New York Pizza & Restaurant

Really awesome find. The food was awesome. Great NY style pizza. Glad we ordered a large pizza, plenty of leftovers for take home. And antipasto salad was delicious and fresh with oil and vinegar. As were the garlic rolls, loads of garlic and butter. So good, If you're on the fence, give them a try.

Tried this place for the first time, and can honestly say it definitely honors its current 4.7/5 rating. It is the best pizza spot so far in the area strictly from a traditional cheese pizza slice comparison. We ordered both a Popeye and regular Cheese (dine-in) for an accurate review. The Popeye had a significant crisp on the bottom as well as a crunchy crust. The Cheese had a similar bottom crisp but not as much as the Popeye. I love the price of the cheese. The Popeye seemed a bit pricey compared to the flavor, I had to add more salt to each bite. Will definitely visit again to try other items but purely from a regular Cheese, this is the spot 🔥

This pizza place is family owned. They all work there and they take like a two week vacation once a year and they close the store for that time that they’re gone and you can tell that they love what they do and they put their hard into it. Their food is amazing. They work very hard. Every time I walk in there. They are friendly, they know me now personally and it’s always nice to go in there and the food never disappoints never in fact when they leave for vacation every year I go through Pizza withdraw because that is the only place that I’d like to get my pizza from there garlic knots are insane. Their salads are fresh. Everything is made to order and it’s just amazing. They’re so nice and so friendly , and this is their life you can tell like they have made this their legacy

I'm from NY which has great pizza. Relocated to Florida over ten yrs ago. This is the best pizza I've had in years...just perfect. The waiting staff lady is very efficient and friendly. Nice clean place also. Go and enjoy a delectable pizza.

Wow! What a gem. Delicious food, and the wings are mesmerizing. Super wet and juicy, can’t wait to come back.

The people that run this place are very kind and meticulous with how their pizzas are produced. Large delicious slices, good prices.

It was my first time and I ordered the Popeye and this was literally one of the best pizzas I've had in a long time and one of the best Ive ever had period. The garlic knots were good too!!

Our FAVORITE PIZZA PLACE! GREAT SERVICE, GREAT AMBIANCE, AND MOST OF ALL GREAT ITALIAN FOOD ! WE GO There FOR THE PIZZA BECAUSE IT'S AMAZINGLY GOOD.
PLEASE VISIT YOU WON'T BE DISAPPOINTED!

This is a family owned restaurant and the place is impeccable.
The food is fresh, delicious and plenty. We're regular customers and even though we live 45 minutes away from their business it's worth the travel!!!

Best NY style pizza ,excellent taste , i love it, i recommend it, i made this my pizza place. always on time. they're just the best👍

This has become our go-to pizza place for fast, fresh, streets-of-NY pie. The crust is perfect without asking for crispy. The toppings are balanced great with the sauce and cheese. They set the industry standard, and they make it great.

Delicious pizza good Service very nice cozy place definitely would recommend👍🏼

First time I've been there and OMG it was INCREDIBLE! I ordered a takeout order and it surpassed expectations. The pizza, *chefs kiss*. The wings, literally perfect. I will 10000000% order from here from now on. Do yourself a favor and don't make dinner tonight, order this pizza!

Really good place, the staff is awesome and their pizzas show what real Italian & new York flavor is.

The pizza is consistently amazing my hubby and used to try all the pizza places in Altamonte and we found heaven with there New York style 18' with ricotta cheese and pepperoni and I get a side of garlic aioli for dipping my crust and it's so amazing the ingredients they use are fresh I can tell. I'm from Chicago where we are picky about our pizza and this place is by far the best in town.

So we won lunch on the company for the store and we ordered two pies and 30 wings. I have to say the pizza was really on point. I'm from up north and it's hard to find good pizza shops in Florida that replicate the style and taste of new york pizza. This hit the mark. Will be one of my go to places for both wings and pizza, the hot wings were like a medium. Not too spicy and very tasty

My wife and I have been going to New York Pizza & Restaurant since 2004. We used to go there weekly while we were working on our new home, but now we eat there every few months. The food is excellent, and their service is top-notch. The food is very fresh. My wife likes to get the antipasto salad. She usually eats half of it one day and the other half the next. The salad is just as good on day two. That can only be done with fresh ingredients. I highly recommend New York Pizza & Restaurant.

Best NY style pizza around. It's a family owned and operated business. Wel worth your time, money and empty stomachs. Best eggplant parmasan.

I was craving pizza today after visiting relatives in nearby Casselberry and passed by New York Pizza on the way home so I decided to stop in. And I am glad I did. This is a very small place located in a very busy shopping plaza. The staff was pretty friendly and the food was awesome.

I ordered a slice of cheese pizza and a soda. The total bill was only $3.19!! Can't beat that price at all - especially considering the fantastic quality of the food. I will definitely return next time I am in the area.

Best pizza in Florida! Definitely TRY HERE. It’s better than NY!