Wiseguy Pizza Pie

This place is all pizza and atmosphere reminiscent of a college pizza joint. It is small, cozy warm and the staff is pleasant and efficient.

There was a lot of take out orders which kept the cashier busy and was good for business.

The space is limited so the tables are small but fit 4 just fine.

I am still astounded by the tip request of 30% in the area.

Yummy pizza better than smoky mountain pizza and better priced.
Great people.
Definitely will be back 1st time here.
Happy Easter 2024 🐰 🐣

Very good! The crust was nice and crispy but also chewy. Super delicious pizza. I’d recommend getting a pizza with the red sauce. We tried the ranch sauce pizza and it was good but a red sauce pizza would’ve been even tastier.

Update: back in town and stopped by for some dinner. Great pizza! Amazing crust. 10/10 recommend

Amazing NY style pepperoni pizza. Recommend. Can order pizza by the piece or the whole thing.

Did take out, delicious pizza!

Had high hopes before I walked in! And 💥 they did not disappoint! Ordered the hangover pizza 🍕 and Fire 🔥 staff was fantastic!

New York style pizza. My little one and I got a couple slices and they were delicious. Fast and great customer services. Oz the lab was an awesome bonus.

This place has some awesome pizza and it is even hand tossed, kind of rare now a days. Lots of varieties to choose from, we had one of the chicken pizzas. Or else make your own, they have loads of ingredients to choose from. The staff here is great also. If you are in Ketchum, Sun Valley or anywhere near try this place out.

The pizza with lemon slices was an amazing idea! I came back with my wife for it

We tried their margarita pizza and their crust was amazing, toppings were plentiful and fresh, their sauce was delicious, and it was baked with attentiveness and care to perfection. Also they were super fast!

I was born and raised in northern jersey and had friends and family who owned pizzerias. In the 15 years I’ve been away from there this is THE BEST PIZZA I’ve ever had. So much so it felt like I was at home.

Amazing pizza! You can get it by the slice or get yourself a large pizza

Amazing Ceasar Salad and wings. Pizza was a legit 7.6 (one bite app). Location was small but staff was super friendly and helpful. Would recommend to anyone!

Best pizza in town, Wise Guys did it! Garlic knots, buffalo wings, good brews on tap, salads, pizza by the slice or pies for the entire crew, Wise Guys is not to be missed.

Went in for a slice and a beer to fill back up!
The pizza was super good: crispy thin crust with delightful toppings. The amount of cheese was perfect. Exceeded my expectations!

Delicious food and beer. Great service and staff. Thank you!

The pizza was better than most places I have been too. I wish they had more options for the slices but other than that 5/5

Great pizza- crispy thin crust, nice staff, fun atmosphere.

I grew up in New York, lived in Italy for a few years, but this is one of the best pizzas I've ever had. Perfectly cooked crust, good ratio of cheese and sauce, really fresh toppings. Loved it, wish we would have gotten a large instead of a medium. We will be back.

Delicious pizza and garlic knots. Garlic knots that aren't overpowering with the garlic. Sat outside and people watched while we waited. Funny guy behind the counter. Will definitely go back when we are in the area again.