HMC

Pearl Restaurant & Bar

Restaurant in Shelter Island

Updated: March 13, 2024 07:01 AM

Pearl Restaurant & Bar is located in Shelter Island (Town in New York State), United States. It's address is 409 Main St, Greenport, NY 11944.

409 Main St, Greenport, NY 11944

4J3R+H2 Greenport, New York

(631) 333-2888

pearlrestaurantbargreenport.com

pearlrestaurantbargreenport.com

Check Time Table for Pearl Restaurant & Bar


Monday12 AM to 8 PM
TuesdayClosed
Wednesday5 to 9 PM
ThursdayClosed
Friday3 to 10 PM
Saturday3 to 10 PM
Sunday3 to 8 PM

Questions & Answers


Where is Pearl Restaurant & Bar?

Pearl Restaurant & Bar is located at: 409 Main St, Greenport, NY 11944.

What is the phone number of Pearl Restaurant & Bar?

You can try to calling this number: (631) 333-2888

What are the coordinates of Pearl Restaurant & Bar?

Coordinates: 41.1039466, -72.3598785

Pearl Restaurant & Bar Reviews

Lindsey Shellman
2023-09-12 19:00:26 GMT

We loved this spot. We shared a ton of appetizers for date night dinner (our hack to try a larger range of the menu, versus getting main courses) and everything was delicious. Great spot, we’ll be back.

**adding new comments: this has now become our favorite spot in greenport and we visit every weekend that we are there. A true SCRATCH KITCHEN. yes, that means 100% everything is made from scratch. I want this place to become so popular but always have a table for me! We

Tracie Onufrak
2021-08-22 00:24:38 GMT

Tonight’s dinner was so amazing I hope more people find this hidden gem “Pearl”
Jess, the Chef, puts her heart and soul in her food. Everything was off the charts amazing! I didn’t even know a Burrata and Tomatoes could be so amazing. I had the home made Ricotta Gnocchi, which was pillows of heaven! My husband had the meatballs which are melt in your mouth deliciousness.
Cocktail list is awesome also
And dessert didn’t disappoint.

Tonia G
2024-01-18 13:37:38 GMT

Quiet winter evening & we were lucky enough to choose Pearl for a late dinner. Jessi greeted us and then single handedly created an evening we woke up thinking about. It was a slow evening so it was just us three ladies there, and Jessi there who graciously made fabulous dirty martinis & prepared our entire meal. The shrimp & chive dumplings were delicious and the wings were excellent, truly my favorite; crispy and juicy with the right amount of heat. The Korean BBQ Ssam Board with Short Rib lettuce wraps was so much fun and each of the accompaniments were fantastic. The service was wonderful, thank you Jessi !

Barbara dickerson
2021-09-09 15:54:10 GMT

We were greeted with two glasses of sparkling wine as the owner knew it was our Anniversary!! The Caesar salad was outstanding! Best I have ever had! And enough to share!!! My husband had the burger which was hands down the best ever!! My gnocchi was great! Light and fluffy and delicious. The wine
Great as well. This certainly is a restaurant NOT to be missed. The service was top notch as was the atmosphere ❤❤❤❤❤

Matthew Keith
2024-02-05 00:27:00 GMT

Sunday night, winter in a summer town and the food was incredible. Every taste and texture was thought out. The tilt to Korean with American dishes was unique. 5 people all left 100% satisfied. The bulgoki beef sandwich on special multigrain bread (like a Korean version of shaved steak) and triple cooked fries was to die for.

Elias Aliprandis
2023-12-31 02:04:17 GMT

What an outstanding Greenport restaurant! This was my second time dining at Pearl with my family. The first time was years ago, and the cuisine was more traditional for Greenport. To my pleasant surprise, the menu offerings this time were mostly Korean-inspired. The result was delicious. We had the Japchae with chicken, and the Korean BBQ board, as well as the scallion pancake, the short ribs, and pork dumplings. We consumed everything with zeal. The staff are wonderful people and I love the family environment of this restaurant. Will return again, very satisfied!

Phaedra Thomas
2021-08-05 00:28:19 GMT

Everything cooked to perfection. Family loved the burger and were in awe of the French Fries. The meatballs were phenomenal with exquisite burrata. My daughter loved the gnocchi. Warm and friendly service. The ambience is perfect and the decor is tasteful and beautiful. Highly recommend.

Jasen Mendoza
2023-12-18 08:25:09 GMT

First class all the way. Jennifer and her staff were amazing. Jesse was great behind the bar and made us feel at home. I love open kitchen concept and the decor of the entire restaurant! I can’t wait to go back.

