Bella Pizza & Subs

Awesome authentic NY style pizza, with extra sauce, great meatball heroes! Kudos to Dave & his staff, our search for home style (NY) pizza is over!

Our favorite pizza on the island. And they'll walk your order over to the bottle shop next door so you can enjoy a cold one with the pie.

We had two slices and a can drink for 6.99 ( dollar extra since we wanted pepperoni) they make their dough everyday.. and it’s a decent slice! Well worth the visit especially since Roma is closed for the season.

Bella's has been a go to and fav since I was a kid coming to the beach just on the weekends! We would always stop on our way in and get pizzas from Bella's! Now as an adult, my family still loves Bella's pizza! Must try!!

9/29/22
We have had pizza three times on the island so far. This was wonderful! The others I felt were average. This one was the best price & the best pizza. 5 stars! Also the young lady who took my order tonight was super sweet! Great job Bella Pizza!

I decided to give this place a try while my family and I were on vacation at the beach. The food was good and did not disappoint. The interior was clean and the staff were very friendly. 2 thumbs up from me. They take CASH only by the way. Thanks!

Great place to get a hot or cold sub, salad, Pizza 🍕, cheesestreak. Where the locals eat.
Enjoy

If you have not been here then can you really even say you are living?? Once you eat the pizza they make here you will realize that you were not living but instead just existing going through the motions like a robot who believes it understands joy. In one bite though you find the true meaning of the word and many more just like it as that bite hits every taste bud and they all come back to life!! The price even better!! The staff are out of this world! So, am I full of it or not? Go and find out, your whole body will thank you later!

Update... the food is still the most awesome stuff ever!!

Stardate 7.28.2023......

We found ourselves cruising through the old neighborhood. It made me nostalgic for the days when I ate at Bella Pizza & Subs.
I turned to my second in command and proceeded to tell him to use the sensors to find something to eat.
Low and behold... Bella came up on the screen and the sensors went hay wire. I couldn't believe it. Caught in a time wave was Bella Pizza! A man who loved this restaurant so much that he made it so anyone could experience it no matter what year it was!!
True, while being a crime against every known law. I want a statue made of this person!!

Great place to eat...very friendly people work there, prices are great and great food. The best pizza place in carteret county

Got carry out. It was good NY style (likeness) pizza and garlic cheese bread. Good food and great service on a holiday.

Ordered 2 slices of cheese pizza and an Italian chef salad. Pizza was thin like New York style and the dressing was delicious, tart, and flavorful. Not fancy, but really good!

Smells so good in here! Everything looks so wonderful. The Italian sun rivaled jersey M…’s

Great sandwiches and pizza. Good prices for quality ingredients. I'm from the Bronx and I was very happy with our meal. Friendly service, cash only, ATM available.

We came here on vacation & wanted to eat local, rather than the usual chain. This place does not disappoint! We ordered an antipasto salad, cheese pizza & the Bella special. All the food is amazing! Can't wait for breakfast pizza!

Vacationing in the area and picked Bella at random and so thankful we did! Pizza was ready in 15 minutes and was very tasty!! Not too greasy, lots of cheese and pepperoni! Can't wait to order from them again! Highly recommend!

Are you looking for the hole in the wall pizzeria that was behind your house when you were growing up? Stop looking, this is the place for NY/NJ style pizza in emerald isle. 5 bucks for two slices (four of those slices make a pie) and a drink. Crust in thin and a perfect texture, a little light on sauce but a good combo with the right amount of cheese. Haven't tried the other menu items yet but if they can do this good with a cheese pizza the other stuff cant be bad.

Some of the best pizza I have had!

Update still the best on the island...have had the manicotti and lasagna...please do not miss this place...the people are very awesome....you will not leave disappointed...cash only please so don't forget but there is an ATM!

Daily special, 2 slices and a drink for $4.99. Can't beat it! The pizza is delicious, along with the rest of the menu. Several outside tables, and seating for approximately 15 inside, so plan on taking this pie to go. Staff is also very friendly. I definitely recommend this place for a quick, cheap, delicious lunch on the go.

Order ahead because of very long wait times, but the pizza is worth the wait. Don't forget to try their cheesy garlic bread. The access road is a bit tricky If you use Google maps, but there are plenty of spots to park and wait for your order to be ready. There are a few seating tables inside but almost no one wears mask. Also, this is cash only so plan for it.

I ordered a pizza for delivery, and it was amazing. Probably one of the best pizzas I've ever had. The crust was delicious - thin, but not too chewy or too crispy. There was an abundance of cheese and pepperoni, with just the right amount of sauce. Even eating the leftover slices two days later was a pleasure.