Schiano's Pizza

The pizza is delicious! The crust is crispy! I love the white pizza with broccoli. The plain cheese pie is good. My husband loves the bacon chicken ranch pie. They have so many choices. The owner and staff are so friendly and welcoming.

My husband and I happened to stop by for lunch just for a quick slice. He is very picky about pizza and he said "It was absolutely amazing" so we decided we would order from here for dinner.

The pizza is awesome it's crunchy on the bottom and soft and cheesy and great on the top. The pizza is very flavorful and doesn't need any added topping which i normally use.

I also ordered a chicken bacon ranch pizza. The pizza had a crunch on the crust, the bacon was perfect it was crispy but not overcooked. The chicken and ranch brought the entire pizza together.

The wings were crunch and cooked to perfection. They come with the sauce on the side which made it easy to give the kids plain wings while we had sweet chili sauce.

We bought garlic knots and not many places perfect these but they were deliciously fluffy inside and crispy outside.

My family and I have found another amazing place to order from. The best part of this is we ordered last minute like 5:45pm and the delivery said 7pm but the food was here by 6:20pm.

Try this place the food is awesome.

My wife and I came up from Columbia, SC to visit where I was raised in Bayville, NJ and to visit family. I had let her know that the pizza I grew up on as a kid was still operating to this day. I grew up in the 70’s in Bayville. My wife was like we have to go and we did. We came in and met the third generation owner and we started talking and he told me his grandfather Sal started it and I told him when I was a kid I remember Sal tossing the pizza dough. Well, after talking to his grandson, the now owner , Sal should be very happy. Great food and service. What a way to make a family proud! We will be back for sure.

I recently moved to the area and was looking for really good, local, authentic pizza. I happened upon a Facebook review of Schiano’s and grabbed some fellow foodies (critics) to go with me for late lunch. The calamari appetizer was fresh and perfectly cooked. We had half meatball, onion, mushroom and half sausage pizza which was Amazing! Looking forward to going back for dinner to try some entrees from the varied menu. Thanks to Brendan and Annamaria for making us feel so welcome. You don’t stay in business over 50 years unless you’re this good!

This is my families go to pizzeria ever since I could remember. We order from here often, sometimes for big events, or just a small order. The orders haven't been mixed up, and the wait time isn't long. The food arrives hot and never cold. My favorite thing to order from here is the either the meatball sub or chicken parm sub. The people who work here are very nice and provide great service.

The buffalo chicken pizza can be hit or miss….but when they hit its sooo good! We ordered buffalo chicken and plain pizza for my daughters bday and got so many compliments on how good the pizza was. Their eggplant parm subs and chicken cheese steaks are excellent as well.

Ordered a bruschetta pizza, by looks it was amazing taste is even better

We took a chance Friday night on Schianos, I’m very picky with pizza, this Italian girl makes her own pizza yes I do.
We ordered a tomato garlic pan pizza. It was incredible!! Everything was fresh, the tomatoes, the cheese, the sauce, loved that it wasn’t salty, just delicious! The crust was crispy not soggy, the dough was perfect, you could see the fresh garlic, good oil, the kind of pizza you can’t stop eating! Wish I lived closer, but we will stop in next time for dinner. Seems like a place that makes good eggplant and meatballs ; )

Absolutely delicious.staff was very friendly and professional.The world we live in today doesn't have this simply yet very human qualities. Definitely recommend this hidden gem!

This is a great little spot! Dinners are consistently good, reasonably priced and BYOB.

I made my first visit this evening and was warmly welcomed.. they didn't have many individual slices remaining but the friendly lady behind the counter offered a pie / slic fresh out of the oven. A little customer service goes a long way these days and even better, the white pie slice I had was delish! I'll be moving to the area in the next few months and plan to visit more often. 😊

Best pizza in town. Family who owns it is friendly, straight from Italy. Always warm and welcoming whenever we come in. Delivery is always on time and still hot! Who knew a little place in a strip mall would be this good!

I had Schianos for the first time a couple of weeks ago at work and took a bite before even looking at the box. It brought back so many memories of my teen years which was more than 3 decades ago. The taste is identical to what it was in the 80’s. I almost cried. Kudos to Schianos for maintaining consistency and therefore nostalgia with maintaining the taste of decades ago. You are still the best pizza ever!

I LOVE THIS ITALIAN RESTAURANT & PIZZERIA!!!!!❤❤❤
The food-Outstanding! The flavor is there, the pricing is competitive, the portions are HUGE! We eat our dinners for up to 3 days!! Their red sauce is yummy!! Everything we’ve ever ordered is just Fantastic!!
And BONUS! THEY COOK GLUTEN FREE ITEMS!!!!
This is our GO TO restaurant and we live about 25-30 minutes away. We drive there for pick up and take it back home to eat.
It is a family owned business.
⭐To be very exact- this is the Schiano’s that is located in BAYVILLE in the SHOPRITE shopping plaza off Rt. 9. There are a whole bunch of Schiano pizza/restaurants BUT they have no relation or association to this restaurant. THIS ONE IS THE BEST!!!!😁❤⭐👍🏼🎉🥂

Best chicken cacciatore! Huge portion, enough for another meal. Loaded with peppers, onions and mushrooms, and a thick, delicious sauce. Not a fancy place, but private booths and byob. Very comfortable for a cozy comfortable meal. Reasonable prices. Highly recommend.

I stopped in today for some pizza and I had such a good experience! The pizza is delicious and authentic and the lady who I assume is the owner is so sweet. Authentic, clean, Italian pizzeria 👌🏻

I deliver food service products to this establishment weekly. Every single time I am there, the entire staff, from ownership to every employee, and I mean EVERY employee, are some of the nicest, sincerest and real people I have ever had the pleasure of interacting with. I have eaten here as well and the food portions are huge. There is no skimping on toppings for pizzas and it is delicious here. Please please please, do yourself a favor and dine here, you WILL NOT be disappointed

We ordered pickup pizza on 5/24/21. Friendly service, and Sal got up and walked over to the counter to say hello while we were being rung up. But the best part was when we got home and opened the box. Not only was my 9 year old ecstatic that there was a “pizza table” in the pie (don’t all kids love to use those as tables for their lego people??), but I was ecstatic at the generous amount of pepperoni on our pepperoni pizza (which almost never happens, right?). Thumbs up to Sal and gang👍👍

We order trays of food every year from Schiano's of Bayville when we have family get togethers. This Christmas we ordered their reasonably priced 5 half tray special with one more of antipasto. Everything was prepared to perfection and absolutely delicious. The food quality here has always been first rate. My order was ready at the time I requested, the staff were all super nice to deal with, and the they assisted me in bringing it all out to the car. Schiano's of Bayville will always be our go to in the future. A big thank you to everyone involved in our order for a job well done. We totally enjoyed every bite.

Schianos has been our family's preferred place for pizza and Italian for 30+ years. We took my toddler for dine-in lunch today and had the best time! Our sandwiches were amazing (as always) and the entire staff was kind and helpful! An extra "thank you" to Sal's sweet wife! My son absolutely adores her! 🍕