Cavallario's Bayside

My kids said it was the best pizza they’ve ever had. It was good and so was the rest of our food. Loved eating by the water. Order at the counter and pick up your food after. Little wait but we went before the dinner rush and didn’t have to wait to long

Just gonna let everyone know how amazing this place is! The pizza is Incredible😍 The customer service between Brenda and Peter is what you would imagine traditional Italian would be! Also, their antipasto is the best I’ve ever had! Check it out! 10/10

Nice bayside pizza place. Food was good. My husband and I got the super hoagie and shared. They run on a number system, so it's easy to here when your order is up too. Would go back again!

I have been visiting Cavallario's from Ontario for over 25 years. Our favorite is the veggie pizza & the wings are delicious too. The owner Pete always remembers us . The service is great and the view to the river is beautiful! Worth a visit!

The pizza was so delicious. You couldn't beat the view either.

In New York, Cavallario's Bayside is a culinary gem that has won my heart with its superb Italian food and cozy, welcoming atmosphere. A hidden gem, this family-run eatery offers an exceptional dining experience that will leave you wanting more.

When you walk inside Cavallario's Bayside, a charming and welcoming ambiance greets you. Every visit seems exceptional because of the authentic Italian atmosphere that is created by the rustic furnishings, low lighting, and relaxing music.

We played the thousand Island River run in Alex Bay the last 2 years. I got a delicious pulled pork sandwich last year and decided I needed another one this year. Was directed to the service station for them to take my order and was taken care of by the sweetest waitress forgive me I did not get her name. I'm one of these annoying people that want my food a special way and am pretty picky about it. The pulled pork was super good as usual their sauce is delicious and love the coleslaw that comes with it as well as the homemade chips. My order was perfect and she helped me out as well with some extra sauce and coleslaw even when they were pretty slammed with business. Thanks again so much I'm sure I will be there next year during the River run and we'll make it a point to come up when we are not playing.

I see some negative reviews, but I am kind of a fussy guy and my wife and I had a wonderful time there with family and friends. Food was fantastic. Staff was very cooperative. Understanding food was great.

Great pizza, wings and sandwiches! They have a great gluten-free crust for pizza, too!

Delicious food and friendly service. My family loved it here!

Amazing place to eat! Delicious pizza right on the water with excellent customer service. Family owned for over 50 years!

Great place to eat the subs are delicious and the pizza is excellent! the ingredients are fresh and the restaurant is still family owned. Great view on the patio of the town docks. You definitely get what you pay for!

Would drive 150 miles for this pizza. Oh wait, I did. I've never had bad food or bad service in 20 years coming here. I'm not a local I only come once or twice a year. But when I come here it's always great.

I ordered the turkey mango panini yesterday. It was amazing! Super hot. Delicious! Will definitely be back.

This place is adjacent to the Lawrence river. The price is little expensive. However, the Veggi Pizzas I ate here was awesome and have never tasted such a crispy and tasty pizzas in any of the prominent Pizza stores.

The Gluten free pizza was delicious! Did not taste like gluten free!

Gr8 place for a meal and excellent staff. Great view with outdoor seating.

The best pizza with the best view in the Bay! Try the wings & the 1000 Islander, its amazing! Pete the owner is a great guy to boot, enjoy Alexandria Bay's best!

Just got the turkey/mango panini with sweet potato fries. Delicious. Fast service with a smile. Best sweet potato fries in town.

Been coming here for 50 years - Amazing Pizza and Wings, great views, friendly service. There is a reason why it's always packed and been going strong for 53 years!