Michael's House of Prime

The prime rib, the ribeye, or the duck... I always have a hard time picking, we love this place! We ended up getting engaged here and Sarah and the staff went out of their way for us!

Update 2/20/21 - We went back to the pop-up offering at the Petite Chef and had an amazing dinner. One of the best French onion soups I've ever had, the prime rib was on point, and the risotto was perfect. Sarah and the staff caught wind our wedding was in 22 days and surprised us with an wonderful dessert.

A beautiful restaurant in the lake. Delicious food and friendly hosts. The patio is very nice.

Steak salad was amazing. Fantastic drinks, they carry a great selection of bourbon and my favorite #BreckenridgeBourbon

Welcomed as soon as we walked in. There were 5 in our group. We sat at the bar and enjoyed Brandy Old Fashion's (Korbel) while chatting with the Owners and Bartender. At dinner we all ordered steak 4 prime rib and 1 Filet. We all agreed it was the best steak and dinner we have ever had along with the service. We e definitely be back!

Great old time supper club. Saturday night special is prime rib, which my husband had. I had a filet. It's pricey, but well worth it. The decor has changed since we last visited. Very sunny and bright. The menu changed as well. They don't have the lazy Susan for salads anymore, but our waitress brought us homemade croutons, which were delicious. You get soup and salad with your meal, along with ham salad and cheese spread. Well worth the trip.

My wife and I really enjoy coming to Michael’s. The food is always delicious, and the staff is always warm and inviting. The prime rib is my favorite anywhere, and the specials are always great. Also, the drinks are very reasonable, especially the wines. This is a beautiful supper club, I highly recommend.

My son recently moved to the area and told me how wonderful this establishment was. Classy yet casual. He brought me there for Father's day and it was fantastic 😊 savory Lucius steaks made perfect. My mouth is watering just thinking of it! They all were very polite, great with the kids and so hospitable. I think everyone deserves to spoil themselves at least once at this magnificent place. We will be back again soon without a doubt! Thanks for a most pleasurable dinning experience!

Second time at michaels house of prime in two weeks. Great food as good as the old place

I normally don't give 5 stars unless a place wows me and Michaels house of prime did just that. I was very skeptical after reading a few of the reviews but I figured what the heck I will give it a try and I'm glad I did. As soon as we sat at the bar the bartender was kind an friendly. One of the owners came over an talked to us we told him this was are 1st time he said your going to love are restaurant..We had a few drinks and were seated within 30 minutes. The prime rib is amazing and quite on the large side even with bone in. Are server was friendly and courteous. As we where leaving one of the other owners asked us how was everything..I said I loved it and you have a new customers..Do yourself a favor make Michael's a Saturday ritual. Highly recommend reservations..

This was our third visit and it is always great. The menu had changed, so we all ended up ordering the filet mignon. It just melts in your mouth, always cooked well. We didn't order the PB&J app this time... But if you go, you have to try it. The owners are always present, welcoming and thank you for coming.
Go for happy hour, stay for the steak! We will return.

We had 5 couples celebrating our May anniversaries. Too many years to count. Our meals were superb. I tried lamb and my husband had the pork. Both were delicious. No one left hungry. Our server Sammy was very attentive. It was our 1st experience and we will be back.

Service was great starting with valet and ending with him. Waiter was awesome. Owner came to check on us as did hostess. Am I allowed to say too much food? Prime and lobster was amazing! Very reasonable prices for the quantity and quality of food and service A wonderful experience

Excellent food, excellent service!
Always wonderful to enjoy a fine dinner here.
One of my very favorite places to enjoy Prime Rib! The Surf n Turf is an amazing choice!
Great seafood here as well!
Baked French Onion Soup is also to die for!
Miss seeing Judy Spalsbury here, but it’s so wonderful Val & Billy stayed!!!

Went here for my parents anniversary dinner.. And wow they have such good service plus amazing food and drinks! Anne was our waitress and she was so knowledgeable about the menu and such a gem! I highly recommend trying them out. It Is expensive.... but definitely worth every penny!! You won't be disappointed.

We are retired and eat out a lot. We prefer smaller, non chain restaurants. The ones locally owned. Quality of food is important, but service is even more so. We had a reservation and the hostess that greeted us was very pleasant. She seated as at a table in a lovely room of all old fashioned white painted small paned windows with white linen table clothes on the tables. The room reminded me of a sunroom. I loved this room! Our server Valerie greeted us right away, introducing herself and taking our drink orders from the bar. My husband ordered coffee and Valerie said she would make a fresh pot. It was good coffee.Very pleasant young woman! Our water arrived, then something we haven't seen in a long time in restaurants, a basket with crackers and breadsticks along with a bowl of cheddar cheese spread and a bowl of ham salad! We also received a loaf of warm bread. I ordered Thai mussels in a coconut milk, lemon grass and Thai red curry sauce with crusty bread for dipping. For me, a meal by itself. Very good! My husband ordered liver that he really enjoyed. It was such a large portion he brought half home. Michael's is known for their prime rib. We aren't prime rib eaters but we saw a number of people enjoy theirs. As we left a gentleman opened the door for us. He asked how our experience was at Michael's. I told him it was great. Upon my asking he said he was one of the new owners who bought it 2 years ago as he walked out with us. Again, an owner who cared to ask us how we liked his establishment. To us this says, he cared about his restaurant and he cared about his customers experience. As diners we have a choice where we eat every time we go out. He obviously knows that and the attitude at Michael's, by everyone, including the valet who parked our car, says "we appreciate your business, please return. "

Beautiful meal and great service and drinks!

Tom M. Jan 2014

I love the cozy lake atmosphere and the nautical theme in the bar. It's the best nautical bar in the country. Prices are really competitive and food is fantastic. Steaks are great and perch fish fry is the best. Great service and Very Friendly people work there as well.

Cozy restaurant across from Pewaukee Lake. They have a section of unique drinks on the menu and we tried a very fun spicy sweet drink called the Flummox. From the main menu we recommend the prime rib blackened and the brisket. Both were delicious! Loaded potato was served in a small iron skillet with a ton of tasty toppings - one of the best we've ever had. We'll be back!

Wonderful prime rib. Nice place to go. Great service...timely, courteous, plentiful food. Hint: Don't order the blond prime unless you are REALLY hungry or want to take food home. Delicious!

Went here for my birthday and sat outside in the globe. It was fantastic! Not just the ambiance but the food. Every course was spot on. Bacon wrapped water chestnuts, French onion soup, Filet, Prime, baked potato & carrots. It all was excellent!