Coniglio's Old Fashioned

Vodka Pizza are the best among the other best pizzas! Sourdough bread is to die for ! Amazing quality amazing food extremely friendly and helpful staff. No reservations required first come first serve ! Definitely one the best pizzas in New Jersey ! A must visit place for pizza lovers

Came here on a Sunday in January around noon. Place was about 1/2 full, you order at the counter and they bring to your table. We had a salad and a 18” Brooklyn round pie. The salad and pizza came out at the same time. The pizza rests on a large can of tomatoes. The pizza was one of the best I have had ever. The only thing I would do differently is to ask them to make it well done or cook slightly longer. The pizza is thin crust with a breadcrumbs (not cornmeal) underneath. The sauce is sweet but still has that acidity bite. The cheese was really nicely proportioned to the sauce and the basil tasted fresh and tangy. The salad was ok nothing crazy. They have other pastry I didn’t try but I will be back again!

We ordered the Brooklyn pie with sausage, it was seriously the best pizza we ever had. The shaved fennel salad was out of this world and served 3 of us. The fusilli with mushrooms was perfectly al dente, delicious comfort food on a chilly night. Our service was fantastic, from placing the order to when we realized that we had bought too many Brooklyn seltzers (delicious by the way) and needed to get our bill corrected. The presentation of all the dishes we ordered was very pleasing as well. To top it off we enjoyed 3 different loaves of bread, freshly sliced and which made delicious sandwiches and toast next day. The fruit and nut was my personal favorite. I am here visiting a friend for a few days but I am planning to take a pie home to the Boston area when I leave. It seriously challenges the two Italian pizza rivals in our Italian North end… I can’t wait for my husband to true it. All in all 5 stars for everything, food, service and atmosphere!! Charming and cozy decor.

We came here for the first time today. This restaurant is amazing. The food is indescribable. Everything is so fresh and delicious. The atmosphere is wonderful and all of the staff is so nice and helpful. Josephine is an absolute god send, she was one of the sweetest people you will ever meet in your lifetime. Out of all of the amazing restaurants in Morristown, walk past them and come to Coniglios. We will be back here every week from now on for the warm comforting atmosphere alone. I felt like I was welcomed into someone’s home.

From top to bottom, this place is 10/10!!! The staff is amazing and the food is outstanding! The entire vibe of this place is breathtaking, to say the least. I traveled 1.5 hours for this place and did it 2 days in a row because I had to go back and try more food! Please do yourselves a favor and check out Coniglio's, and you will be glad you did!

Great pizza spot with very friendly service. Definitely recommend the grandma with pepperoni! It was phenomenal.

But the cinnamon roll is a hard pass, a very odd item that feels out of place and unneeded.

Seriously delicious pizza! Tried the Josephina Square Pie and all of the components were spot on - especially the sauce. Absolutely amazing flavor that I immediately saved the spot as a favorite. It’s a top contender on my quest to find the best pizza.

Restaurant has an interesting and diverse set up. You order at the register making it feel like a to-go spot, but they have ample seating to dine-in. Also, has some good looking baked goods/bread. Can’t wait to come back and try more off the menu.

First time in and it didn't disappoint!
The service is a bit odd but maybe because I didn't expect it to be that way. You wait for a table and then order your food at the counter. No table service. They do bring the food to your table and it's not a bad system but definitely different. Makes tipping strange too as do you tip a full tip, who is actually getting it and for what service? We did leave a full generous tip but it seemed odd.
BUT on to the food. We got a grandma's pie and an eggplant parm sandwich. There were 4 of us and it was plenty of food. The pizza is large and filling and OMG delicious!! I literally want to go back every night for a month so I can try all the pies. The eggplant parm sandwich was also amazing. The bread was to die for and the eggplant was sliced thin and had just the right ratio of sauce and cheese.
The atmosphere is great. Very fun. Very NY feel. It is small so expect a wait I'm sure if you go prime time. We went around 6 on a Saturday and only had to wait about 5 minutes for a table. Food comes out pretty quickly. It was piping hot, we sat right next to the ovens. Perfect on a chilly night!
Again, the service was good it was just a bit strange at first. Now we know the drill and will know what to expect next time.
Oh there will definitely be a next time!!
And don't even get me started on the Bombolone! We had an assortment platter, lemon, strawberry, pistachio and Nutella. Warmed and delicious!

The best pizza in New Jersey!
Brooklyn style pizza thin crust with lots of sweet sauce. The secret is in the crust which is perfect and a bit salty. The Brooklyn round pizza did not disappoint. Very friendly staff. Family friendly. BYOB and lots of interesting soft drinks and Italian doughnuts and desserts. Super affordable in a popular area of Morristown. Ask for Pablo and he will help with your order.

