Fortino's Tavern

I had dinner with a friend “Jill” on Thursday night , One of the best steak I’ve had so far. The chefs were amazing . And the service was smooth like a butter . Honestly I loved the food. Mostly the creamy Pappardelle pasta with mushrooms 🍄 damn !!!! it was mind blowing . Thank you so much guys . Can’t wait to visit again .

You should not eat at this place. Because there aren't many tables and I don't want you taking mine!
Hidden Gem. Sorry for the cliche, but it truly is. I want to help the business by giving the praise it deserves, but truly fear too many of you will try it and spread the word.
The setting, food, service and overall experience were all spectacular.

The views, the ambiance, the food, and the service was 2nd to none! The food was SO FRESH! My wife and I celebrated our anniversary last night with dinner at Fortino’s Tavern. Saying that it’s the best would be an understatement. It’s just that good!

I rarely write reviews but this place is a true gem. One of the main reasons I return to Greenport. It is hidden and truly magical. The owners are super nice and invested in their business. But besides that - the ambiance and the food is some of the best I have tried. You cannot go wrong with anything. Must try!!!

My wife and I recently dined here for the first time and we loved it. We booked a table online, which was seamless and very convenient. We got there a bit early, but the staff was very kind and let us be seated early. We ate outside and the atmosphere was incredible. You're literally on the water. We had some drinks and lobster rolls. Everything was amazing. We will definitely come back when we're in the area.

Fabulous appetizers, dinner and cocktails. Staff was like family…extremely warm, friendly and very attentive. Peaceful setting. Water view was amazing. Absolutely will be back! Delish!! A MUST go to fine restaurant!

Absolutely loved everything about the place. The food was over the top amazing, delicious and the service was fantastic. The staff was very attentive, supported each other and intent on making sure you had impeccable service. All of this while you dinned on tables on the dock under the stars. The combination of great food, amazing service and wonderful ambiance makes this a must visit restaurant and one of the best restaurants in all of the whole Hamptons.

This is a place you’re gonna come back to. Beautiful view on the water. The food was cooked with such skill and passion, the head chef knows how to perfectly put the flavors together. 10 out of 10! Highly recommend. The service and staff were amazing!!!

Enjoyed dinner here during an impromptu trip to Greenport. Outdoor dining does not get any better than this—you’re literally over the water, with amazing views of shelter island, sun shining and a gentle breeze. The hand rolled pappardelle pasta was amazing. The striped bass was fresh and perfectly seasoned and cooked. Short rib was tender and flavorful. Friendly and attentive service. An excellent dining experience, a must try when you’re on the north fork!

We had such a memorable experience here at Frontino's that we could not remain quiet. The entire establishment was top tier. The food was excellent and the service was great. The one thing was their bathroom was just, ok. I expected better. Overall brilliant!

Cozy restaurant with delicious appetizers and mains. Loved the mussels!

Highly recommend.

This place was delicious, at the suggestion of one of the barmaid in town, try the mushroom parpadelle its a small plate and it was perfect, we then split the lobster roll that comes with a side of this fabulous tortellini salad and it was the best I've ever had, so good cant wait for our next vacation to go back.

I rarely post reviews but this restaurant was phenomenal! Went for our anniversary and the food, staff and setting could not be improved upon. Already looking forward to returning because we didn't have room to try everything!

This place is great. Amazing food, awesome views and great service, love watching a game in the bar too!

Absolutely the most unbelievable food in the world. I come to this restaurant every Monday for the best steak I have ever eaten, the corn bread is to die for and the service is unmatched! Bartender makes the best drinks! Five stars is not enough for this place highly recommended.

Food was delicious & the service was amazing!! Highly recommend the chefs tasting menu. Definitely will be back.

Such a true welcoming feel. It’s owner operated which only makes it better as well. The attention to guests needs is above and beyond and they seem to strive to make accommodations for everyone to have the best experience. They will make things right for you if something is off. Fantastic place!

Food was very good. We sat inside with well spacing between tables. It was a little too cold to sit outside that night. Service was good attentive and not overwhelming. We shared a watermelon salad. Very good. I had a veal chop special, my wife had the pasta. Everything was terrific. I think that they are staying just for the season but not positive about that. If so I hope that they will be back next year.

Fantastic food and service !!!
Love this restaurant- will be back!
The lumberjack salad was delicious and the cod with pumpkin risotto, acorn squash and broccolini was amazing.
My husbands steak was one of the best he ever had, cooked to perfection.
Great night, friendly staff!

Amazing food with great service and owner Nikki makes you always feel welcomed