Carol Ann's Pizza LLC

First time pizza pick up order at Carol Ann’s. We are new to the area and decided to give this pizzeria a go. We were told 30 minutes and our pizza would be ready. We had a little drive to get there from Jackson, but our friendly order taker said no problem, we will keep it hot right on top of our oven. It was so! Arrived to find a friendly face and our pizza ready. We ordered DICED onions and green peppers (not sliced) as well as black olives and pepperoni. It was prepared exactly as we asked, and done to perfection! I wish we would have taken a pic, because this ‘Za looked as good as it tasted. Not too much cheese, not too much sauce. (My wife likes a lot of cheese, and I like more sauce). The crust was delicious and tasted home made. Perhaps a pinch more salt would benefit, but that is splitting hairs. We will definitely be back. Thanks Carol Ann’s for good service and a great pizza!

Pizza's are always delicious and they offer several options so you can be as creative as you want. Also love their salads and broccoli cheddar bites.

Ordered from here about 5 times now and it has always been excellent. Employees are pleasant and give accurate pick up times over the phone.

Always a Great place whenever I have been there. Food has always been good. Unfortunately this past weekend they didn't have fish for Friday fish dinners. But We shifted gears for some other great tasting options.

We have never been inside to dine but the delivery service is very good and the pizza is to die for. Definitely worth any out of your way drive to sample one of WI best pizzas. We highly recommend 👌

The pizza and cheese bread were great.

These people are the best. So nice. After a couple times there they treat me like I've been going there for years. They know your name and when you order they know who it is before you tell them. The owner ( I think his name is Jeff) is the nicest guy ever and the pretty young lady that works there is sweet too. I would suggest this place even if the pizza was awful but it's really good. I love this place.

I'm from Chicago and was working in the area. I ordered a large pizza and Italian sausage sandwich. Both excellent. Love how the pizza crust is crunchy. The Italian sausage sandwich is the same sausage they put on pizza but they pack it together into a patty. Delivery came in about an hour as they said it would. Will order again next time in this area!!!

My husband has tried the pizza here and was excited for me to try for my first experience with Carol Ann’s Pizza. This is a new style of pizza, and I have never had anything quite like this. We had a small pizza, regular crust, mushrooms and cheese. The sauce was a perfect balance, the crust was sturdy and held the rest of the ingredients as a crispy crust that did not fold or collapse while eating. As the safer at home ordinance was still in place, we decided to take a drive and knew when we called in the order, we were just going to enjoy the pizza in our vehicle. When I entered the restaurant, everything was clean and minimal. The young lady at the counter was super friendly, smiled, and was professional. I asked about paper plates and they had already made little packages of plates and napkins to go for a small extra charge. Unfortunately they only had caffeinated soda and no water, but that was not a problem as the gas station was across the road. This pizza was soooooo delicious! I enjoyed every bite and stopped myself after three little pieces so as not to pig out and eat more than I should!😂 So impressed and looking forward to visiting again soon! This is definitely a little gem! Thank you to the cooks, staff, and ownership! You are doing a phenomenal job!💜💜

We got the bbq chicken and a pepperoni and sausage thin crust pizza, as well as the onion strings and cheesy bread. Everything was delicious and their thin crust is my new favorite!! All the staff were friendly and welcoming, despite ordering pretty late. We'll definitely be back!

This place is a hidden gem. We have been looking for a good pizza place ever since we moved to Menomonee Falls a couple of years ago with no success. All the places we used to like have changed, and none for the better. We stumbled upon Carol Ann's one night and were very pleasantly surprised. They have excellent pizza! The pizza and appetizers were great!! The people were extremely friendly, and prices were very reasonable!! This is probably going to be our go to pizza place out here from now on!!

Carol Ann's has consistently good quality food and excellent, courteous staff and delivery people. We love their supreme thin crust pizza and have recently tried their Friday fish fry. Great job Carol Ann's! We'll be coming back again and again.

Honestly ruined a lot of other pizza for me. The sauce is amazing and love the crust it's thin but not to thin and it's always crunchy. Highly recommend its a bit expensive but worth it in my book. Kids get "fast food" pizza adults get this pizza!!

Local pizza SOOO good. We love their thin crust pizza! delicious sauce, good topping portions, and the jalapeno poppers are *chefs kiss*.

Par-baked or fully baked, their pizzas are fantastic. Carol Ann, gave us a sample of the new fish she will be using for her fish fry starting May 29th. It is out of this world. Try Carol Ann's, you won't be disappointed.

WOW!!!!What a pizza!!! This is my go too pizza place from now on. Best tasting pizza that I have had in a long time.It is worth the drive to me to have a quality pizza that leaves you craving for the next one! Great job Carol Ann's...staff is friendly and personable...a joy to sit down and relax in a cozy environment.

Awesome food! Homemade fries, and friendly staff! Everything I ever tried here was very good.

Excellent pizza!! This is a small place. The amenities are simple and sparse. But the food is great!! I've had many things off the menu and never had bad food!!

I'm a former OTR driver and everytime I went to richfield terminal I would go to Carol anns. The pizza is awesome. Love how they cut it and the ingredients are 👌. Im From texas so this was a pleasant surprise to find. A diamond in the rough for sure.

My Second time at Carol Ann's: This time I took the small, thin crust sausage, mushroom, onion pizza to go on a snowy 15-minute ride home in Mequon. I was worried that the crispy crust I found amazing when I ate in at Carol Ann's would be sub-par when I got the pizza home.
My fears were dispelled, it was amazing, and crispy, even in the end when it got cold.
Needless to say, I ate that pizza (entirely) and cannot comment on leftovers.
If you appreciate the best, fresh, thin crust pizza like I do, Carol Ann's is a dream. You won't be disappointed.