Johnny Manhattan's

We enjoyed a very good dinner here. Spiedini, prime rib, scallops, and a rack of ribs were our main dishes.
Like all restaurants today, quite expensive at $76 per person, but our waitress Laura provided exemplary service and the food was delicious.
The atmosphere and setting here is wonderful as well. Definitely will be back!

Incredibly lavish, yet enticing place. Top shelf service, decor that stuns and soothes, and they serve best Manhattan on earth.

Party of 4 adults and 3 kids. Food was amazing. The atmosphere is awesome. Our server Rachel did a fantastic job. I couldn't believe the amount of choices on the menu. They have everything from affordable fried chicken dinners to high end surf and turf. I wish I lived closer so I would eat there more often. 10/10 highly recommend and will absolutely be back.

Delicious environment and absolutely perfect meal. We started with bread and oil, salads, and filet mignon and porkchops. The steak was cooked to perfection at medium rare with a perfect sear. The waitress recommended one broiled and one breaded pork chop. Absolutely the way to do it.

The strawberry and peach pear was very tasty, if a bit too sweet. Caesar salad was one of the best we've had.

One of the best Filets I’ve ever eaten. Great food, great drinks, great atmosphere.

The entire experience was amazing. Bartender was great- the brandy old fashioned sweets were make perfectly ,Hostesses were very friendly and attentive. Our server Kelly L was phenomenal. I looked forward to every interaction with her because of how committed, engaged, funny and kind she was. She said the owner and management treat their staff great and they are happy to work there.Bravo 👏🏼. Every staff member you saw was working diligently with cheer. The filet was cooked perfectly. Escargot and crab cakes were perfect. Even the salad dressings were great- I recommend the creamy garlic. I cannot say enough wonderful things about the entire experience and look forward to going back. Thank you thank you thank you!!!

Beautifully decorated for the holidays. Excellent service and ambience. Food was a little pricey, but worth it. Rib eye cooked to perfection, incredible jumbo shrimp, huge portion of delicious chicken alfredo and the best mudslide I've ever had. Definitely will be back!!

First off , The Restaurant is Absolutely Beautiful inside with all its Wood Furnishings. It was my Girlfriend’s and I’s First Visit. Our Waitress ( Abby T ) was A+++++++, My Girlfriend had Fettuccine Alfredo which she Loved , I Had NY Strip and Baked Potato Which was Absolutely Perfect. We are already planning our next visit their with my Nephews (My one Nephew is who recommended It to Us ) to Sample there Friday Fish Fry.

We absolutely LOVED our dinner at Johnny Manhattan's. Ambiance was 12 out of 10. So nice and a perfect atmosphere to set the stage for an incredible dinner. We worked with manager Debbie for a group of 9 and she set us up in a private room which was incredible. Our server Nicole was perfection start to finish. Very sweet and attentive without being intrusive. She was lovely. The food was delightful and beyond any expectations. From the broiled pork chops to the weekly special scallops to NY strip to the mushrooms and au gratin potatoes. Everything was cooked to perfection and delicious. This was a first time visit for our entire group and we all will be returning again and again! This rates alongside the finest steakhouses in Milwaukee. We had the most perfect experience and cannot wait for our next meal! Thank you!!

Third dinner at Johnny Manhattan's, our welcome to New Year! We / I loving our trips to eat here. I had filet min. And wife had the salmon. Bourbon old fashions top notch. This is a special place great food, service, ambience that is hard to beat!

Great atmosphere and great people. Staff was very friendly and server was excellent! We had our 2 year old with us and they loved her. The food was cooked to perfection and steak melted in our mouths. Great experience. Definitely coming back.

My wife and I went to another restaurant for our anniversary but had a very bad experience (never ended up eating). On our way home at about 6:30 in the evening we called Johnny Manhattans to see if we could get a table at such late notice on a Saturday night. We talked with Katelyn (the hostess) and told her our story, she was awesome! She said she needed to put me on hold while she figured out how she could squeeze us in. A few minutes later she came back with several options, and we told her we would be there in 15 minutes. When we got there, we were seated almost immediately and had a truly great meal. I had the ribeye with French onion soup and my wife had the lamb, both excellent choices. Our waiter (I forgot his name) was excellent also, he helped to make the whole experience fun and entertaining.

Great service and lively place complete with well done Christmas displays. Nice building and ample parking. Bathroom could use more light. Once the stall door is closed the one lightbu the sink isn't enough. The rest of my party enjoyed the lobster and steaks. For dietary reasons I needed to stick to salad that night which were little more than iceberg lettuce and a single grape tomato. One shave of brussel sprout. Realizing the focus are the meat dishes but it's 2024 in a few short days...there are many more who may come in a party or as a guest who don't/can't eat meat....and it's not that difficult or expensive to have a decent salad. There is one meatless pasta which was an option but I could not have heavy food that day. So did not enjoy not having a true dinner salad but everyone else was happy and waitstaff were great so still giving 5 stars.

Very upscale bar on a country drive. Food was delicious.

First time there. The inside is beautiful, finished with local hand-carved wood. The atmosphere is pretty relaxed/casual. The wine selection is huge! Good assortment of craft beers on tap as well as bottled. Large bourbon and other liquor choices. And the specialty mixed drinks are delicious. The service was fast and attentive and the food delicious! They have indoor and outdoor seating (we were inside). The prices were a touch higher, but not ridiculous, especially given the quality of the food, etc. I recommend checking them out. I plan to go back to try the steak they're known for (we went Italian tonight)!

Fantastic Steakhouse! Great selection of wine and spirits. The ambiance was perfect and the food was terrific. I took my meal at the bar which is what I prefer when I eat alone. Jen had the perfect amount of sass and conversation while being on top of the perfect service I received. Also had a nice conversation with Debbie. The entire experience made me feel very comfortable and at home. Highly recommend!

We had a wonderful date night out at Johnny Manhattans. Made a reservation on open table, several days in advanced, and were seated within minutes of our reservation time. Our waitress was very friendly, prompt, knowledgable and made great recommendations. Be sure to get the house dressing with your salad. We had a New York strip and the large filet, both cooked perfectly to order and had wonderful flavor. The new au gratin potatoes and Chocolate mouse cake were fantastic. Food and ambiance is a 10/10 must visit.

Excellent food and atmosphere. Head straight for a steak order. I ordered the Prime rib, but nothing beats the steaks. The drinks are punch you in the face, strong.

So…I find this place intimidating due to how fancy it is inside. The food was to die for, but not a fun atmosphere. Sign says “Classy but Casual”. I found it more classy than casual. I used to work close by, and during the height of the covid epidemic, they had movies in the parking lot and delivered food to your car with masks on. It looked so fun. Gotta love ‘em.

Best dinner I have had in a while. Delicious food, beautiful ambiance and fantastically crafted cocktails. The wine list is very extensive and our service was impeccable. I would highly recommend reserving the wine cellar room for your future 10-20 people gatherings. The specials were amazing also. My favorites were the ahi tuna and calamari appetizer. Do not skip dessert. The berry marcapone cake was unforgettable.