Gaetano's Cheesesteaks

Best steak sandwich ever! And I'm very picky when it comes to eating! Will not go anywhere else! Sandwich was packed with steak and loaded with mushrooms and onions! Had a hamburger from there and it was top notch and fresh and not one of those pre-made frozen patties. Oh, forgot, great fries also!

Stopped at Gaetanos this afternoon for lunch while working in the area. Read some reviews and was surprised with the number of 1 star reviews! Maybe I made a mistake coming here? Well, I definitely did not!!! The service was perfect. And most important....the cheesesteak was amazing!!!! I ordered the "small", which is actually a pretty large sandwich. I normally don't eat everything I order in one sitting, but I devoured this entire sandwich in my work truck while traveling to my next job!!! I had a nice conversation with the owner, who I found to be a very personable, very nice and very serious small business owner. To those morons that review with low ratings for customer service.....complete liars. To the other low star raters.....move the f out of jersey and go to California with the rest of the fruits and nuts! Gaetanos will def be my go to spot anytime I am in the hamilton area!!!

I honestly just googled to give the positive feedback I think this place deserves.. I went there two times ..1st I got a large buffalo chicken cheesesteak with extra cheese and it was absolutely delicious.. I had to go back and try a large cheesesteak with x cheese and mushrooms… it was just as good as the first time if not better.. breads amazing and the quality of the meat is on point and full of flavor.. both times I went in everyone was polite and even took my order even though they were closing!! I’d say great place and a must try for a new jerseys cheesesteak spot.. definitely one of the best I’ve had in the area!

Best Chicken Cheese Steak my Wife and I ever had. Little Air Conditioning .... Buy it 2 go !

Best cheese steaks you can ever get. Better than Philly, NY or the rest of Jersey. Best cheese steak I ever had really.

The flavor of the steak is just another level the palce is awesome and the restroom is very clean the customer service was so professional congratulations keep going

The owner is very nice. The food is great. They do a food challenge. I could never even try to complete it. Huey tried and did well but lost the battle... . All the sauces are good. And homemade. The food is fresh. Great place. Have gone multiple times and will continue to go.

Excellent food, staff and service. Quality ingredients lead to quality products and Gaetano’s come through every time - I’ve bought sandwiches here since their old location down the road and they’ve always been spectacular. You get what you pay for and that’s worth it, thanks for your hard work guys

This was my first time going into the restaurant and I must say I would love to dine in. Very humble customer service and food didn't take long at all. I'm eating my chicken cheese steak now and omggggg it's so good I'm so glad I found a spot closer to home. My new cheese steak spot for sure. Thank you again

Just pick up three large cheesesteak for dinner tonight. Can't wait to get home and eat them, their smelling up the car. Just might have to pull over and enjoy. Service was great and a good conversation with the owner Bill. Great time and great place!

BEST wings in the area, with actual meat on them. No joke either and their sauce slaps like no other.

You go anywhere else for wings your making a mistake, the meal is never over when you're full here, it's over when you hate yourself.

Love this place so much. Other than having the best food around, the people who work there are top-notch. Great food, great people, great experience.

Please you gotta go to.

Most amazing cheese steak I've ever had! But make sure you see what size sub your getting!!! A small is huge much less a large!!!

Huge portions and great food!!! You won't be disappointed!

Biggest Cheesesteak I've ever had. Plenty of steak & good soft roll. HOMETIME EATS !!!! NEW JERSEY BABY...😜

Kind of just want to leave a one star review to see what the owner says and then change it to 5 stars depending on how bad the burn is.

Update: Lmfaoo not bad 5 Stars indeed!

I’ve eaten here plenty of times and the food is always good. Leaving a five star because someone told me to read the owner’s responses to the reviews, and they did not disappoint lmfao—even if I hadn’t eaten here before, I’d give it five stars just for that reason.

Food tasted okay but I threw up about 30 minutes after eating. Not sure what it was but the meat did taste a bit off. I wonder if it started to rot

Food was great. Got a mini cheesesteak hoagie, was huge. Also got a side of mozzarella sticks, never had this kind before. They are huge and good. Not the soggy under cooked ones everyone els has. Good talking with you and your mom last week.

I was skeptical at first after reading the reviews. I found the customer service to be good; the lady at the counter was personable. The cheese steak was pretty good. I got a small and was amazed at the size. I ate half and was stuffed. The price may be on the high end, but they give you your money's worth. I'll definitely be coming back.