Castaways

Great host, server, and staff! Was very shocked and impressed that we could get soup AND salad AND dessert with the entrees! All that food for very little price! So affordable! Portions were huge for the entree’s! Huge selection on the menu! Carol is a hard worker, presents herself well, and cares about the customer! She does a great job leading the team! Both servers today, (Christmas Eve) were bubbly and great with all of the people! Good to see the place busy!

Absolutely amazing waitress. Friendly atmosphere. Cheap, delicious food. The pork chops, soup, even the green beans were amazing!! So happy I found this spot. I will absolutely go back!

We drive from Westville Indiana to eat here. I enjoy he friendly faces and excellent service we receive every time. You get Soup and Salad, entree and dessert with full dinners. Can’t beat the prices for all you receive.

Came in a large group (9 people) accommodated quickly and efficiently. Servers and owner very personable and friendly. Good food great prices 10/10 recommend!

Castaways is a sweet little diner with delicious food and really good mimosas. The staff was attentive and really friendly. We will definitely be back!

We had the very best experience. Good por- tions, the very best service, and the owner was the best. We had a large group and she jumped in and helped what a wonderful lady. You can tell her workers loved working for her as they gave their best also. We will be back I'm sure.

I had the Texas Burger with an order of french fries and an order of onion rings with a bowl of taco soup. I could eat that taco soup every single day and not get tired of it. It is good. The service is great. Always very kind.

Excellent food and friendly fast service. I had the breakfast tacos and my wife had the breakfast scrambler with a hot chocolate. Food came out fast. Coming from about 45 minutes away would definitely make the trip there again.

Personally I feel like this is the best diner in town. The other breakfast joints just slop everything on the plate, this place actually cares what it looks and tastes like. Had lunch there for the first time and I was really impressed. Great family setting. Will eat there many more times.

Great place to have a meal and relax. The staff is very courteous and the owner, Carol visited with us. Yazmin served us and she was a happy soul. We will definitely be visiting more often.

Stopped in to try this family establishment out. I was not disappointed. Food was great, service was too! I will definitely return in the future.

The food and service was amazing. Our servers, Hannah and Yasmine, were very nice and patient with our large group. We were seated very quickly, and our food came out in a timely manner. Definitely coming back and would recommend!

Finally visited this little joint today to try out their breakfast that is served all day.

I got their Garden Benedict on sourdough with spinach, onion, and tomatoes topped with three perfectly poached eggs and a side of divine hollandaise sauce along with fruit. So good!

It was so delicious. There was so much food. My husband got the breakfast tacos. And I got the breakfast scrambler. I ate about a quarter of mine. But my favorite thing was the hot chocolate. It was the best I have ever had hands down!!!

First time eating here. Food was excellent, great value, portion was great sized. The atmosphere was fun and comfortable. The wait staff was very attentive and made sure we were taken care of. Our waitress was Bella, she definitely likes her job and did a great job of making sure we had everything we needed. We will absolutely make this our go to place for a sit down home cooked night out.
If you are looking for a good place with great food in Plymouth I definitely recommend you try Castaways!

The wait staff were pleasant & attentive, worked well as a team. The portions were good, the 3 of us each carried home about half of our meal. The food presented well & was tasty.

The best service and fresh food I experienced while in Indiana. The emphasis is on SERVICE! WOW! You must try this place while in Plymouth, Indiana.

Wonderful food, great menu. The staff is incredibly friendly.

We visit at least once a month for breakfast, plenty of staff which says alot these days. Good food nice portions, blueberry pancakes were awesome and you can even get mimosas.

Food was great, the service was great, we never had an empty drink. Overall a under-rated restaurant. It's phenomenal.