Tommy took care of me. Thank you Tommy for opening this wrestling heaven!!

Tommy is awesome! This store brings you back in time wonderful experience.Loaded with all types of collectible’s. Thanks for making my day better.

Wonderful esoteric collection! Constantly changing, so check in often! It's very easy to get to as well, and plenty of parking. I love that they have a separate space for signing events too! And the staff is just wonderfully helpful and enthusiastic, which really helps!

I returned the week of 7/25 and had an amazing experience. I can’t wait for 90s wrestling con!

Tommy is a great guy and very knowledgeable. There prices are very fair and you can always find something different every time you go in. Also there signings are very organized it is a must for any wrestling fan.

Where else can a pro wrestling fan relive their childhood. From classic magazines to wrestling figures. They even host meet and greet sessions. Recommend this place highly. Worth the drive.

Not just a store its an experience. Great place and Tommy the owner makes your time there a must stop destination for any wrestling fan.

Place is a must for any true collector great customer service and very knowledgeable. I will definitely be there again.

Amazing was there from first day to now amazing memories being made at this store all thanks to a great owner