V A
2021-07-25 12:58:35 GMT

Jessica can cook. I just went in to try a great burger. It was huge , medium, perfect. The hand cut fries were amazing. I did start with the crab cake. Guess what? It had fresh crab meat and lots of it.. I would put it up against Maryland anyway. I was just recently on Maryland shore so this I know.
John her husband tends that beautiful bar. This was called a blue crush. So good ,addictive.
BTW the Caesar salad you must have. The croutons are large ,fresh n tasty. I get it, croutons are typically day old bread but how Jessica arrived at this , nice

Sheri Winter Parker
2021-08-08 11:52:31 GMT

Pearl is #AMAZING Full Stop. You have got to try this jewel when you are in Greenport. Whether it’s a cocktail or the food, the atmosphere, you will be so thankful you did!!
Hands down one of our absolute all time favorite places.
And as a bonus, John and Jess are incredible proprietors.. John mans the font of the house and the bar like the pro he is and Jess is a #rockstar chef.
This is a must go to!

Patrick Hernandez
2023-12-09 16:25:51 GMT

We stumbled upon Pearl when visiting Greenport and were so happy we did. Every dish was delicious, the wine selection was ON POINT, and the owner knew what’s up.

Betty Butler
2023-06-20 20:59:06 GMT

My husband I went to pearl on Father’s Day for a late afternoon drink and appetizers. The service was outstanding and the appetizers were as well. Our young bartender attended carefully to our order. The bar and dining room are spotless and well appointed. We live in Greenport but this was our first visit. We had mussels and chicken wings. I give it my highest recommendation. Try it you won’t be disappointed.

Lori D
2023-06-03 00:17:16 GMT

A bunch of us went to Pearl for dinner. We ordered every appetizer, all which were fabulous! Some of us ordered our own meal (cheeseburgers!) the rest shared plates (Korean Fried Chicken Wings, dumplings, Blue Lump Crab Cakes, Korean BBQ Ssam, Truffle Mushroom Spinach Grilled Cheese.) The group was beyond impressed with the delicious food!!!!

The food, service, and atmosphere were splendid - as is their cocktails and wine list! We didn't feel rushed while we chatted, laughed, and enjoyed every bite of food AND our cocktails!!!

We cannot wait to get back to Pearl!

Jack Tulley
2021-07-05 16:23:14 GMT

We had a absolutely delicious dinner last night. The presentation was great and it tasted even better then it looked. The crab cakes were done to perfection. Lightly crispy on the outside and moist and flaky on the inside. My main course was the sea bass and it was perfect too. I shared some with my wife, but after I took my first bite I wanted her shared piece back, it was that so flavorful. Great selection of wines and inventive cocktails. A really great find. I hope it’s around for a long time. It’s menu is limited at the moment since they are just opening up, but that shouldn’t stop anyone from going. The decor is very nice too. Very comfortable seating. Best of luck to the owners, John and his wife , the chef, Jessica.

Howard Silverman
2023-12-12 22:13:59 GMT

We had our holiday dinner here and Jess and staff outdid themselves. The food was fantastic. I can't thank Jess enough.

Rob McCormick
2022-07-19 22:56:46 GMT

Pearl is a gem nestled in Greenport. The amount of detail incorporated throughout the restaurant is astonishing (custom pearl wall paint & hand painted shells). The decor isn’t the only thing that draws you in, the aroma is simply delicious. Jess cooks every meal with love and passion. I look forward to returning regularly so I can continue to try every entree. The prime dry aged cheeseburger and mussels are some of my favorite plates. If you are looking for a delicious menu made with quality ingredients look no further.

shannon clifford
2023-07-17 15:37:03 GMT

Been meaning to get to this place as the photos I have seen looked amazing. We finally made it last night and the food did not disappoint. We loved the sweet and sour chicken and the fries.

Marc Bean
2021-08-29 01:42:05 GMT

My family and I had an amazing meal and experience last night. The North Fork has upped its culinary game but Pearl’s food was the best we’ve had by far (and most varied)...the cheeseburger, ribs, meatballs, crab cake, gnocchi and mussels were all exceptional tasting and artfully prepared. The service was impeccable and vibe, a combo of discerning locals and an almost urban scene. The team of Jess and John are very well coordinated, divide and conquer and have tremendous pride in their customer’s experience. Can’t wait to come back and try new dishes.

Anabelle
2021-08-28 15:41:18 GMT

Really nice restaurant!! The inside is beautiful and comforting and the food is very good. You can tell the owners really put a lot of thought into their restaurant and love to engage with the customers. We tried a wide assortment of foods from the chef (once a private chef, developed an excellent menu) and were impressed with every dish. Again, everything from the food to the service to the ambiance was great - it kind of felt like a well-orchestrated show. A must-go while in Greenport or really the New York area.

Joseph Sikora
2020-12-10 00:17:40 GMT

I wish they would post more pictures. Because the interior is stunning. The food is incredible. I mean REALLY incredible. Chef Jessica is stellar and nice. Every course that we ordered was better than the next. Their liquor and beer selection is on point and we will definitely be coming back every time we visit the area.

Write a review of Pearl Restaurant & Bar


Pearl Restaurant & Bar Directions
About Shelter Island
Town in New York State

Shelter Island is an island town in Suffolk County, New York, United States, near the eastern end of Long Island. The population was 3,253 at the 2020 United States census. source

Top Rated Addresses in Shelter Island