Amazing pizza and quick friendly service. I ordered the Salsiccia Pep Onion Square with Hot Honey on their website. My friends have been raving about this pizza for months and yes it lived up to the hype. I had added the hot honey sauce for the extra charge, but it was very different and complimented the pizza. I stopped in to pick it up and it had an adorable ambiance, felt like you could come here for a fun date night or casual family or friends get together. Staff had a family feeling to it. I would come back. So many different pizzas to try!

Did a pre-show dinner tonite at Coniglio’s. The food is on point. We did Fennel Salad, Pasta Fagioli, Uncle Carlo’s Onion Pie, chocolate brioche and espresso. So good! Already planning our return visit. Pizza, Bread and fresh baked goods were all top quality and delicious

This is the only review you need. It’s a 5/5 - the atmosphere is classy, super ideal for a family gathering or a date. The food and staff are incredible - so sincere and ensure you are happy and comfortable. It was my first time here and I will now be a frequent returner! I’m speechless.

This is easily the best pizza in Morris County. It's definitely in my top places in the entire state also. Not only is the pizza great, but all the food is spot on. The bread is fantastic, and the sandwiches are delicious. Honestly, it's probably the best sandwich and bread in the county. We always get a pizza, salad, sandwich, and pasta, and all the food is always excellent. It has a great atmosphere, too, and I love not needing to wait at the end of the meal to pay the check. The staff is always knowledgeable and friendly also. Highly recommend.

Stumbled here last weekend while looking at houses in the area. My husband and I live right outside the city with great pizza options so we weren't expecting much when we came in. Boy were we wrong! The pizza was so good! We got the vodka pie and it is amazing! The sauce is perfect, not too tart, not too sweet, somehow the stracciatella added the perfect amount of creaminess without making it too rich, and the sourdough crust was crisp yet soft and SO good! Definitely stop by if you're in the area! The pastries looked amazing but we'll have to come back for them!

I have nothing but great experiences at Coniglios. From the People to the Pizza and to the Donuts. Everything is top notch and is now a must stop anytime I am in Morristown.

Have been wanting to come here for months! We finally Dined In on a Thursday evening with my wife where the place was empty.

We explained that we had never been there before and the guy at the counter told us we need to try the Brooklyn round. We wanted to try half of it with pepperoni. We started with the meatballs in a ton of absolutely delicious sauce. They were excellent at $10 for 4.

The pizza comes out and gets placed right on top of our Green Olive container- the pizza stand for all the tables. This was the absolute best pizza I’ve ever tasted. From the sauce, to the delicious crust. The pepperoni was also incredibly good.

If you want some of the best pizza around, you need to come to Coniglios.

We came here on a Sunday, mid to late evening, with our young baby. It was our first time going out to dinner with the baby and we thought it might be a good spot for that. We were way off - it was a perfect spot. We thought it would be mellow, but it was jamming. In a good way. Even so, it still seemed relaxing. We didn’t have to raise our voices to have a conversation despite the steady energy in the room.

The food was fantastic. We got the shaved fennel salad and the upside down Sicilian pizza. World-class.

It was busy, so the pizza took a little bit. But the company was good. Josephina came around and complimented our baby daughter, she made us feel like family. In good time, the pizza came out and it was spot-on.

This place lacks nothing and makes positive gains in food and spirit. We’ll be back.

This pizza is phenomenal!!! After reading the reviews, I had to try this spot and it has been our top place to pick up from ever since 😅 I've had the vodka stracciatella and the upside down grandma pies so far- both are out of this world. Unlike any pizza around.

Personally, I think the vodka stracciatella is the stand-out item- it's just unbelievable. I've always liked vodka pizzas and typically order them whenever I see them on a menu...I've never tasted anything like this 🤌🏻

The desserts and sandwiches and pastas are incredible too! It seems like everything they do here, they do WELL

Came by for dinner on a Friday afternoon and had a really great experience.

Yes, it's more expensive than your generic NJ pizzeria, but Coniglio's is offering much more than that, and I felt like the food was worth it. And the food is what we're really here for, right? The quality of everything we had was on point, the pizza toppings were creative and delicious. We ate enough to be Thanksgiving dinner full, and still had leftovers to feed several more people.

For me, great pizza starts with a great crust, and the pies I had totally delivered. Well-baked, crunchy and chewy. The vodka sauce and stracciatella pie was outstanding.

The meatballs were delicious and drenched in basil oil, the Caesar salad was crisp and well-dressed, and the arancini were packed with cheese and meat and fried to perfection.

We also had a great experience with both the staff and owner. The staff was attentive and friendly, and the owner made sure to stop by our table and personally take care of a mix-up with the shape of the pie we ordered. It's hard to ask for much more than that.

Pizza is great, don't sleep on the food because it's as good as the pizza, and the bombolone are better than the ones I just had in Sicily. Nino, the owner, is first class and is humble but prideful about his product. Highly recommend. Easily one of my favorite places in all of jersey!