New City Pizza

New City Pizza is probably my favorite pizza in the New York area — the pizza is amazing and it tastes exactly how I remember as a little kid. It has a unique flavor, the slices are a decent size, the crust is tasty and they put lots of cheese and sauce on the regular slices, which is the difference maker in my opinion. A crispy thin crust balanced with toppings.

That being said, they are / have become somewhat expensive and sometimes the pizza is a little more well-done than you might like; I personally like a crispy crust but I’ve taken other people here who thought it was a bit burnt. Tell them how you want it and you won’t be disappointed

There’s plenty of tables, TVs, drinks and ice cream in the back

New City Pizza is an exceptional 5-star pizza place that truly stands out for its remarkable customer service and outstanding food quality. The staff goes above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience, making you feel welcomed and valued from the moment you walk in. Their pizzas are a true delight, with fresh ingredients and a perfect balance of flavors that keep you coming back for more. Overall, New City Pizza is a must-visit for anyone craving top-notch pizza and impeccable service

They have this cute little section called C.R.E.A.M. bar and it’s abbreviated for, cereal rules everything around me. Super cool! I was hitting the road back home to Jersey from one of the marinas and wanted a slice.

The grandma pie was amazing!!! I took three slices to go and I enjoyed every bite, my dog enjoyed his slice as well 😊 I loved every chunk of tomato and basil I found. Will definitely be heading back when I’m in the area. I’d say it’s better then NYC margs and grandma slices I’ve had.

My Pepperoni Sicilian was absolutely delicious 😋 such flavor and the crispy crust… 😋 service was great, friendly efficient staff. Can’t wait to try this place again’ 🍕

Loved this place! The pizza it’s so delicious, with fresh ingredients and well seasoned. The Chicken Ranch was awesome and the garlic nots are really good. Excellent service and very nice atmosphere.

VodkaRita is probably the best pizza I had in years. Service was great, manager very professional. Overall a great experience. I will def go back ASAP

New City Pizza has the best staff, pizza and entree's. They are our go to place at least twice a week.

Always excellent food, quality service and friendly staff. Both a clean and welcoming establishment also. Highly recommended.

Good pizza and selection. But specialty pizza is expensive. Over $16 for 3 slices to go? Otherwise, all good. A large pepperoni pie, $22 after tax, is super tasty!!

best pizza in Rockland nothing even comes close ! Best pizza has to be grandma

Outstanding pizza – perfect crust, fresh toppings, and a cozy vibe. A must-try!

very nice environment, made me feel very welcomed and the pizza was top tier, I recommend.

Even with new owners, still the best slice in New City. New location, new faces and the same great pizza

The decor in this pizzeria is dope. As a huge hip hop addict, I can appreciate the love for hip hop in this pizzeria. Spoke to the manager real quick as he was busy, but despite being busy he was cool enough to chat for a bit about his store and decor. Gave him his props and went on my way. Pizza was great by the way as well as his staff who seemed to really like working there. Always a great sign. Great job guys!

I had a great experience here! Food was amazing and customer service was excellent!

Having bought myself an outdoor pizza maker and after a lifetime of tasting pizza all over New York City, Rockland County and the Jersey shore, I understand that there are many variables that impact how a pizza tastes. The flour, water content and humidity, the sauce and cheese quality not to mention the ovens and the quality. I like toppings of meats and extra cheese as much as the next guy, but to me, the purest bite is the plain slice. I had one just the other day at 11 am. It was brought to the table hot and I burned the roof of my mouth just a bit- a sign of a good smelling slice you just can't wait to eat. The cheese with hints of olive oil, oregano, basil reached my mouth and taste buds simultaneously while my teeth bit through a firmly crisped dough. This was cooked perfectly leaving the pizza with a great chew that blended with the cheese and filled my mouth with that satisfying flavor and texture. A bottle of cold Root Beer cooled my mouth down. I've also had meatball heroes and veal parm heroes here and they are both well done and satisfying. They also have an ice cream area where you can mix and match flavors with toppings and while I've been very tempted, I have yet to give in to temptation. If the pizza and heroes are any indication of the quality of the rest of the menu, you cant go wrong picking anything on the menu. As the Terminator says, "I'll be back...)

Exactly what you would hope to find when you walk into a NY pizza place. Great pizza. I had a Sicilian corner slice, one of my favorites. Crust was well done and crispy, sheese was melty and delicious.

Excellent pizza and service! What more can you ask for?

Best Pizza in Rockland, but I also recommend the heroes. I love the Arthur Ave.

Just ordered a 1/2 pepperoni and 1/2 buffalo pie for the family. Both were generously topped, and very tasty. Also, staff was courteous and friendly -both on the phone and in person. Pie slices were a bit smaller than other pizzarias we have been to, but the quality more than made up. Will be going again!