Pleasantville Pizzeria

The best plain pie in Westchester, hands down. Similar to Johnnys in Mt Vernon, but better

George is The Pizza man. I don't think I have ever met some so dedicated to many such a tasty pizza. And this is for the last 25-30 years... Amazing. Such dedication 🌞

Nice regular NY style thin crust pizza and good calzones. They only have 3-4 individual slices and mostly sell whole pies (at $20 ish a large pie, 25+ options). Friendly staff, good amount of indoor and outdoor seating.

They also have gluten free and cauliflower bases. Additionally they sell Italian ices, calzones, heros, wedges, salads etc. There is a $15 minimum for free delivery in Pleasantville.

The pizza crust was pretty good and had a nice crunch while staying chewy. The sauce did need some help from the condiments to make it more flavorful. The calzone was packed with cheese and was definitely worth the $6.

Very good Pizza made with attention to detail. Eat in or take out.

Very kind owner, great calzone & pizza

Best pizza in Westchester. Crispy crunchy crust, the best sauce and tasty rolls too. They deliver in a flash.

This is the best pizza in the area, delicious 👏👍

I am a long time pizza aficionado born and bred in Brooklyn, and I love the pizza here. Whenever I am nearby I make sure to stop in for a slice. I'm not sure what makes the pizza here great, but I am guessing it is a combination of the wheat flour, kneading and leavening, the cheese, and lots of love. Definitely what I remember from my childhood days in Brooklyn. It's a small takeout with limited seating inside and some additional seating outside, right next to the train station. Plenty of parking. Enjoy!

Great pizza! Been here a few times on my break. The owner is very nice good personality & always shows respect to customers.

Perfect thin NY slice with delicious sauce and cheese, plus the top dog in the kitchen, George, is a real genuine, friendly guy. Best pizza in Westchester that I've tried and could easily go toe to toe with a city slice any day of the week.

Best pizza in the area by far, and my family has tried them all.

This might just be the best pizzeria in Mt. Pleasant. Sicilian is top notch, but hard to call in an order past 7:30/8 as they seem to leave early. Worth it to keep trying.

Live in Katonah for forty years had your pizza for the first time yesterday. Outstanding pie. My only complaint is you are not located in Katonah. But it certainly won’t be the last time I have your pie. Outstanding

Really good pizza and great service. Deserves it's high ratings.

Delicious pizza on our road trip!!!

This is the best pizza around, wonderful authentic sauce and the crust is perfect!! My favorite is the thin sicilian. "Thank you George, you're the best and so is your pizza"

I’ve been going here for 30 years. My family travels in from around the country for this pizza.

I never had pizza like what I just ate most amazing pizza the quality of the service and even the Pizza Man’s name is George unbelievable you will enjoy your pizza you must visit it posting it right now

Best pizza on earth always and forever, been getting slices here since I was a kid. George is the GOAT.

Love their pizza. Great service and always friendly.